Loading...
1725 Deerwood Dr PERMIT City of Eagan Permit Type: Building 3830 Pilot Knob Rd Permit Number: EA091753 Eagan, MN 55122 . Date Issued: 10/26/2009 (651) 675-5675~~~ EPermit Category: ePermit www.ci.eagan.mn.us lflflUl tflflLLL Site Address: 1725 Deerwood Dr Lot: 6 Block: 10 Addition: Cedar Grove 8th PID 10-16707-060-10 Use Description: Sub Type: e-Windows/Doors Construction Type: Work Type: Windows/Doors-New/Replacement Description: House Census Code: 434- Occupancy: Zoning: Square Feet: 0 Comments: huprovements to the home require smoke detectors in all bedrooms. If altering window openings, call for framing inspection. Call for final inspection after installation. Carbon monoxide detectors are required by law in ALL single family homes. Fee Summary: BL - Base Fee $3K $88.50 0801.4085 Surcharge - Based on Valuation $3K $1.50 9001.2195 Valuation: 3,000.00 Total: $90.00 Contractor: -Applicant - Owner: Window World AKA Probuilt America Angela Petri 2211 11th Ave E, #130 1725 Deerwood Dr N St. Paul MN 55109 Eagan MN 55122--173 (651) 770-5570 I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Applicant/Permitee: Signature Issued By: Signature CITY OF EAGAN 3795 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, MN $5122 N? 4 3 0 3 PHONE: 454-8100 BUILDING PERMIT Receipt # To be used for 1 ! i : , , Date 19 Site Address Lot Block iIJ Sec/Sub. d Parcel # Name _ Address o Name S ame Z 0 u 4 Address u Ce ~ City Phone uIy WW Name ?-z !A Address - Police Fire Eng. Planner Council Permit I St), ?t Surcharge Plan check SAC Water Conn. Water Meter I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that Bldg. Off. the information is correct and agree to comply with a!I applicable State of Minnesoto Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. APC Total Signature of Permittee` ':+L;`iC,• ?-'€155 A Building Permit is issued to: on the express condition that all work shall be done in accordance with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eacon Ordinances. Building Official Erect 53 Alter ? Repair ? Enlarge ? Occupancy Zoning --- Fire Zone _ Type of Const. V Move ? # Stories Demolish ? Front 7! ft. Grade ? Depth ft. Approvals Fees Assessment Water 8 Sew. a • permit # Date laud permit he Plumbing ?- Mechanical _ i -W -T - INSPECTIONS DATE INSP. Rough-in Find Footings -? Date Insp. Date Insp. Foundation _ Plumbing - ?? Frame/ins. - / • 7 Mechanical Final Remarks: t CITY OF EAGAN 3795 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, Minnesota 55122 Phone: 454-8100 _ PERMIT No. 14 Date: Receipt No.: ' Single l Site Address: 1 725 De-T',(; :c: ".r. Residential Lot Block Sub/Sec. Multi Res., Comm./Ind. Name yeS /Repair New/Alter . . Address 7711 Cost of Installation C 'a5ai3 City Phone: ')' Permit Fee ?' ` i" ` Nome Surcharge .5. 2 ddress C City _ Phone: Total This Permit is issued on the express condition that all work shall be done in accordance with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Official CITY OF EA"N 3795 Pilot Knob Road - !? Eagan, Minnesota 55122 t' Phone: 454-8100 PERMIT No. July 1-1, Date: ^~ l Receipt No.: ^ Single Site Address: Residential i0 Lot Block Sub/Sec. CG 8 Multi Res., Comm./Ind. Name Ver,ess New/Alter./Repair. Y`` w Address 1774 ieadowl2rk T oa ? Cost of Installation C City Eagan Phone: Permit Fee 20. 00 ` Name sarme Surcharge .50 S V All Address F3 City _ Phone: Total This Permit is issued on the express condition that all work shall be done in accordance with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Building Official INSPECTION RECORD CITY OF EAGAN PERMIT TYPE: 3830 Pilot Knob Road Permit Number: Eagan, Minnesota 55122-1897 Date Issued: (612) 681-4675 rJ If SITE ADDRESS: , 1 r. 8 t 0(r 1 , :. APPLICANT: PERMIT SUBTYPE: TYPE OF WORK: 11; .) . . ' j !lit) 1111 1 1 It t MIA 0-i 'Aadjoi Ali1:'71(ja Mltl VU PA IR 1 . Is F, is t lr 11111 I OPS 7 Permit Holder Date Telephone M PLUMBING HVAC Inspection Date Insp. Comments FOOTINGS FOUND FRAMING ROOFING pl119 ROUGH PLUMBING PLBG AIR TEST ROUGH HEATING GAS SVC TEST INSUL GYP BOARD FIREPLACE FIREPLACE AIR TEST FINAL PLBG FINAL HTG ORSAT TEST BLDG FINAL DOMESTIC METER IRRIGATION METER FLUSH MAINS CONDUCTIVITY TEST HYDROSTATIC TEST BSMT R.I. BSMT FINAL DECK FTG DECK FINAL CITY OF EAGAN Remarks Addition Cedar Grove #8 Lot 6 Rik 10 Parcel 10 16707 Owners 92?l?Ca?s ?i?? Street 1725 Deerwood Dr. State Eagan,MN 55122 Improvement Date An Annual Years ayment Receipt ate STREET SURF. DD 1 62.67 10 c X770 STREET RESTOR. M GRADING DD 19755 . 0.9 10 ?-ooZ7 ? ?/ 7 SAN SEW TRUNK 1970 125-00 .00 2 c,u,Z7r *SEWER LATERAL _ 1 97 1539-10 307.2 ? 1l 7? WATERMAIN # WATER LATERAL 1974-1 WATER AREA IS 1977 160.00 10.66 15 138-68 A(If)-;76-; 4-4-78 . STORM SEW TRK # STORM SEW LAT `' 1 974 5 CURB & GUTTER SIDEWALK STREET LIGHT WATER CONN. OQ ?Q BUILDING PER. # SAC Do S- PARK i j CITY OF EAGAN SEWER SERVICE PERMIT 3795 Pil,t Knob Road PERMIT NO.: Eagan, MN 55122 DATE: 7!' Zoning: No. of Units: Owner: Address: Site Address: r . ?> • . Plumber: agree to comply with the City of Eagan Connection Charge: • - Ordinances. Account Deposit: Permit Fee: ?• Surcharge: By Mi Ch sc. arges: Date of Insp.: Total: Insp.: D P ate aid: CITY OF EAGAN 3795 Pihl, Knob Road Eagan, MN 55122 Zoning: Owner: ' Address: Site Address: s"?t?'?'cl nr. Plumber; Meter No.: Size: Reader No.: 1 agree to comply with the City of Eagan Ordinances. By Date of Insp.: WATER SERVICE PERMIT PERMIT NO.: DATE: No. of Units: Connection Charge: Account Deposit: Permit Fee: Surcharge: Misc. Charges: 1':E Total: Date Paid: Insp.: o g Agenda Information Memo October 20, 1987 L? ?,. L ACCESSORY HOUSING PERMIT/MICHAEL KALZENBERG A. Accessory Housing Permit, 1725 Deerwood Drive for Michael Ka lzenberg--Michael Kalzenberg who resides at 1725 Deerwood Drive made application for an accessory housing permit on August 25, 1987. Since this application is the first formal application received by the City for consideration of an accessory apartment, the Planning Department has carefully reviewed the intent of the ordinance and proposed accessory apartment to determine whether the unit meets the intent of the city ordinance. It was determined by the City Planner that the application appears to meet all the requirements of the Eagan City Code, Chapter 11.20, Subdivision 5.C.7. Therefore, a letter was sent to all residents within 200 feet of the Kalzenberg property stating that if any property owner wishes to object to the proposal, a written letter of appeal must be submitted to the City within 10 days of the date of that letter. The letter was mailed on October 9, 1987. For a copy of the City's notice, refer to page . For a copy of a rough drawing and sketch of the house, refer to pages through This item appears on the City Council agenda due to an objection expressed by several neighbors in a petition dated August 26, 1987. The neighbors have asked that this item be heard by the City Council and are planning to attend the meeting on Tuesday to object to the accessory housing permit as requested by Michael Kalzenberg. Enclosed on pages through is a copy of a brief update from City Planner Runkle including a petition received from home- owners in the area. ACTION TO BE CONSIDERED ON THIS ITEM: To approve or deny the accessory housing permit as requested by Michael Kalzenberg of 1725 Deerwood Drive and, further, that action is required due to objections stated by residents within 200 feet of Kalzenberg's property. oPKykliI 9l?<f UME L 1 /z GU S EAGAN TOWNSHIP BUILDING PERMIT N° 2931 Owner _....... ': v-Cre?.-!:{:.......-..._ Eagan Township Address (present) ....... t..... .'4-?Z..:._. ..... _............. ..._ Town Hall Builder ........... Address ..._. DESCRIPTinN Dale ..../:>:...._j.. ?.2. Stories To Be Used For Front Depth Height Est. Cos! permit Fee Remarks p / JL/ LOCATION /0 " G Street, Road or other Description of Location Lot Block Addition or Tract 3, y S? 6 7? This permit does not authorize the use of streets, roads, alleys or sidewalks nor does it give the owner or his agent the right to create any situation which is a nuisance or which presents a hazard to the health, safety, convenience and general welfare to anyone in the community. THIS PERMIT MUST BE KEPT ON THE PREMISE WHILE THE WORK IS IN PROGRESS. ,/ This is to certify, that .......:..c..l'?.`.>..^:_GF :!......._has permission to erect a.....l..L ....... .......°'..?...... ...-...................... upon the above described premise subject to the provisions of the Building Ordinance for Eagan Township ado tad April 11, 1955. ) ? ::.`?:.`_......t.....?.."C - Per Building Inspector.. CITTOF EAGAN 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, Minnesota 55122-1897 (651) 681-4675 PERMIT PERMIT TYPE: FU 1. LDING Permit Number: 0 3 4 4 1. 0 Date Issued: 01 / 1. 3 ,' 9 9 SITE ADDRESS: :L72S DEERWO00 OR LOTr 6 BLOCKt 1 CEDAR GROVE 68 P.3.N.t 10--16707-960-1.0 DESCRIPTION: REPLACE Buildino'-Pel-mit Tvpe Eduild.ino Wiirk TVpe 'CPnsuti Cod: r i SIDING Sr, (PIlSC. 1 REPAIR 434 ALT. RESIDENTIAL r _ REMARKS: FEE SUMMARY: VALUATION $5.000 SUrcharge _ 50 'Iotal Pee $113.115 CONTRACTOR: - Aonitcant Si`. LIC. OWNER: 1. 'd0031.484 KELZTNBERG NIKE 7s?JA PlSDN CONSI TN C„ R :L r1982','), 17466 1AGUAR FA TI{ 1725 DEERWOOD DR LAKEV7.LLF MN 55044 F A 0 A N NN 551?7 '.6121 895--2571 (651)933-3339 I hereby acknowledge that I have read this aoolication and Mate that the intorrnation is correct and agree to coinoly with a I 1 301)1icab1 e State ot Kin. Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. i? APPLICANT/PERMITEE SIGNATURE Q_ ?l SSUED BY: SIGNAT R?1 E z?kc?k?? XcrXXc*Xc?SXcX?%??k?X?#??? k?X?X?X?%:??csK%?X?zcX??%X?X?m Xc CITY OF EAGAN CASHIER: S TERMINAL NO: 795 DATE: Ol/1.3/99 TIMEg 15:19.05 ID: NAME: R SHANSON CONSTRUCTION 3210 9001 1.725 DEERWOOD D 111.25 2155 9001. 1.725 DEERWOOD D 2.50 Total. Receipt, Amount: 113.75 CR 1.01.902 USER ID: NANCY 113 75 1999 BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION (RESIDENTIAL) CITY OF EAGAN j? LI I 3830 PMOT KNOB RD - 55122 (651) 681-4675 New Construction Requirements Remodel/Repair Requirements ? 3 registered site surveys ? 2 copies of plans (include beam & window sizes; poured fnd. design; etc.) ? 1 energy calculations ? 3 copies of tree preservation plan if lot platted after 7/1/93 required: -Yes _ No DATE: \ 113 1 DESCRIPTION OF WORK: GSI6,z ? 2 copies of plan ? 1 site surveys (exterior additions & decks) ? 1 energy calculations for heated additions CONSTRUCTION COST; LI ?? STREET ADDRESS: 1--)QS 2 ?? U t ?y>7 (DA LOT: _C , BLOCK: I SUBD./P.I.D. CQ- " ;\_ C., Y b V - PROPERTY OWNER CONTRACTOR ARCHITECT/ ENGINEER Name: KA 2 t nhk yz ', rn/ (TV-CJ Phone #: Last I First Street Address: City p? C( l State: l 1 Zip: Sl 2-17---- f? ?C?iQQq GIdI -?Llbr7?, #: Company: (2 r) C?Y1S?12cne?t? Phone Street Address: q -Y( o'tL License #°?n?31yU 4(( Exp. 3 ?S? t City I_(A 1AQ.1? State:m'V\ Zip: Company: Name: Street Add City Sewer & water licensed plumber (new construction only): and lot change is requested once permit is issued. Penalty applies when address chang I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application, state that the information is correct, and agree to comply with all applicable Stat of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Signature of Applicant: OFFICE USE ONLY Certificates of Survey Received Yes - No Tree Preservation Plan Received Yes - No Not Required Phone #: Registration #: _ State: Zip: PERMIT CITY OF EAGAN 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, Minnesota 55122-1897 (612) 681-4675 PERMIT TYPE: Permit Number: Date Issued: BUILDING 033046 08/27/98 SITE ADDRESS: P.I.N.: 10-16707-060-10 1725 DEERWOOD DR LOT: 6 BLOCK: 10 CEDAR GROVE #8 DESCRIPTION: T.O. & REROOF/STORM Bukld1ng"3Permit Type STORM DAMAGE Bgilding W*k Type REPAIR e{sus Cody>434 ALT. RESIDENTIAL aC r ? t ?? t av o-kv C Rh`'irCC? 3 ?H. ?&tl I'm.. g R,a mvli _? LC ` H'frs f 6 W8k !TV{ ??2 .C? L3&'?Se., did E?- t pE 4-E!, '? ? a °' ,4F Y'$ e? it ?'. REMARKS: FEE SUMMARY: CONTRACTOR: APPLICANT/PERMITEE SIGNATURE OWNER: - Applicant - KELZENBERG MIKE 6540 169TH ST W EAGAN MN 55122 (651)953-3339 I 1998 BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION (RESIDENTIAL) CITY OF EAGAN 3830 PILOT KNOB RD - 55122 a ql Ly 681-4675 C? New Construction Requirements Remodel/Repair Requirements # 3 registered site surveys # 2 copies of plan # 2 copies of plans (include beam & window sizes; poured fnd. design; etc.) # 2 site surveys (exterior additions & decks) # t energy calculations # t energy calculations for heated additions # 3 copies of tree preservation plan if lot platted after 711/93 required: _ Yes _ No JJ DATE: CONSTRUCTION COST; ?? , 000 • J DESCRI? ON OF WORK: ki- SThk4ET ADDRESS: ?? ? Pd Q r l yj? ??? LOT: _L.5, BLOCK: 0 SUBD./P.I.D. #: O PROPERTY OWNER Name: ??,??/(I /(/,r Y P Phone #: L, \ ,5 -3 33 ? Last First Street Adc City Company: J1 State: AV Zip: l??I Z Phone #: CONTRACTOR Street Address: !] ?'e-` License # City _ ARCHITECT/ ENGINEER Company: Name:_ Street Adc City Sewer & water licensed plumber (new construction only): and lot change is requested once permit is issued. Zip: Penalty applies when address Chang I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicabl State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Signature of Applicant: d% OFFICE USE ONLY Certificates of Survey Received - Yes No State: Zip: Phone #: Registration State: Tree Preservation Plan Received Yes - No - Not Required D?: qq BUI.LDI dC- PERMIT APPL'CA..i V)"1 ?0 BT,OCK _ : O. ADDITIOLR._h'-- -- 'ICFT.: & SFC^IOet "THISER I.F Ui1PL.?ITTED o d .-}zL / % s: P 1, ? Anrr ?I. ivn! . a" GCCUPX1CY USE .'?,+'=i'• j?N1'_G./: Tit`/ c,f ;°w`z VGIy?GS TELEPHONE i':O. x' is tS; ?i tl?? rFrVe)e cn,k. t # tA r *i e? v S/2 2 't'ELEPFIONE no S/i el-w"/IA2 A Rdll TNrfl i/' +', "?v [tote= Inclade site plan, building plans, and ener_gp calcuiati^ns = th thi.' application Signed OFFICE USE 00 "a:. L )IMECTIOLI ^L, '3R "TEETER .'??SDri3G PERRIT FEE fRC"':RC+L. FEE "L tiI C; I.CK FEn ".'ARK DEDICATIOV' TWEE OT`MR n'rI: L' 'Plovill.S, M5 SSXK T CLEim ..-BUILDING DEPT POLICE DEPT. 7".,71:'R & SEWER DEPT. F2R2 rCPT. PPMK DEPT. F1 CITY OF EAGAN ' 3795 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, MN 55122 N2 4303 PHONE: 454-6100 BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION $469000. Receipt # ?,a}}_ To be send for Sing. Fam Da1S. b roara>_re Date May 39 , 19 77 Site Address 023 Dperwead Dr. Erect Occupancy - Lot b Block 10 Sec/Sub. C.G R Alter ? Zoning _ R1 Parcel # Repair ? Fire Zone Patrick Veness Enlarge ? Type of Const. V c Name Move ? # Stories 3 Address 1 774 Mearlnwl ark Rd. Demolish ? Front 72 ft. 0 city E8R8II Phone 414-6422 Grade ? Depth 28 ft. p Name Soma Approvals Fees Address Assessment Permit 130.50 ~ City Phone Water & Sew. Surcharge 23.00 H Police Plan check ww Name Fire SAC 475. 0U rZ _,. Address Eng Water Conn 230.00 I hereby acknowledge that 1 have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Signature of Permitte?("!iJ. atrick Veness Planner Council Bldg. Off. _ APC Water Meter 6U.00 Total 918.50 A Budding Permit ' s iss d to: _ on the express condition that all work shall be don is or, rice wi all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Building Official ?h ? r d (VO 1 5 ell, 01- 0 0 arV a ti ? n W?l / ?. ,lmy 0 3 n 1999 BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION (RESIDENTIAL) CITY OF EAGAN 3830 PILOT KNOB RD - 55122 651-681-4675 New construction ReouiremeMS RemodeOReoair Reauiremenis D 3 registered site surveys showing sq. ft of lot, sq. fL of house and All roofed areas (20% maximum lot coverage allowed) ? 2 copies of plans (show (ream & window sixes; poured fnd. design; etc.) ? 1 at of energy calculations ? 3 copies of Use preservation plan If lot platted after 7MI93 DATE: DESCRIPTION OF WORK: STREET ADDRESS: LOT: (? BLOCK: PROPERTY OWNER CONTRACTOR ARCHITECT/ ENGINEER Cr of-e 113 "2s 2 copies of plan 1 set of energy calculations for hated additions 1 site survey for exterior additions & decks CONSTRUCTION COST: S OOn Name: K PJ7-e &4 &,t Phone #: 953 - 333 last First Street Address: -& -qo 1& q i4& S ?, Lx)' city oak 'Ir n-11 v-1 State: to-v- Zip: Company:. of rert/Ue &14147 Ser ld 2 -44C, Phone #: Lr1a X85 =9 ??g ?Ij (area code) Street Address: /ajea7AinI44i Aw- S. License # &nLk S , Exp. J7e' City &42f d?iki,fdN State: 04,U/U. Zip: SS41a4 rLj Company: Telephone C ( Name: Registration M City State: Zip: Sewer & water licensed plumber (new construction only): Telephone Penalty applies when address change and lot change is requested once permit is Issued. I hereby aclunowledge that I have read this application, state that the Information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and Cit of ?gan Ordinances. I Signature of Applicant I zeoz OFFICE USE ONLY Certificates of Survey Received Yes No Tree Preservation Plan Received Yes No Not Required Corrective uildin? Serve S PROPOSAL Inc. 8892 Wentworth Avenue South TO: Michael Kelzenberg 6540 169th Street West Apple Valley, MN 55124 Bloomington, Minnesota 55420 PROJECT: Foundation Repair Phone (612) 885-9808 Egress Windows FAX (612) 885-9796 1725 Deerwood Drive Eagan, MN PROJECT NUMBER: 99-11-105 PROPOSAL NUMBER: 1 We hereby propose to furnish in accordance with the specifications below, or on attached pages, all materials and labor to complete the following: GENERAL CONDITIONS: The project consists of repair of the south masonry foundation wall of the home. Along with the repair the two existing windows at the east half of the south foundation wall will be replaced with egress sized windows. The repair will consist of excavating along the exterior of the south foundation wall to expose the wall. The wall will then be straightened to a plumb condition, and reinforced with interior pilasters to provide a stable foundation. The egress windows will be installed, the exterior of the wall waterproofed, and the soil back filled and compacted. The surface grade along the exterior of the south wall will be changed to provide proper slope away from the house. The following specifications apply: PROJECT SPECIFICATIONS 1. Provide all permits. 2. Install braces at interior of south foundation wall. 3. Excavate to elevation of footings along south foundation wall. All soil to stay on site. 4. Install jacks at interior of south foundation wall and straighten foundation as close to plumb as possible. 5. Remove section of foundation wall to provide access for two egress windows at east half of south wall. Window openings to match existing window locations. 6. Install wood frames for egress window installation. 7. Install two clad casement egress windows at south wall. Painting staining and trim by others. 8. Install reinforced core fills 32" on center along south foundation wall. Each core fill to have one 1/2" steel rod. 9. Waterproof exterior below grade portion of south foundation wall. 10. Back fill excavation with existing soils. Compact in two foot lifts. 11. Install two galvanized steel area walls, one at each egress window. Provide escape ladder for each area wall. 12. Haul in additional clay soils and grade to provide positive drainage away from building at south wall. 13. Remove braces and shoring from interior of house. 14. All interior finish work to be by others. 15. All landscape and sod repair to by others. Page 1 of 3 3I ?V o(?, 1FIREPLACE PERMIT APPLICATION CITY OF EAGAN 3830 PILOT KNOB ROAD - 55122 651 681-4675 Date: /o 7 J Description of Work: k- Construct new fireplace ? Gas -Masonry Install gas insert only Other a - / (-(-d() Alterations to existing Install gas line only Job address: / X Let _& Block: 0 Suhdivision/P.I.D. #: GtLL\ ' b V Q\14P ? Applicant (circle one only): Owner Contractor Permit Fee: $60.50 PROPERTY OWNER FIREPLACE INSTALLER Name: 'r t? ?rl_, cc Phone #: 661 Last First Street Address: City State: Zip: Company: ?yntL '}-F tt2l??cc? 1-11 Phone#: la'?- g`I1itAl / O (area code) Street Address: 2!!* 12?/Q U Gs ? s G/Z City State: S Zip: S5?; Company: Phone #: Zar__ -&,(-Sorg GAS LINE (area code) INSTALLER Street Address: City State: Zip: I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota S nces. Signa FEB l q OFFICE USE ONLY BUILDING PERMIT TYPE ? 16 Fireplace WORK TYPE ? 31 New ? 32 Addition ? 33 Alterations ? 34 Repair GENERAL INFORMATION Census Code 434 SAC Code 01 REMARKS Chimney/flue must be inspected before concealing ? 39 Gas Line ? 40 Gas Insert ? 41 Wood Stove ?k?X<Xc?X?MXc 4c?t*?kMX':NtXt?tXi>Kk?x?rk?X>k%k?k?k?k?%?ki??k?ItkkA?k:k CITY o1F 1::A(6>.N CASHIER: JS Tlii:PMTtVL NO;: 131.9 DATE„ 02/i.4; 00 "!Jh E: 13.,59 ;:31. IL?: h:!C: STOVE (Mr-PI ACE (ALL.0"'Y :32:10 JO( 1. 1.7 2`J 1101:9140M, D ;.50.00 21.', 5 900:1. 1.725 T31--0 WOOD 1:i 0.`50 I m?#Y,t:kY,:x?r:?'bV6 CJ?M?:.?kYXXc?;c;;itX?%W ?X?:c ::w*ik?k?«'m>k>K?%*M?k0 M E M O R A N D U M TO: LTom Hedges, City Administrator Dale Runkle, Community Development Director FROM: Jim Sheldon, City Attorney DATE: May 11, 1989 RE: Kalzenberg House Rental Our File No.: 206-6240 The following is a summation of the facts of this matter to date: 1. In April of 1987, the City adopts an ordinance creating accessory apartments. Eagan City Code Section 11.20, Subd. 5(c)7. 2. August 25, 1987. Michael Kalzenberg petitioned City of Eagan for accessory housing permit. 3. October 20, 1987. Council resolves to deny the application based upon the strong opposition of the neighboring property owners (Mr. Yetzer included). 4. October 7, 1988. Complaint received from Mr. Yetzer advising the City that the basement of the Kalzenberg property is being rented in contravention of the ordinance and Council's action. 5. January 17, 1989. Council rescinds ordinance creating accessory apartments. Eagan City Code Section 11.20, Subd. 5(c)7. 6. John Yetzer and other neighbors inform the City that Kalzenberg had continued to rent his lower level as a separate unit up until the present. Mr. Yetzer states there seems to be only one renter at present. City of Eagan has directed us to serve notice and prosecute, if necessary, Mr. Kalzenberg's violation of the R-1 zoning ordinance prohibiting maintaining two living units in an R-1 zone. On February 16, 1989, a certified letter was sent from our office to Mr. Kalzenberg informing him that he was in violation of Eagan City Code Section 11.20, Subd 5. We informed Mr. Kalzenberg that if he was not in compliance with the City zoning ordinance by April 1, 1989, he would be cited for criminal violation of the City Code, a misdemeanor. Mr. Kalzenberg responded to our notice with a letter dated February 23, 1989. In that letter, he stated he was not in violation of the zoning code. Be stated that after the accessory housing permit was denied, the couple living in his basement moved out as required by the City Council. He further stated that he now has three roommates which share the entire house equally. The issues are whether the City has sufficient evidence to charge Mr. Kalzenberg with a violation of the zoning ordinance and secondly, the City's chances for success in prosecuting Mr. Kalzenberg. The Eagan City Code allows only one family detached dwellings in R-1 districts (11.20, Subd. 5(a)l). "Family" is defined as an individual or two or more persons each related by blood, marriage or adoption living together as a single housekeeping unit; or a group of not more than five persons not so related maintaining a common household and using common cooking and kitchen facilities (11.03, Subd. 21). Therefore, in order to prove that Mr. Kalzenberg is in criminal violation of the Eagan zoning ordinance, the City must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Mr. Kalzenberg has two "families" residing in his dwelling. Since Mr. Kalzenberg does not claim to be related to the renters or renter, the City would have to prove that: 1. There are either more than five persons in the home or 2. That the unrelated persons are not maintaining a common household or are not using common cooking and kitchen facilities. We feel that there is sufficient evidence to charge Mr. Kalzenberg with a violation of the Code. That evidence is as follows: 1. Kalzenberg's application for an accessory housing permit showed an intent to use the home for two families. 2. The home inspection and diagrams made by Dale Runkle and Doug Reid show that there are complete and independent living facilities including a separate cooking and kitchen facility in the lower level of the Kalzenberg home. 3. After the accessory housing permit was denied, Kalzenberg made statements to the neighbors at the Council meeting that he would continue to rent the lower level and would merely call the renters "roommates". 4. Observations by the neighbors that Mr. Kalzenberg did indeed continue to rent the lower level of his home. 5. Observations of the neighbors that the current renter uses the lower level entrance to the home while Mr. Kalzenberg uses the upper level entrance to the home. While this evidence would give sufficient cause to charge a violation, the City would still have an uphill battle meeting its burden of proof. This is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The City -2- must establish guilt by legally sufficient evidence, either direct or circumstantial, so complete as to overcome reasonable theories of innocence and to the exclusion of every other reasonable hypothesis. This has been explained to Mr. Yetzer in detail and he is still anxious for the City to proceed against Mr. Kalzenberg. We have explained to him that the neighbors' testimony will be a crucial element of the City's case. Mr. Yetzer has assured us that the neighbors are ready and willing to testify. The City would also have to subpoena Mr. Kalzenberg's renter to testify. The case may be won or lost on whether or not this renter, in all likelihood a hostile witness, will admit on the stand that he and Mr. Kalzenberg are using separate cooking and kitchen facilities or are not "maintaining a common household". JPE/djk -3- McMENOMY & SEVERSON EDWARD 13. McM I'NOMY I.AIt RY S. SEVIORSON* JAMI•,S P. SIIF LDON J. PATRICK wH•cox- TNRENCE 1'. DURKIN MICI IAI'A, C. DOU(mi-AIT1' READJ. HANSEN MICHAI9, 1'. MOLENDA- 'ALSO LICENSED IN IOWA "ALSO IACKNSI:O IN WISCONSIN }ALSO LICENSKID IN NEBRASKA May 5, 19 Mr. Jo Yetzer 1726 artell Drive Eag , MN 55121 'I,' (6-7 ( ) 7-- 0(A°," A PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION ATTORNEYS AT LAW Z'REPLY TO: MM WEST 147TH STREET P.O. BOX IN= APPLE VALLEY, MINNESOTA 55124 TXLEPAx NUMBER 432 XW (612) 4340106 ? REPLY TO: 144M SOUTH ROBERT TRAIT. ROSEMOUNT, MINNESOTA 55 (012) 4211155 PAUL J. STI ER PATRICK 1V. STEW'ART KEVIN 1'. CARROLL KENNETH It. HALT. SCO'PI' D. JOHNS•1'ONi' JOSEPH I'. BARLEY MARY L. COLIKK MICIIAI;L C. McCIANN OP COUNSEL: LEONARD Y. HIERNAT JOHN I.. VOKP.LICII RE: Kalzenberg Home Rental Our File No.: 206-6240 Dear Mr. Yetzer: This letter is written as a follow-up to our phone conversation of may 1, 1989. During that conversation I reviewed with you the contents of our earlier conversation where we had discussed the necessity for neighbor testimony should Mr. Kalzenberg be sited for a zoning violation. You stated during our conversation that one of the roommates had moved out of the Kalzenberg home recently and he had also done some tidying up around the property. I further explained to you that Mr. Kalzenberg had responded to our letter telling him he was in violation of the zoning ordinance regarding accessory apartments. I've enclosed a copy of that letter for your information. i explained to you that in order to prosecute Mr. Kalzenberg, we would have to prove in a Court of law beyond a reasonable doubt that the "roommates" do not share common living facilities within the house or alternatively that there are more than five people in the home. I will speak to Dale Runkle and we will make a determination as to whether or not we would be able to successfully prosecute Mr. Kalzenberg for a violation of the single family zoning restrictions. McMENOMY & SEVERSON A PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION ATTORNEYS AT LAW Mr. John Yetzer May 5, 1989 Page Two I also informed you that we would keep you fully informed of any and all steps the City will take. Thank you for your cooperation in this matter. Sincerely, MCMENOMY & SEVERSON, P.A. Joseph P. Earley J PE/di k cc: D le Runkle, Community Development Director m Hedges, City Administrator February 23, 198`' P. ':rarely Mclrlenom.r & S ors. 7300 W i4'lth st Apple yally, MN 55124 Fe: Letter of February 16, 1989 Dear Mr :Carley: I was saddened to receive your letter. It appears that you have somehow been mislead. Your notification of a violation is completely in error. Some time ago, I applied for an accessory housing permit. It was denied by the City Council. Shortly thereafter, Mark and Janet Michael mover] out as required by the City Council. Subsequently, I found honest hardworking roommates whose lifesty7.es mesh with my way of life. Presently, I have three roommates. Other then out respective bedrooms, we ull share the entire house equally. I am not aware that four unrelated people sharing a house is a violation. I have no way of knowing for sure why you have taken time out of your busy day -to allege that I am a non law abiding citizen. I suspect that Mr. John Yetzer is continuing his personal vendetta and has filed some false complaints against me. If this is the case, I would appriciate if you and the City would not be a party to this uncalled for harassment. In summary, I am now and will always be in compliance with the city zoning ordinance. I hope this matter has now been satisfactorily cleared up for you. I'm available at the following address if you have any futher concerns. Sincerely, A'/,& a' Mike Yelzenberg 1725 Deerwood dr Eagan MN, 55122 McMENOMY & SEVERSON A PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION A17O RN EYS AT LAW N.Il1VARIl IS. klcM RNO bi I' I.ARRI' 5' SF:VERSON` .1AN11:S l" SHELIA)N J. I':AI'ItlCK 1CIU, OX' 'H:IWNl'I! P. DURKIN %110 IIAI I.(; I)llif aIF:It'I'1' i(F:II).I IIAN-zI!N \IH'i 1Aha. F;. MOLENDA" LI. Ii NSI-:II IN 1114\:\ V: 111,II'ES.iEb IN WISCIINSIS C4LV(11.11 1(.NSF: It IN NEBRASKA E'REPLY'ro: MW WEST 1471'11 SI'REET P.0 BOX 24:129 APPLE v,V.LKI'. MINp'tSUTA in114 TEI.F.t'AX NUNINKR 4:12:1'80 (6121 132. d I:F.3 ? REPLY TO: 13 4.-d] SOU'I'11 RO ERT (RAIL ROSI;MOUNT. MINNESOTA 55(66 (612)4'_, 11.11 PA U 1..1. a'l'l RR PATRICK W'. STEWART KI':VIN 1'. CARB)LI. KF'NNETH R. HALT. SCOIT 1)..10 H NSTO N4 B)Sl HI 11. YL\Rl' 1_1;151 .I IiE MICHAELC.MWANN (11: Cu U NS KI.. LFUNARII K BlKBNAI' 'JOHN F. VUKKI.I(Ai February 16, 1989 CERTIFIED MAIL - RRR Michael elzenberg 1725 erwood Drive'. Eaga , MN 55122 RE: Residential Ordinance Violation Our File No: 206-6240 Dear Mr. Kelzenberg: We write as City Attorneys for the City of Eagan. You are hereby notified that you are in violation of Eagan City Code, Section 11.20, Subd. 5. Your home is located in a district zoned R-1. This means that only one-family detached dwellings are permitted. By allowing renters, unrelated by blood, marriage or adoption, to reside in your lower level and providing them with complete independent living facilities, you are in violation of the above-referenced zoning ordinance. A violation of the zoning ordinance is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine up to $700.00 and/or 90 days in jail. The City staff has made numerous attempts to work with you on this matter to no avail. They have now turned the matter over to us for criminal prosecution. If you are not in compliance with the City zoning ordinance by April 1, 1989, you will be cited for criminal violation of the City zoning ordinance. MCM ENOMY & SEVERSON .\ I'ROFE,"8IONM. ASSOCIATION ATI ORNK) p AT IAW Michael Kelzenberg February 16, 1989 Page Two I look forward to hearing from you as soon as possible concerning this very serious matter. Sincerely, McMENOMY & SEVERSON, P.A. Joseph P. Earley J PE/di kk cc: VD ale Runkle, City of Eagan Tom Hedges, City of Eagan LL ? 6 10 ?ec ar ? DiJ6 $-% MEMO TO: TOM HEDGES, CITY ADMINISTRATOR FROM: DALE RUNKLE, CITY PLANNER DATE: OCTOBER 7, 1988 RE: YETZER COMPLAINT - DEERWOOD DRIVE ACCESSORY HOUSING The Planning Department has been advised of the complaint regarding the accessory structure or rental unit on Deerwood Drive. As you recall, the City Council reviewed and denied an application for accessory housing at this particular location. The City has been contacted that the owners of the property are using the basement as rental and the Planning Department is. in the process of reviewing the circumstances regarding this complaint. The City has advised the complainant that they must file a written complaint to the City in order for us to monitor the property for the violation. Presently, it is difficult to cite a violation as the City would have to provide proof this is a rental unit and without permission from the homeowner to enter the property, it would be difficult to determine if a violation is occurring at this property. Upon receipt of a written complaint, staff will then begin monitoring the property with the help of the police department to determine if there is a violation of the zoning code. We are also pursuing this complaint with the City Attorney's Office to see if we can prosecute or what information and documentation the City will need in order to prosecute the violation. The Planning Department is aware that this complaint has reached City Council members and this department is working expeditiously to review and monitor this complaint. Our utmost attention will be given to resolve the current problem as soon as posible in accordance with proper ordinance procedure. Staff will give you an update on the situation once a determination is made regarding an ordinance violation. If you have further concerns or would like additional information, please advise. DCR/js CC: Shannon Willey - Zoning Administrator October 6, 1988 Eagan City Hall Attention Ms. Shannon Willey 3830 Pilot Knob Road P.O. Box 21-199 Eagan, MN 55121 Dear Ms. Willey: This letter is in response to the ongoing concern of the property at 1725 Deerwood Drive in Eagan. As you are aware, in November of 1987, homeowners appeared before the City Council meeting and expressed their wishes of having the renting of the lower-level apartment in a single-dwelling area stopped. The owner of the property at 1725 Deerwood Drive was told at that meeting that he must stop renting the lower-level apartment in his home. The lower-level apartment has continued to be rented without interruption. Since November 1987 there have been four different parties renting the lower-level apartment; and the neighbors have not received any letters regarding permit requests. The last renters moved in the first of October 1988. Thank you for your efforts in resolving this matter. S' rely, John E. Yetzer 1726 Sartell Avenue Eagan, MN 55122 454-3619 ?w C? October 14, 1987 Mr. Dale Runkle, City Planner P.O. Box 21-199 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, MN 55122 Dear Mr. Runkle: This letter is in response to the NOTICE OF INTENT TO APPROVE ACCESSORY APARTMENTS. We, concerned homeowners of Eagan, request that you reconsider our letter of August 26 and not approve an application for the accessory apartment at 1725 Deerwood Drive. Attached is a copy of the August 26 letter. Many us have lived in our homes since the area was developed. We moved in because of the zoning and we want it to remain as single-family dwellings. We hope, you will consider our request to not approve the application, and also,fput a stop esent renting of the accessory apartment ?t 1725 Deerwood Drive. Again, thank you for your consideration of our request. Sincerely, Attachment cc: Mayor Bea Blomquist, Councilmen: Theodore Wachter James A. Smith Thomas Egan Vic Ellison city of 3830 PILOT KNOB ROAD. P.O. BOX 21199 - BEA BL OMOUIST OM EAGAN. MINNESOTA 55121 M PHONE: (612) 454-8100 THOMAS EGAN "ES A SMITH VAC ELLISON THEODORE WACHTER Cw 11 Members THOMAS HEDGES July 27, 1987 ON Admin ftM1 EUGENE VAN OVERBEKE city cle MR MICHAEL KELZENBERG 1725 DEERWOOD DRIVE EAGAN MN 55122 Re: Accessory Housing Dear Mr. Kelzenberg: It has come to my attention that you are renting the lower portion of your house. Enclosed is a copy of the Accessory Housing Ordinance and an Accessory Housing Permit Application. After reviewing the ordinance and submitting your application form, please call me at City Hall so we may schedule an appointment for inspection. Your cooperation in this matter is greatly appreciated. If you have any questions or comments regarding this matter, please call me at City Hall. Sincerely, Shannon Willey Zoning Administrator Enclosure SW/jeh THE LONE OAK TREE ...THE SYMBOL OF STRENGTH AND GROWTH IN OUR COMMUNITY RECEIVED J4 6 N7 July 2, 1987 Eagan City Hall Attention Shannon Willey 3830 Pilot Knob Road P.O. Box 21-199 Eagan, MN 55121 Dear Ms. Willey: This letter is in response to your request for a written letter from me stating my concerns expressed in telephone conversations we had on June 19 and June 25 regarding the property at 1725 Deerwood Drive in Eagan. My concern is the fact that the lower level of this home is being rented as an "apartment". We built our home in the area 14 years ago in a single family area and the fact that many parties moving in are renting out parts of their homes is a concern to many homeowners in our immediate area. We have been told by realtors that this most certainly will bring down the property value. We have not been notified that the above-mentioned property wishes to rent out the lower level of their home as an apartment. I have been told that a permit is needed to do this. We would appreciated it if this matter could be checked in as soon as possible. We too pay taxes and feel we have a right as a homeowner to question the fact that a permit has not been obtained and perhaps there are some matters that are not legally up to code. For example, the stairs laid on the ground up the back hill. Please feel free to contact me if I may be of assistance. I did hold up sending this letter thinking that perhaps this party would move out and the "apartment" would not be rented again, but this was not the case. Thank you for your efforts. Sincerely, Linda Y /ze? 1726 Sartell Avenue Eagan, MN 55122 Home - 454-3619 Work - 681-3628 6 1, 04649;1 D o 3 «AR A fA.1, 5 1 R A f eS A F vw 1 9 S F I o ce o? y d. T 7 R. C, o Vm Me t 9 7 SQ f5 f P- 416 S GZ z E- 3 -,...7 5 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Jkl y E9 g R - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - ,.• --- - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - __A?A NF - - -- - - - - - - - - - TF - - !2 4:F I 17 E 3s 8 -r 1-7 CITY USE ONLY PERMIT #: RECEIPT DATE: 2008 RESIDENTIAL MECHANICAL PERMIT !APPLICATION crrYoF EALGM 3830 PILOT KNOB RD EAGAN II N 55188 651-681-4675 Please complete for. D single family dwellings townhomes and condos when permits are required for each unit Date: '2 0 0 SITE ADDRESS: OWNER NAME: Jaime <) Jew v,,r t INSTALLER NAME: STREET ADDRESS: I TELEPHONE #: l0 t ! y IL/36111 LL-{L TELEPHONE #: .TszA-pi o Ai RSA- Sq s. 0 00 5- CITY. J n y ?- STATE: Place a check mark next to the permit work type M' U ZIP: 5 5 3 ?. 8. FIT Add-onjxwdifieefi -eF4Ne>$tpn to existin dwelling unit Ii 1 AUG 2 3 2002 L 30.00 _ a' mace replaced • air exchanger • air conditioner BY • other Nature of work: '«Ci /Act -Rcy- a-ce- L"11c)-?C Aqc&-l ? G i-/ 0 Lk H - 36 A - 0 r7 p State Surcharge $ .50 $301,50 Total S OF PERMITTEE voz PERMIT City of Eagan Permit Type: Building 3830 Pilot Knob Rd Permit Number: EA107554 Eagan, MN 55122 Date Issued: 10/16/2012 (651) 675-5675 ~ of (1 3R Q www.ci.eagan.mn.us Site Address: 1725 Deerwood Dr Lot: 6 Block: 10 Addition: Cedar Grove 8th PID: 10-16707-10-060 Use: Description: Sub Type: Single Fam Construction Type: Work Type: Day Care Inspection Description: Census Code: 434- Occupancy: Zoning: Square Feet: 0 Comments: Fee Summary: Day Care Inspection $50.00 1221.4216 Total: $50.00 Contractor: Owner: - Applicant - Angela Petri 1725 Deerwood Dr Eagan MN 55122-473 I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Applicant/Permitee: Signature Issued By: Signature PERMIT City of Eagan Permit Type:Building Permit Number:EA115513 Date Issued:09/26/2013 Permit Category:ePermit Site Address: 1725 Deerwood Dr Lot:6 Block: 10 Addition: Cedar Grove 8th PID:10-16707-10-060 Use: Description: Sub Type:Reroof & Siding Work Type:Replace Description: Census Code:434 - Zoning: Square Feet:0 Occupancy: Construction Type: Comments:If there is no ice protection inspection prior to final, the contractor must meet the inspector w/ a ladder and flat bar. Pictures are not acceptable in lieu of inspections. When installing ventilated soffit material, remove existing material (i.e. debris that could block vents) and take steps to ensure maximum ventilation to attic. Call for final inspection after installation. Valuation: 8,000.00 Fee Summary:BL - Base Fee $8K $162.25 0801.4085 Surcharge - Based on Valuation $8K $4.00 9001.2195 $166.25 Total: I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Contractor:Owner:- Applicant - Angela Petri 1725 Deerwood Dr Eagan MN 55122--173 Great Northern Builders 9419 Buckley Ct Inver Grove Heights MN 55077 (651) 436-5672 Applicant/Permitee: Signature Issued By: Signature PERMIT City of Eagan Permit Type:Mechanical Permit Number:EA179664 Date Issued:10/17/2022 Permit Category:ePermit Site Address: 1725 Deerwood Dr Lot:6 Block: 10 Addition: Cedar Grove 8th PID:10-16707-10-060 Use: Description: Sub Type:Furnace Work Type:Replace Description: Comments:Carbon monoxide detectors are required within 10 feet of all sleeping room openings in residential homes (Minnesota State Building Code). Questions regarding electrical permit requirements should be directed to State Electrical Inspector, Pete DeGrood at (507) Fee Summary:ME - Permit Fee (Replacements)$59.00 0801.4088 Surcharge-Fixed $1.00 9001.2195 $60.00 Total: This permit shall be null and void if work does not start within 180 days of issuance, or if work is suspended for 180 days or more after started. I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Contractor:Owner:- Applicant - Angela & Ryan Petri 1725 Deerwood Dr Eagan MN 55122--173 (952) 200-7405 Sedgwick Heating & Air Conditioning 1240 Trapp Road, Suite A Eagan MN 55121 (952) 881-9000 Applicant/Permitee: Signature Issued By: Signature