Loading...
10/24/1978 - City Council Regular0 0 MINUTES OF A REGULAR MEETING OF THE ADVISORY PLANNING CO?QSISSIGN EAGAN, MINNESOTA OCTOBER 24, 1978 A regular meeting of the Advisory Planning Commission was held on Tuesday, October 24, 1978, at 7:00 p.m. at the City Hall. Those present were: Chairman Harrison, Bl.omquist, Hall, Roszak, Dembroski and Sperling. Hedtke was absent. Also present were: City Administrator Hedges, City Zoning Administrator Runkle, City Planner Voss, City Engineer Rosene, Public Works Director Colbert and City Attorney Hauge. AGENDA. The Chairman noted that the applications of Dunn b Curry Real Estate Management, Inc. to rezone approximately 80 acres and for preliminary plat appro- val for Beacon Hills South of Cliff Road was requested to be heard at the joint meeting with the City Council. Mr. Rod Hardy, representing the developer, was present and stated the importance of having the matter heard as soon as possible. Roszak moved and Blomquist seconded the motion, with all members voting in favor, to continue to -two public hearings described above to a special meeting to con- sider the applications to be scheduled on October 30, 1978, at 7 p.m. MINUTES, Upon motion duly made and seconded, the minutes of the previous meeting were approved as distributed. ROBERT HIPRINS WAIVER. - WESCOTT GARDEN LOTS. The first public hearing that was convened by the Chairman concerned the application of Robert Hipkins for waiver from platting regulations to split Lot 11.,Block 2, Wescott Garden Lots into two equal lots. Mark Parranto was present representing the applicant. City Zoning Administrator Runkle had indicated in his report, dated October 17th, that the. lot area did not appear to comply with the five acre provision for each of the two remaining lots and that the frontage on Center Street is 298.53 feet or about 1-1/2 feet s,iort of the ordinance requirement. Planning Commission members indicated that the intent of the ordinance appears to be covered and suggested that the staff attempt to work out a proposed solution to the issue. Hall moved to recom- 11 Page 2 OCTOBER 24, 1978 11 mend and Blomquist seconded the moticn, with all members vcting in favor, approval of the application for waiver of subdivision regulations subject, however, to com- pliance with all ordinance requirements, park contribution for the newly created lot, and further, with the understanding that all technicalities will be resolved prior to Council action. There was discussion concerning the possibility of fur- nishing utilities to the property within a very short period of time. WENDELL WIDSTROM CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT - WESCOTT CARDEN LOTS. The next public hearing convened concerned the application of Mr. and Mss. Wendell Widstrom for conditional use permit to permit the parking of three industrial trucks on Agriculturally zoned property. The applicants were not present. They did appear later in the meeting. A number of objecting owners were present and also sub- mitted a petition signed by all other neighboring property owners objecting to the application indicating it is not an appropriate location for a trucking, business. Hall moved and Dembroski seconded the motion to recommend that the ap- plication be denied on the basis of the objections that were submitted and the fact that it did not appear to be an appropriate location for a trucking business use. All members voted in favor. Sperling moved and Dembroski seconded the motion, with all members voting yes, to recommend to the Council that investigation be made with view toward terminating the operation on the Widstrom trucking business. E -Z MINI STORAGE PYLON SIGN The next public hearing that was convened re- garded the application of E -Z Mini Storage for conditional use permit for a pylon sign at the facility located at 4005 Sibley Memorial Highway. Mr. Mery Hoyt of Universal Sign appeared on behalf of the'applicant and requested one 20 -foot high pylon sign on the property. He indicated that there would be no request for an additional pylon sign. Blomquist moved and Dembroski seconded the motion to recommend approval of the sign provided that it meets all applicable ordinance provisions. All members voted yea. 11 Page 3 OCTOBER 24, 1978 RAX ROAST BEEF PYLON SIGN. The hearing regarding the application of Rax Roast Beef for conditional use permit for pylon sign under ordinance No. 16 lo- cated at 3830 Sibley Memorial Highway was next opened. Dale Runkle indicated that he was uncertain whether the location of the proposed sign was within the 300 foot minimum provision from existing signs. No one appeared on behalf of the applicants. Sperling moved and Hall seconded the motion, all members votin� yes, to recommend approval of the permit subject to all ordinance requirements including the 300 foot provision ender Ordinance No. 16. UNION CHEMICAL DIVISION C014DITIONAL USE PERMIT. Chairman Harrison then con- vened the public hearing regarding the application of Union Chemical Division of Union 011 of California for conditional use permit for storage of liquid chemicals on Lot 16, Block 5, Eagandale Center Industrial Park. The local manager of the Union Chemical Division of Minneapolis was also present. Mr. Stinson Bachelor, engineer for Union Chemical, explained the proposal including the distribution center of chemical products. The facility would contain a 30,600 square foot building, and 55 storage tanks that would have a capacity of 500,000 gallons of liquid chemicals. The plan indicates that 33 of the 55 tanks would be underground for a total of 171,000 gallons and 21 tanks above ground for a total of 344,000 gallons. It was understood that the facility would not be refining chemicals, but redistributing and blending about 90% of the chemicals. There were objections from Planning Commission members regarding the proposed use in a I-1 zoned area, including the proximity to residential uses and the other neighboring industrial uses. It was also suggested that an alternate location be sought with the possi- bility of rezoning to I-2, Heavy. Industrial. Sperling moved to continue the hear- ing to the next regular meeting to afford the applicant an opportunity to meet with the staff to consider an alternate site and the possibility of providing for I-2 zoning on the alternate site; further that a written recommendation from the • Page 4 OCTOBER 24, 1978 Fire Departrant and review of the insurance implications on adjacent propertiec be included. Blomquist seconded the motion, all members voted is favor, encept Roszak who doted no, Th: C:(ty Engineer indicated that iZ d.i3 not appear to have an adverse impact cn the can.itary sewer an..'_ sto.r water systems. There would be 7 trucks per day in and out and the tanks above ground would be a maximum 24 feet 4 inches and 12 feet in diameter. In addition, it was requested that the Metropolitan Airport Commission be contacted because the facility lies under a flight pattern. CARL DEVALERIA SUBDIVISION WAIVER - LETENDRE ADDITION. The next public hear- ing regarded the application of Mr. and Mrs. Carl DeValeria who own Lot 10, Block 1, Letendre Addition for waiver of subdivison regulations to provide for split of the lot into two equal parcels. Mr. and Mrs. DeValeria were present and there were no objections. It was noted that assessments have been picked up on each of the adjoining streets. Hall moved and Roszak seconded the motion, all members voted in favor, to recommend approval of the application. RAUENHORST CORPORATION LOTS SPLITS - EAGANDALE CENTER INDUSTRIAL PARR. Chairman Harrison next convened the public hearing regarding the application of Rauenhorst Corporation for waiver from platting regulations to create three lots from five existing platted lots consisting of Lots 33, 34, 35, 4 and 5, Block 2, Eagandale Center Industrial Park. Michele Foster appeared for the applicant. There were no objections to the application. After review of the report of the City Zoning Administrator, Hall moved and Roszak seconded the motion to recommend approval of the application. All members voted yes. LOTS SPLIT - DAKOTA COUNTY RECORDER. It was noted that in the case of the DeValeria property, that a deed had been recorded by the Dakota County Recorder for half of the lot contrary to the State law and City ordinance, to permit the recording. Roszak moved and Hall seconded the motion, all members voted in favor, to recommend that the Council authorize the preparation of a Resolution by the P Page 5 OCTOBER 24, 1978 0 staff and the City Attorney explaining the legal implications and requesting t':at the Cornty Recorder review all deeds for the conveyance of real estate and refuse to record those convaycnces where property a.s laso Lia. five acres and unplatted. 6.'ENDELL WIDSTROM CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT. Mr. and Mrs. Wendell Widstrom appeared and requested that the Planning Ccmmission adopt a motion reconsidering the motion to deny their request for conditional use approval on Lot 3, Block 4, Wescott Garden Lots. There was no motion and, therefore, the matter was forwarded to the City Council. JKR COMPANY PRELININARY PLAT AND PLAN APPROVAL. Chairman Harrison next con- vened the public hearing regarding the application of JKR Company and Kenneth Applebaum for preliminary plat approval and plan approval for community shopping center on a nine acre parcel located at the Northeast quadrant of Pilot Knob Road and Crestridge Drive. The report of City Planner; John Voss, dated October 18, 1978, was reviewed by the Planning Commission. Mr. Robert Karatz, one of the developers, appeared and introduced the representatives of the applicant. Mr. Douglas Moe, architect, explained that the shopping center complex would consist of a 68,800 square foot building on the CSC zoned property with a 14,000 square foot office building on the South 6.2 acre parcel. In addition, there was a pro- vision for -5,000 square foot expansion of the shopping mall. There would be a 40 foot green strip along the Duckwood Drive Northerly boundary of the shopping center. 6.2.acres was within the Pilot Knob Heights Planned Unit Development area and a portion of the CSC zoned property to the North. There was provision for a 495 car parking area with parking generally on the Planned Unit Development property in addition to the office building with the shopping center complex on the CSC zoned property. There was discussion concerning excessive traffic on Crestridge Drive and general safety in the area. Mr. Moe indicated that parking requirements can be met North of the building, to provide for employee parking. The office 0 Pape 6 OCTOBER 24, 1978 0 building would consist of a two story office building with approximately 20 feet in height. It was noted that the fce owner of Pilot Knob Properties had not signed the application and the representative of the o•nsr had indicated that he would sign the application within two days. There was discussion concerning storm water holding areas including Fish Lake. There were a number of objecting neighboring, owners present and also neighboring owners who favored the project. There were questions as to whether the original plan had been denied by the City Council on September 5, 1978, actually differed from the community shopping center concept under the current application. The applicant indicated that the City has asked that Pilot Knob be upgraded and that there would be a right turn in and out.of Crestridge Drive. There was also discussion concerning cross easement parking. Blomquist moved and Roszak seconded the motion to recommend to the City Council that the applications of JKR Company - Kenneth Applebaum for overall plan approval and preliminary plat approval for Eagan Shopping Center be recommended for denial for reasons including the following: 1. The exhibit attached to the Planned Development Agreement for Pilot Knob Heights indicates the 6.2 acre parcel to be used for convenience center and office building providing a less dense and lower commercial use with less potential im- pact on the area than the shopping center proposed. 2. The proposal requires a combination of a 6.2. acre Planned Unit Develop- ment parcel with 10 acres CSC to the North into a single development site which is not allowable without a modification of the Planned Development Agreement which the developer elected not to apply for. 3. The designation on the 6.2 acre site was not revised when the new zoning ordinance code was adopted in 1975 and the designated use under the Pilot Knob Heights Planned Development Agreement does not allow for a large scale shopping center as proposed. • Page 7 OCTOBER 24, 1978 11 4. There is a parcel of property to the North including the 10 acre parcel in the proposed development zoned Community Shopping Center which would provide sufficient large scale shopping facilities in the central portion of Eagan. 5. The proposed development would create excessive commercial development in the general area at the present time given the existing commerical development which could cause economic blight for existing commercial facilities. 6. The Planned Development Agreement appears to allow convenience center and office building uses on the 6.2 acre parcel and the contract should be strictly construed. 7. An additional commercial development of the scale proposed creates exces- sive traffic congestion on the already overburdened Pilot Knob Road - County Road #31, including the intersections of Duckwood Drive and Crestridge Lane with Pilot Knob Road. 8. Additional proposed commercial development would create excessive runoff on the lakes and ponds in the immediate area, which at the present time do not have permanent outlets. 9. The plan of the proposed development appears to provide inadequate park- ing space in accordance with the plans for the commercial shopping center. 10. It appears that the revised plan for the entire shopping center is not substantially different than the plan proposed by the same applicants and denied by the City Council on September 5, 1978. 11. The Planned Development did not provide for parking on the 6.2 acre parcel to be utilized by a shopping center complex outside of the 6.2 acre parcel. After considerable discussion, Sperling moved and Blomquist seconded the motion to move the previous question. All members voted in favor except Roszak who voted no. The Chairman.then requested a vote on the main motion. Those in favor were: Harrison, Sperling„ Roszak, Blomquist and Dembroski. Abstention: Hall. 0 0 Page 8 OCTOBER 24, 1978 WALTER RUZIK VARIANCE. The last public hearing convened by the Chairman concerned the application of Walter Ruzik III for setback variance to build a garage on Lot 1, Block 8, Cedar Grove No. 7. Mr. Ruzik was present and explained the proposal. He indicated that there did not appear to be a setback problem and that a hardship would be created because of the need to change roof lines and also potential water problems if the location of the garage was changed to the rear. Hall moved and Dembroski seconded the motion, all members voted in favor, to recommend approval of the variance according to the recommendations of the Zoning Administrator on the basis of the hardship provisions explained above. OCTOBER 30, 1978, JOINT MEETING. A joint meeting, of the Advisory Planning Commission with the City Council was scheduled for October 30, 1978, at 7 p.m. at the City Hall to discuss issues concerning park land dedication, fire facili- ties and school site dedication by developers, Dayton Hudson Property development issues, etc. ADJOURNMENT. Roszak moved and Sperling seconded the motion, all members voted yea, to adjourn the meeting at 10:05 p.m. DATED: October 24, 1978 City Clerk PHR I 0 0 MINUTES OF A REGULAR MEETING OF THE ADVISORY PLANNING CO?QSISSIGN EAGAN, MINNESOTA OCTOBER 24, 1978 A regular meeting of the Advisory Planning Commission was held on Tuesday, October 24, 1978, at 7:00 p.m. at the City Hall. Those present were: Chairman Harrison, Bl.omquist, Hall, Roszak, Dembroski and Sperling. Hedtke was absent. Also present were: City Administrator Hedges, City Zoning Administrator Runkle, City Planner Voss, City Engineer Rosene, Public Works Director Colbert and City Attorney Hauge. AGENDA. The Chairman noted that the applications of Dunn b Curry Real Estate Management, Inc. to rezone approximately 80 acres and for preliminary plat appro- val for Beacon Hills South of Cliff Road was requested to be heard at the joint meeting with the City Council. Mr. Rod Hardy, representing the developer, was present and stated the importance of having the matter heard as soon as possible. Roszak moved and Blomquist seconded the motion, with all members voting in favor, to continue to -two public hearings described above to a special meeting to con- sider the applications to be scheduled on October 30, 1978, at 7 p.m. MINUTES, Upon motion duly made and seconded, the minutes of the previous meeting were approved as distributed. ROBERT HIPRINS WAIVER. - WESCOTT GARDEN LOTS. The first public hearing that was convened by the Chairman concerned the application of Robert Hipkins for waiver from platting regulations to split Lot 11.,Block 2, Wescott Garden Lots into two equal lots. Mark Parranto was present representing the applicant. City Zoning Administrator Runkle had indicated in his report, dated October 17th, that the. lot area did not appear to comply with the five acre provision for each of the two remaining lots and that the frontage on Center Street is 298.53 feet or about 1-1/2 feet s,iort of the ordinance requirement. Planning Commission members indicated that the intent of the ordinance appears to be covered and suggested that the staff attempt to work out a proposed solution to the issue. Hall moved to recom- 11 Page 2 OCTOBER 24, 1978 11 mend and Blomquist seconded the moticn, with all members vcting in favor, approval of the application for waiver of subdivision regulations subject, however, to com- pliance with all ordinance requirements, park contribution for the newly created lot, and further, with the understanding that all technicalities will be resolved prior to Council action. There was discussion concerning the possibility of fur- nishing utilities to the property within a very short period of time. WENDELL WIDSTROM CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT - WESCOTT CARDEN LOTS. The next public hearing convened concerned the application of Mr. and Mss. Wendell Widstrom for conditional use permit to permit the parking of three industrial trucks on Agriculturally zoned property. The applicants were not present. They did appear later in the meeting. A number of objecting owners were present and also sub- mitted a petition signed by all other neighboring property owners objecting to the application indicating it is not an appropriate location for a trucking, business. Hall moved and Dembroski seconded the motion to recommend that the ap- plication be denied on the basis of the objections that were submitted and the fact that it did not appear to be an appropriate location for a trucking business use. All members voted in favor. Sperling moved and Dembroski seconded the motion, with all members voting yes, to recommend to the Council that investigation be made with view toward terminating the operation on the Widstrom trucking business. E -Z MINI STORAGE PYLON SIGN The next public hearing that was convened re- garded the application of E -Z Mini Storage for conditional use permit for a pylon sign at the facility located at 4005 Sibley Memorial Highway. Mr. Mery Hoyt of Universal Sign appeared on behalf of the'applicant and requested one 20 -foot high pylon sign on the property. He indicated that there would be no request for an additional pylon sign. Blomquist moved and Dembroski seconded the motion to recommend approval of the sign provided that it meets all applicable ordinance provisions. All members voted yea. 11 Page 3 OCTOBER 24, 1978 RAX ROAST BEEF PYLON SIGN. The hearing regarding the application of Rax Roast Beef for conditional use permit for pylon sign under ordinance No. 16 lo- cated at 3830 Sibley Memorial Highway was next opened. Dale Runkle indicated that he was uncertain whether the location of the proposed sign was within the 300 foot minimum provision from existing signs. No one appeared on behalf of the applicants. Sperling moved and Hall seconded the motion, all members votin� yes, to recommend approval of the permit subject to all ordinance requirements including the 300 foot provision ender Ordinance No. 16. UNION CHEMICAL DIVISION C014DITIONAL USE PERMIT. Chairman Harrison then con- vened the public hearing regarding the application of Union Chemical Division of Union 011 of California for conditional use permit for storage of liquid chemicals on Lot 16, Block 5, Eagandale Center Industrial Park. The local manager of the Union Chemical Division of Minneapolis was also present. Mr. Stinson Bachelor, engineer for Union Chemical, explained the proposal including the distribution center of chemical products. The facility would contain a 30,600 square foot building, and 55 storage tanks that would have a capacity of 500,000 gallons of liquid chemicals. The plan indicates that 33 of the 55 tanks would be underground for a total of 171,000 gallons and 21 tanks above ground for a total of 344,000 gallons. It was understood that the facility would not be refining chemicals, but redistributing and blending about 90% of the chemicals. There were objections from Planning Commission members regarding the proposed use in a I-1 zoned area, including the proximity to residential uses and the other neighboring industrial uses. It was also suggested that an alternate location be sought with the possi- bility of rezoning to I-2, Heavy. Industrial. Sperling moved to continue the hear- ing to the next regular meeting to afford the applicant an opportunity to meet with the staff to consider an alternate site and the possibility of providing for I-2 zoning on the alternate site; further that a written recommendation from the • Page 4 OCTOBER 24, 1978 Fire Departrant and review of the insurance implications on adjacent propertiec be included. Blomquist seconded the motion, all members voted is favor, encept Roszak who doted no, Th: C:(ty Engineer indicated that iZ d.i3 not appear to have an adverse impact cn the can.itary sewer an..'_ sto.r water systems. There would be 7 trucks per day in and out and the tanks above ground would be a maximum 24 feet 4 inches and 12 feet in diameter. In addition, it was requested that the Metropolitan Airport Commission be contacted because the facility lies under a flight pattern. CARL DEVALERIA SUBDIVISION WAIVER - LETENDRE ADDITION. The next public hear- ing regarded the application of Mr. and Mrs. Carl DeValeria who own Lot 10, Block 1, Letendre Addition for waiver of subdivison regulations to provide for split of the lot into two equal parcels. Mr. and Mrs. DeValeria were present and there were no objections. It was noted that assessments have been picked up on each of the adjoining streets. Hall moved and Roszak seconded the motion, all members voted in favor, to recommend approval of the application. RAUENHORST CORPORATION LOTS SPLITS - EAGANDALE CENTER INDUSTRIAL PARR. Chairman Harrison next convened the public hearing regarding the application of Rauenhorst Corporation for waiver from platting regulations to create three lots from five existing platted lots consisting of Lots 33, 34, 35, 4 and 5, Block 2, Eagandale Center Industrial Park. Michele Foster appeared for the applicant. There were no objections to the application. After review of the report of the City Zoning Administrator, Hall moved and Roszak seconded the motion to recommend approval of the application. All members voted yes. LOTS SPLIT - DAKOTA COUNTY RECORDER. It was noted that in the case of the DeValeria property, that a deed had been recorded by the Dakota County Recorder for half of the lot contrary to the State law and City ordinance, to permit the recording. Roszak moved and Hall seconded the motion, all members voted in favor, to recommend that the Council authorize the preparation of a Resolution by the P Page 5 OCTOBER 24, 1978 0 staff and the City Attorney explaining the legal implications and requesting t':at the Cornty Recorder review all deeds for the conveyance of real estate and refuse to record those convaycnces where property a.s laso Lia. five acres and unplatted. 6.'ENDELL WIDSTROM CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT. Mr. and Mrs. Wendell Widstrom appeared and requested that the Planning Ccmmission adopt a motion reconsidering the motion to deny their request for conditional use approval on Lot 3, Block 4, Wescott Garden Lots. There was no motion and, therefore, the matter was forwarded to the City Council. JKR COMPANY PRELININARY PLAT AND PLAN APPROVAL. Chairman Harrison next con- vened the public hearing regarding the application of JKR Company and Kenneth Applebaum for preliminary plat approval and plan approval for community shopping center on a nine acre parcel located at the Northeast quadrant of Pilot Knob Road and Crestridge Drive. The report of City Planner; John Voss, dated October 18, 1978, was reviewed by the Planning Commission. Mr. Robert Karatz, one of the developers, appeared and introduced the representatives of the applicant. Mr. Douglas Moe, architect, explained that the shopping center complex would consist of a 68,800 square foot building on the CSC zoned property with a 14,000 square foot office building on the South 6.2 acre parcel. In addition, there was a pro- vision for -5,000 square foot expansion of the shopping mall. There would be a 40 foot green strip along the Duckwood Drive Northerly boundary of the shopping center. 6.2.acres was within the Pilot Knob Heights Planned Unit Development area and a portion of the CSC zoned property to the North. There was provision for a 495 car parking area with parking generally on the Planned Unit Development property in addition to the office building with the shopping center complex on the CSC zoned property. There was discussion concerning excessive traffic on Crestridge Drive and general safety in the area. Mr. Moe indicated that parking requirements can be met North of the building, to provide for employee parking. The office 0 Pape 6 OCTOBER 24, 1978 0 building would consist of a two story office building with approximately 20 feet in height. It was noted that the fce owner of Pilot Knob Properties had not signed the application and the representative of the o•nsr had indicated that he would sign the application within two days. There was discussion concerning storm water holding areas including Fish Lake. There were a number of objecting neighboring, owners present and also neighboring owners who favored the project. There were questions as to whether the original plan had been denied by the City Council on September 5, 1978, actually differed from the community shopping center concept under the current application. The applicant indicated that the City has asked that Pilot Knob be upgraded and that there would be a right turn in and out.of Crestridge Drive. There was also discussion concerning cross easement parking. Blomquist moved and Roszak seconded the motion to recommend to the City Council that the applications of JKR Company - Kenneth Applebaum for overall plan approval and preliminary plat approval for Eagan Shopping Center be recommended for denial for reasons including the following: 1. The exhibit attached to the Planned Development Agreement for Pilot Knob Heights indicates the 6.2 acre parcel to be used for convenience center and office building providing a less dense and lower commercial use with less potential im- pact on the area than the shopping center proposed. 2. The proposal requires a combination of a 6.2. acre Planned Unit Develop- ment parcel with 10 acres CSC to the North into a single development site which is not allowable without a modification of the Planned Development Agreement which the developer elected not to apply for. 3. The designation on the 6.2 acre site was not revised when the new zoning ordinance code was adopted in 1975 and the designated use under the Pilot Knob Heights Planned Development Agreement does not allow for a large scale shopping center as proposed. • Page 7 OCTOBER 24, 1978 11 4. There is a parcel of property to the North including the 10 acre parcel in the proposed development zoned Community Shopping Center which would provide sufficient large scale shopping facilities in the central portion of Eagan. 5. The proposed development would create excessive commercial development in the general area at the present time given the existing commerical development which could cause economic blight for existing commercial facilities. 6. The Planned Development Agreement appears to allow convenience center and office building uses on the 6.2 acre parcel and the contract should be strictly construed. 7. An additional commercial development of the scale proposed creates exces- sive traffic congestion on the already overburdened Pilot Knob Road - County Road #31, including the intersections of Duckwood Drive and Crestridge Lane with Pilot Knob Road. 8. Additional proposed commercial development would create excessive runoff on the lakes and ponds in the immediate area, which at the present time do not have permanent outlets. 9. The plan of the proposed development appears to provide inadequate park- ing space in accordance with the plans for the commercial shopping center. 10. It appears that the revised plan for the entire shopping center is not substantially different than the plan proposed by the same applicants and denied by the City Council on September 5, 1978. 11. The Planned Development did not provide for parking on the 6.2 acre parcel to be utilized by a shopping center complex outside of the 6.2 acre parcel. After considerable discussion, Sperling moved and Blomquist seconded the motion to move the previous question. All members voted in favor except Roszak who voted no. The Chairman.then requested a vote on the main motion. Those in favor were: Harrison, Sperling„ Roszak, Blomquist and Dembroski. Abstention: Hall. 0 0 Page 8 OCTOBER 24, 1978 WALTER RUZIK VARIANCE. The last public hearing convened by the Chairman concerned the application of Walter Ruzik III for setback variance to build a garage on Lot 1, Block 8, Cedar Grove No. 7. Mr. Ruzik was present and explained the proposal. He indicated that there did not appear to be a setback problem and that a hardship would be created because of the need to change roof lines and also potential water problems if the location of the garage was changed to the rear. Hall moved and Dembroski seconded the motion, all members voted in favor, to recommend approval of the variance according to the recommendations of the Zoning Administrator on the basis of the hardship provisions explained above. OCTOBER 30, 1978, JOINT MEETING. A joint meeting, of the Advisory Planning Commission with the City Council was scheduled for October 30, 1978, at 7 p.m. at the City Hall to discuss issues concerning park land dedication, fire facili- ties and school site dedication by developers, Dayton Hudson Property development issues, etc. ADJOURNMENT. Roszak moved and Sperling seconded the motion, all members voted yea, to adjourn the meeting at 10:05 p.m. DATED: October 24, 1978 City Clerk PHR I