DENIED - Zoning Permit 3-26-20243830 PILOT KNOB ROAD I EAGAN, MN 55122-1810 (651) 675-56851 FAX: (651) 675-5694 planning@cityofeagan.com
I Date Received: _____ _
I I Staff: _________ I
, _________________ J
ZONING PERMIT APPLICATION D Please identify improvements on a scaled site plan drawing that shows lot lines, structures, and existing
conditions.
For projects involving significant land disturbance, a Stormwater Management Permit and collection of security may be required.
Property
Information
Site Address:
Owner Name:
Name:
1386 Lone Oak Rd
Erin Gable
Erin Gable Phone: ----------------6512696359
1386 Lone Oak Rd City/State/Zip: _E_a_g_a_n _______ --lContact Address:
Applicant Signature: m� Date: 03/20/2024
Email address: eolenag@gmail.com
□Retaining Wall <4 feet □PatioType of Work o Sidewalk
Description of work: Dock
□Driveway □Sport Court □Fence
□Shed (if over 120 sq.ft.,indicate matching
roof style and exterior materials to
house)□Other: ____ _
Planning Setbacks, hard surface coverage, shoreland zoning, bluff zone/setbacks, etc.
Approved / Denied
Notes:
Revised Plans
Approved: Yes/ No
Date: _______ Staff:
Date: Staff:
Engineering Grading, drainage, utility easements, wetlands, erosion control, improvements in the Right-of-Way, etc.
Approved / Denied
Notes:
Revised Plans
Approved:
Comments
Yes/ No
Date: _______ Staff:
Date: Staff:
Sections 11.65 and 10.24 of the City Code apply and establish the following limits on docks:
5 ft. max width, 60 sq. ft. max area, 20 ft. max length. The proposed dock exceeds both the
60 sq. ft. max area and 20 ft. max length standards. Therefore, we are unable to approve
this permit as presented.
3/26/24
Floating dock by Wave Armor
3 sections are 10’x5’.
Ramp is 7’x5’
Bench on the final section.
This will go where I removed cattails
(got permit for that last year). See
picture below.
Proposed Dock
Width = 5 ft.
Area = 185 sq. ft.
Length = 37 ft.
Proposed dock
exceeds max area and
length standards.
DENIED
3/26/24
Dock will wrap around the cattails.
1
Pam Dudziak
From:Brian Leyendecker
Sent:Monday, March 25, 2024 10:33 AM
To:Pam Dudziak
Cc:Jenna Olson; Julie Strid
Subject:RE: Dock Permit Request
Follow Up Flag:Follow up
Flag Status:Flagged
Thanks Pam,
I agree with your determination they will need to meet the Sec. 11.65 dock dimension requirements regardless of an
easement. It looks like the placement is okay as proposed, as it doesn’t appear would impede maintenance access or
performance of stormwater infrastructure.
After Eric left I somewhat unofficially became the interim Water Resource contact person for Sec. 11.65 Shoreland
Overlay District review, but often confer with Jenna in final decisions. I’m okay with being the initial contact person for
now however it may be best practice to copy the general Wateres@cityofeagan.com in case I’m out of the office.
Thanks,
Brian Leyendecker
Stormwater Specialist
3501 Coachman Pt | Eagan, MN 55122
Office: 651-675-5489 | Cell: 651-529-0193
https://www.cityofeagan.com
From: Pam Dudziak <pdudziak@cityofeagan.com>
Sent: Friday, March 22, 2024 10:48 AM
To: Brian Leyendecker <bleyendecker@cityofeagan.com>
Cc: Jenna Olson <jolson@cityofeagan.com>; Julie Strid <JStrid@cityofeagan.com>
Subject: RE: Dock Permit Request
Brian,
Docks are a collaborative effort, and we would still like Water Resources to review dock permits, although the ZP will be
logged, filed and sent out from Planning. Docks come up only occasionally, but we wrote this memo in 2012 and I
believe all of these ordinance references are still valid.
This one is on LeMay Lake, it is a Shoreland Waterbody, and there is a d/u easement but no conservation easement
along the shore here. The proposed dock meets the 5’ max width standard of Sec. 11.65, but far exceeds the 60 sf max
per Sec. 10.24 Subd. 5. So we are unable approve this permit. They would have to reduce the overall size to max 60 sf.
If they go down to 4 ft. wide, they can have a 15 ft. long dock.
2
Previously Eric Macbeth was the only one to sign off on any Zoning Permits for Water Resources. I’m copying Jenna on
this so she can confirm that responsibility has been delegated that to you. In that case, you will become our contact for
review of any other ZP’s that we get that need a review from Water Resources.
Thanks,
Pam
Pam Dudziak
Planner
3830 Pilot Knob Rd | Eagan, MN 55122
Office: 651-675-5691
https://www.cityofeagan.com
From: Planning <planning@cityofeagan.com>
Sent: Thursday, March 21, 2024 2:29 PM
To: Pam Dudziak <pdudziak@cityofeagan.com>; Brian Leyendecker <bleyendecker@cityofeagan.com>
Subject: FW: Dock Permit Request
This is our first, to my knowledge, dock permit. Who will be reviewing this? Planning or Water Resources?
Julie Strid
Planning Aide
3830 Pilot Knob Rd | Eagan, MN 55122
Office: 651-675-5686
https://www.cityofeagan.com
From: Erin Gable <eolenag@gmail.com>
Sent: Thursday, March 21, 2024 2:14 PM
To: Planning <planning@cityofeagan.com>
Subject: Dock Permit Request
Hello!
Please see attached documents for a dock permit request. Note: I had submitted one last year, but didn't get around to
installing it and learned more about the space I'll be adding it to so had to pivot from my original plan. Please reach out
if you have any questions.
Thank you for your time!
Erin