The URL can be used to link to this page

1859 Covington Lane õ ÿþ ÿþþýüüûüúûúü ùýýþþüñõîø îÿ ññ ÿþ ýüûúù ø üûú÷ö úù õ ÿ ÿ ú ô óý ò þ ú þ þ ñððñïð ãó ù ñïø öû ò ùéîúèçñêïêðïï ÷ù ó ÿùæçñêêñ öõõô óò úú áëûíÿß ÜåòÚó ñïø öûïñãåÿ ã ûò÷ññð ÿò÷ññ éìèñìñ ó ýûöÿó óå óúúóóä ÿ úûöóúúý äòãûä ÿâ ê úúÞ ÿ ûÿ . • CITY OF EAGAN ' - 3830 Pilot Krab Road, P.O. Box 21-199, Eagan, MN 55121 . PHONE: 454-8700 BUILDING /ERMIT Reu+at # TA V rmA f" ' --?' Eef Velue L' G V Dote 19 Site Address Lot Block ? Sec/Sub. Paroel No. rJSCON IiOMF.S I r; ? IName ? Address Citv ?Phone 4 .?' g ?u u? ? Name _ Address Erect F:J Occupancy Remodel ? Zoning Repair ? Type of Const. Enlerge ? No. Stories Move ? length ; ?'• oaR,misn ? Depth Grade ? Sq. Ft. Assessment Woter b Sew. Police firo Erq• Plonner Council Bldg. Off. APC Var. Date Name Address City Phone ' 1 hereby acknowiedga thot I how road this npplication ond state that the inlormotion is correct or?d agree to comply with oll applicnbla Stcta of Minnewro Stotutes ond City of Eaqan Ordinonus. Sipnoturo of Permiftet , N Bulldiny Permit is issued to: all work sholl be dona in xcordonce with all oppliooble Stote of Mir 8ufldinp Offlciol S AME Permit Surchorge 3 ;. Plan Review , '•; `-, 5AC '.. • v ?1 Woter Conn. Woter Meter Rood Unit Total on tF+e express condition thar ond City of Ecpen Qrdfnances. Permk No. Pwmk HoldW Data Tslephon* ?t : Plurdbinq H.VA.C. E?^? ?19 ?- L yl L?t l8 3 a o sof.M. . Inspectioo Oate Insp. Other Footinys - Foundstion Fnminy ?' Rooiing ? ?. ? Rouph PIlq. . Roud+ HVAC Inwlation ?. Final PI6p. Finsl HVAC 4 j ? Fin.l G?t/Ooc. Water Oescribe Locatlon: YWII Sower Pr. Dhp. Reaeipt (YIECHANICAL PERMIT Parmit No. CITY OF EAGAN Fee ' Fill in numbered spacas S/C .;^ Type or Print /egiW y Tot. ?n• J!1 . 1. Date 2. Installation Cost ?^'''? `• '.' 3. JobAddress= -j) 9 rOVj^?o-('> Lot Blk. Tract 4. OWfl@r ? ?tsf?1#1"1.?7f'L A1(:.a ':C11{a}/ e 5. Contractor ?entel Mechanica1 Pr,one ^59-1565 ' 6. Address 36n+^ RatlR."b@C )1" ?ca "a r `id 7. City 122 State Zip 8. Building Type: Residential U Commercial ? Institutional ? 9. Work Description: New U. Add O Alier El Repair 13 10. Describe ' (4. 'yS • Fuel Type ? A I 11. No, Equinment BTU - M. Ea. ForcedAir ?'?•??j'? No. Eauiament CFM Mfg. Air Handling: 8oilers Mfg. Mech. Exhaust Unit Heater Mfg. ' O h y Air Cond. t er Mfg. Gas, Piping Outlets 12. I hereby certify that the above information is true and correct, and I agree to comply with all ordinances and codes governing this type of work. Signed : tor Rough Final Inspections: Date Insp. Date Insp. This is your permit when numbered and approved. Approved CITY OF EAGAN 454-8100 Receipt PLUMBING PERMIT. • Parmit No. CITY OF EAGAN ? -• Fae - Fil! in numbered spaces S/C ' Type or Print legrb/y Tot " 1. Date 2. Installation Cost 3. Job Address Lot Bik. Tract ? I 4. Owner 5. Contractor Phone 6. Address 7. City ' State ; Zip 8. Building Type: Residential, ? Commercial O Institutional ? 9. Work Description: New`fl Add ? Alter ? Repair ? 10. Describe 11 No. Fixtures Water Closet No. Fixtures Cesspool/Drainfield l Bath tubs Septic Tank - - Lavatory Softner ? Shower Well _L Kitchen Sink Urinal/Bidet Other Laundry Tray I f Floor Drains I Drinking Ftn. , t Slop Sink Gas Piping Outlets ? _ 12. I hereby certify that the above information is true and correct, and I agree to comply with all ordinances and codes governing this type of work. Signed : for Rough Final Inspections: Date Insp. Date Insp. This is your permit when numbered and approved. Approved CITY OF EAGAN 454-8100 CITY UF EAGAN Remarks?'f U??=r??f r?7 ???& t Addition PARK RIDGE Znd Lot 11 eIk 1 Parcel 10 56751 110 Ol owner Street 1859 Coving*nn T•aIIP State Eagan, MN 55122 Improvement Date A Annual Years Payment Receipt Date STREETSURF. 1982 16.15 10 6. 0 C010 11 6-2 -$ STREETRESTOR. C 1985 32.80 15 459.20 GRADING SAN SEW TRUNK (rJ9?I 1982 159.37 I0.62 15 116.89 SEWER LATERAL 19$5 626. 16 41.74 15 584.42 WATERMAIN y6?1 1985 642 54 64.25 10 578.29 WATER LATERAL WATER AREA j$Z 159.37 10.62 15 116.89 STORM SEW TRK ? 1985 370.93 24.73 15 346.21 STORM SEW LAT 6 CURB & GUTTER SIDEWALK STREET LIGHT Roc-id Unit . WATER CONN. 500.00 9UILOING PER. 9bi SAC . PARK IN CITY OF EAGAN 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, Minnesota 55122-1897 (612) 681-4675 SITE ADDRESS: , Ic- i11tV t nN1 r:! t- I Ui,t . PIIPERMIT SUBTYPE: TYPE OF WORK: rr p PA ! R i k3lliiF' lNQ) kfli)I t Nto 'TIUN RECORD PERMIT TYPE: 11 ` `'' Permit Number: Date Issued: ' ' " PI APPLICANT: r-+ t , ... , ,;E. . ; tF?i.'? 447-:1!.I, Permlt No. Permit Holder Oate Talephone Ik ELECTRIC PLUMBING HVAC Inapectlon Date Insp. Commenta FOOTINGS FOUND FRAMING ROOFING ROUGH PLUM8ING PLBG AIR TEST ROUGH HEATING GAS SVC TEST INSUL GYP BOARD FIREPLACE FIREPLACE AIR TEST FINAL PLBG FINAL HTG ORSAT TEST 6LDG FINAL BSMT R.I. BSMT FINAL DECK FfG DECK FINAL CITY OF EAGAN I? 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, Minnesota 55123 (612) 681-4675 I SITE ADDRESS: INSPECTION RECORD PERMIT TYPE: Permit Number: Date Issued: i.. ?,'VIMh1"N tANf ? ???? p . i i?i?? ii?? ? PERMIT SUBTYPE: H!f I 1 i1 I Nil H":t10,{1 4fSllkrlt?a APPLICANT: I Y. I. I . L I Y.1 TYPE OF WORK: NI 1, INSPECTION .. . .. ,At??r? - ? I PermR No. Pe?mk Molder Deta Telephona k SI1N PLUMBING HVAC ELECTRIC ELECTRIC Inspection Daw Insp. Commentc FooUngsl Foundation Framing RooHng Rough Pibg. Rough Htg. Isul. Freplace Final Htg. Orsai Test Final Plbg. Plbg. InspeCtor- Notify Plumber COnet. M6ter EngrJPlen Bldg. Fnal Deck Ftg. ? W iw Deck Finai Well Pr. Disp. CITY OF EAGAN 3830 Pilot Knob Road P. O. Box 21199 Esgan, MN 55121 Zonlrq: -, , Owner. ro ?M /lddrcss: 1 Plumber. 3? a WATER SERVICE PERMR PERMIT NO.: Di1TE: No, of Units: 1 hr No.: Connection Chor . t? l? .(? U p d "'?iZ°: /lcoount De osit? n (? p Raoder No.: L) ? L? a d?f 0 Permit Fee: - 1 yrse !e csmply wuM dw Cify of Ep"¦ Surcharge: OirJiwasas. Mise. Charpes: -.'et c? r Totol: ? -? _ ' ? •? ' ?? c BY Dats Poid: Dote of Insp.: y J Insp,; CITY OF EAGAN sEWER SERVICE PERMIT 3830 Pilot Knob Road P. O. Box 21199 PERMIT NO.: '-'-.? r Eagan, MN 55121 pATE- 4-12 -6 5 Zonlnp: ? I No. of Units: Ownsr: ?,u6COn i'a?CB Add?ess: Slh Addi Plumber. I yM to oeMphr rdM !Iw Clep of Eson OndiwmseM. By Dore of Insp.; Comeetlon CJqege; 425• ?,,-, r+d Aooount Depostt: I S. 0 0 PennM Fw: • P'•- Surchoryr P ? _ Misc. Chorqm _ Totol: - Dab PoJd: This request wid 5 j.135 ???? ?t?? ??,? 3, v Requesl Dale Ftire Na_ ?upA-in?ins ion OReadY Now ill NolitY InsPec- ,? I7 No tor Mfhen ReadY /ti V+ Licensed Electncal Contractor I herepv repuest inspection of above elwc[riral work installed at: LJ Uwner -- C??Y Street Address, Box or Route No_ n .an °? g" & di ' ? ?j ?/7 ' ( . Township N or No. Range No• e tion . CountV Occupant I?INTi Phone No- se o? Power Supplier ,?- '4ddr?? ? Electrical Contractor ICompanv Nart-) ontractur's License No_ ?f d 14- O lation) Mailing Address (Comractor w Owner Msking A 24 N IS ? 4 ? Insta um ef tor/ ? Mlakillaiion l Ph°^e ont c i Authori - - ------ ? wcocrT?n?r wFnIIFST rllL NOT NINNESOTA STAT?ARD OF ELECTRICITY Griygs-MidwaY 8 d9. - Room N-191 1821 UniversilY Ave.. St. Paul, MN 55104 Phone (612) 297-2117 BE ACCEPiED Bll THE 5iA7F 60ARD UNLESS PROPEp INSPECTION FEE fS ENCLOSED_ 5i?3 ? REQUEST FOR ELEGTiaCAL INSPECTION E?)I? ' See inslruetions for complel,ng this lorw on 6aek of wllow coPY- 'V l B 2 9 Q Q 7 "X Below Work Coveted by This Fequest Qdd Rep. Type ot 8uildong Applisnces wi/sd Equipwient wire?l Home Range Temporary Service Duplex IKater Heater Ligfitiny Fiztures Apt. Building Dryer Electric Heatin Comnercial eldg. F?wnace 5i!o Unloader Industrial Bldg. Air Conditioner Bulk Milk Tank Farm OtnF?r pec? V Other lSDCr_ifyl t _r r Succ:ilv other oihe? ompute Inspeciron Fee 8elow p Fee ServiceEntraoceSiza k Fae Feeders?5ubteeders M Fee Circuits 0to200Am Oto30A 9 ZL? 9to30An Above 200 Arry?s 31 to 100 Amps 31 to lOQ A n4is wimmi Pool Above 100_Amps A6ove 100_A ranstormers T Irrigation 6oorrs Partial. Other F Re ?? .4? ig ?s s Special Inspec*_ion TOT I 7 ? O/ 7 P- Rough-in Date . t: ???,?.. he.ob? ? ve cerlil?r tAst the abo Final / D le ??Lp? hrs bse i n ? ssde. TAis requeat `A+e 18 nwnms ttom Joseph Tramonte 1859 Covington Lane Eagan, MN 55122 651.6811756 RECEG!!ED November 27, 2005 JoM Gorder, P.E. City of Eagan 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, MN 55122 N 0 V 2?; 2005 tAUHiV ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT Dear John: I would like to take this time to thank you for pursing and settling our wazer run off problem from the adjacent propeRy at 1855 Covington Lane. After five years of ineetings with neighbors affected by the water, and meetings between the City of Eagan and Dako[a County Parks we have finally obtained a soluCion. The four neighbors that were direcdy affected by the cunoff can finally put behind them, the unrest that has been caused over the years. After the last meeting on Apri14, 2005 between the City of Eagan, Dakota County Pazks, Patrice Rosinbaum, Rick Chodek, Julie Chodek, my wife Laur& and myself, we thought we might have a solutioa Unfortunately, as it turned out the Chodek's refused to participate once again. At this point you could have easily dropped the process and moved on, but along with Mike Adams and his people at Dakota County Pazks you stayed with it. We appreciate the effort and the cooperation between the City, and Dakota Counry Parks and the understanding oFthe frustration level that has been present during these past five years. Sincerely, ndams - Dakota County Parks Mayor Geagen - City of Eagan ............................ City 0f EaVflon Pat Geagan MAYOR Peggy Carlson Cyndee Fields Mike Maguire Meg Tilley COUNCIL MEMBEFS Thomas Hedges CRV ADMINISTflATOR MUNICIPAL CENTEFl 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, MN 55122-1810 651.675.5000 phone 651.675.5012fax 651.454.8535 TDD MAINTENANCE FAqIITY 3501 Coachman Point Eagan, MN 55122 651.675.5300 phone 651.675.5360fax 651.454.8535 TDD www.cityofeagan.com THE LONE OAK TREE The symbol of strength and growthin our community. September 15, 2005 Mr. Steve Sullivan Director Dakota County Parks Department 14955 Galaxie Avenue Apple Valley, MN 55124-8579 Re: Covington Lane Area/ Lebanon Hills Regional Park - Backyard Drainage Improvements Dear Mr. Sullivan: Please consider this letter as a request for consideration by Dakota County of a drainage swale construction on Lebanon Hills Regional Pazk (LHRP) property by Eagan residents to improve spring runoff pattems in the backyards of 1851, 1855 & 1859 Covington Lane. Historv of the Situation As you are awaze through conversations with the affected residents and various County and City staff, spring snowmelt from LHRP and area properties cunently pools on frozen ground in the backyazds of 1851 and 1855 Covington Lane, before discharging overland towazd the 1851 and 1859 Covington properties. This discharge has caused house property damage to both residences on more than one occasion. This past spring, your staff, Mr. Mike Adams in particular, kindly facilitated a meeting between the residents of 1851, 1855, and 1859 Covington Lane, and personnel representing Dakota County, in an attempt to resolve the situation. City staff was also in attendance for technical support if needed. At the meeting, Mr. Adams stated the County's position that it the LHRP and its drainage patterns existed before the residents' houses were built, and that the current drainage issue should be resolved on their properties. All parties left that meeting feeling that the issue could be resolved by a drainage swale on the private properties, with some plan assistance from the City. Subsequent to that meeting, the property owners at 1855 Covington Lane chose not to participate in the solution by not allowing construction on their property. Unfortunately, an adequate drainage swale to address the problem cannot be built on private property without construction on the 1855 property. ? Repuested Construction/ Easement This leads to the City's request for Dakota County's consideration of construction of the swale on LHRP property, without affect to the 1855 property. A sketch of the proposed swale grading is attached. The grading required will be minor, averaging approximately 1 foot in depth, with the deepest excavation at 1.5 feet to 2 feet. The swale will direct water westward to a location where it currently dischazges, but slightly changes the route in which it takes. Instead of being directed in the backyards very neaz the houses, the drainage will be maintained within LHRP properiy longer before discharging to an existing ravine which leads into properties further west along Covington Lane. Also, the requested easement document creating public easement over the proposed swale in favor of the City for its future maintenance will be forwazded under separate cover, for the County's consideration. If approved by the County, the 1851 and 1859 Covington Lane residents plan to hire a contractor to complete the work this fall, under the inspection of City staf£ Since this property will be covered by a City easement, a City permit to work in easement will be required and administered. Disturbance to LHRP will be restored to the County's satisfacrion. It is estimated that the excavation work will be completed in one day, with restoration also completed in one day. Thank you in advance for your consideration of this request. Please contact me if you require further information or have any questions at 651-675-5645 or j order(&cityofea an.com. Sincerely, John Gorder Assistant City Engineer Encl: Drainage Swale Sketch C: Tom Colbert, Director of Public Works Russ Matthys, City Engineer Patrice Kampmeyer, 1851 Covington Lane Richard Chodek, 1855 Covington Lane Joseph Tramonte, 1859 Covington Lane W E f o zo ?o ? ? CO,ANGT N LANE x000.00 Esisting Elavation OD.O Proposed Elevotlon Z Q 1847 o W c? a 1851 > Z 1855 167 86 0 0 0 1859 h aa' h^? ?b p? 1? GRADE 5' WIDE SWALE TO ELEV 938 75 (140' /- L G) i,+ ' -? "i9 +9 ? +9 +9 . . MATq1 EX. SIDE ELEVA71 NS '7- SLOPES NOT TO EXCEE O :1 ? HILL AL PAR ^ \ / ~ .. I?IT c ? ? i z1 ` CITY OFEAGAN PER PERMIT TYPE: 3830 Pilot Knob Road B U I L D I N G Eagan, Minnesota 55123 PermitNumber: 023650 (612) 681-4675 Date Issued: 0 5/ 19 / 9 4 SITE ADDRESS: 1859 CqVINGTQN LANE LOT: 11 BLOCK: 1 PARK RID6E 2ND P.T.N.: 10-56751-110-01 DESCRIPTION: Buikding'-Permit Type DECK Auilding Wt`zr.k 7ype NEW t ? -, 1 1 , v Q ? -.! ytiS L? 47 Hj ? ! i ? REMARKS: FEE SUMMARY: Base Fee $30.00 5urcharge ?.50 Tntal Fee $30.50 CONTRACTOR: OWNER: - Applicant - HEINRICH LINDA 1859 COVINGTON LN EAGAN MN 55122 (612)232-5131 T hereby acknowledge that I have read this information is correct and' agree ta comply Statutes end C3ty af Eagan Ordifianaes. ? •-' AP ATURE ? applicot3on and state that the with all app3.icable SCate of Mn. -j -AW LIIA (1'h-d ISSUED BY SIG A URE ' - : . • CITY OF EAGAN 1994 BUILDING PERMIT APPUCATION 0 681.4675 RECENED - { _P+'!_ 1 _3 i994 - -- SINGLE & MUITI-FAMILY 2 sets af plans, 3 registered site surveys, 1 copy of energy calcs. COMMERCIAL 2 sets of architectural & structural plans, 1 set of specifications, 1 copy of energy calcs. Penalty applies: 1) when permit is typed, but not picked up by last workinq day of month in which request is made, 2) address is changed or 3) lot change is requested once permit is issued. Date Valuation of work c-AW. ? Site Address:_ A gm tk"v i-e--. STREET SUITE !1 Tenant Name: (commercial only) IAT BLOCK LBD.?? Iv {J .1 q?_I `LP I \;tRI ,L. yu.? P.I.D. # Descri tion of work: Cl The applicant is: Owner ? Contractor ? Other (Describe) Name L Phone Property LAST FIRST lu) asa-s?3? - 4?jn70. Owner rw ' ? ? ? i Lt? Address ,t -- -- STREET STE # LG?fL?v-- ? Z L City State Zip Company Phone Co ntractor Address License # Exp. City State Zip Company Phone Architect/ Engineer Name Registration # Address ' City State Zip Sewer & water licensed plumber Processing time for sewer & water permits is two days once area has been approved. I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State ?of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. ? Signature of Applicant: L2r?,Lz-?r7T???? ' ENGINEERING - eoMPRNY, INC. 1000 C1lST 1461h STRCLT, cr-?rp?'?on • NORTN sc?ItE ?''=3?' T32.0: CENOTES EXI•_,TINC, EI?LVAT+cli 93t •d ) DEUOTES pRGPOSED ELEVATIOnA 1--- lNDICATE5 DiRECT1UN oF SuRFqCE DRAINA6E FINISHM GARqsE kt_ocp E Lt VATON = 9 35', S loT 11I SLOLK 1j PA42K R1pr?E 2Np AD??T?oN? DAKOTA CojNT'(/ MINNEZ-?OTA, ? CcViNGTON LANE 0 ? L°?5.00 R= yl7.?n7 03' 30 6z4.oi ? ro.o 2z.o F2oNT 93G.: I ?-_` BU?LCItJC. G T ?4?;.-i SEZL?r+C? P'r,- L10.1E ? ?? --?.? ?3s z .n z?. ? ,n --- °? ? I o PROPOSE c N ? °,p (_ i l N O W HOVSE u-, ?? izn A .e ?_- :- -`93_ : -c ` 93' a_• ? i'= ? ? 3 (93S.Z;I 51? DRqiNAc-E AND ;t VT}LIT\' EASEMEw1 ?940 0? ? - - ??. ? -r- ¢) (940.0) S89°3S 34 E htroby ctMity that thil is a trua and comct roprerentation ot a traet ot and as rhoxn'qnd dercribed horson.. J1m preparvd by me on thts 2`=. dar ot 1965, ' . . Cof1SVlTiNO tN01N(lS rtnt+r+(ns e„a ?nHD Iunv(vons Clx1NSVIlLC, ItiNNCSOTA 57737 1'H 472-3000 Ce r,? z?' c a,? ? __._..'?.y ? 4*7 1985 BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION - CITY OF EAGAN NOTE: ALL CONTRACTORS NUST BE LICENSED NITH THE CITY OF EAGAN INCLUDE 2 SETS OF PLANS 3 CERTIFICATES OF SURVEY 1 SET OF ENERGY CALCULATIONS - ao 77?d? To Be Used For: Sinqle Family Valuation: 54;99O-.5$-Date: Site Address: 1859 Covington Lane Lot: 11 Block 1 Sect/Sub Parcel ll OFFICE USE ONLY Park Ridg@rect a n/p Remodel Repair Enlarge ? Occupancy Zoning ? Type of Const ? ll of Stories , Length ? _ Depth Sq Ft Owner Robert Heinrich Move Demolish Address Grade City/Zip Code Phone 780-4620 Contractor Ruscon Homes, Inc. Address 14530 Pennock Ave City/Zip Code Apple Valley, MN 55124 Phone 432-1433 Mark Nage17 Areh./Engr. Probe Engineering 14570 Pennoc Ave Address 1000 E. 146th St. Apple Valley, MN 55124 City/Zip Code Burnsville, MN 55337 APPROVALS Assessments Permit 3(04.00 Water/Sewer Su^charge 77g So Police Plan Review 18Z.? Eire SAC SZS. w Engr 1,Iater Conn 500.? Planner Water Meter (43.°? Council oad Unit ZE?CJ. ? Bldg Off? Parks APC Treatme,t P2 132.°r Variance TOTAL Phone 0 432-2044/432-3000 C CITY OF EAGAN No 9987 3830 PiIM Knob Road, P.O. Box 21•199, Eagan, MN 55721 PHONE: 454-8100 /?- U BUILDING PERMIT Receipt # ,1 ? M w" 1er Sj' DWG/GAR Esr. Vnlue $77.000 Date M T 19j5- A4CH 2'-- e 1859 COVINGTON LN Erect R Occupancy Rl Site Addresn k 1 ceclSub. PARK RIDGE 2 11 131 Remodel ? i ? Zoning TypeafCOnst. V a Lot Repa r Parcel No. Enlarge ? No. Stories Move ? Length 48 RUSCON HOMES INC pemolish ? oepth 51 W Name 14530 PENNOCK AVE Grade ? 59. Ft• ? Address APPLF VP.L phone 432-1433 Install ? city ppyro.ala Fees ? Neme SAME Assessment 364.00 Permit u? Address ? Woter E Sew. 3$ 50 SurcFarqe . City Phone h Plen Reviaw_ju.+-00 ROBE ENGR police Firo 5pC 25- 00 Name PENNOCK AVE Eny, WaterConn. 5 0 0 - 0 0 = 432-2054 E VAL Ph Vlanr?er WoterMeter ?+1- n0 one Rood Unit 2R DL-0 0 Council ve read this opplicotion and stote that t 1 h h gldy, pff, 3 2 ?. 85 T. P. 1.3 2. ? ? a a I hereby ackrowledga t rre[f and ogree ro wmply with all applicable i APC „S7?OR4 ?i? Total s co the inlormotion Sfate of Minrwsofc Stotutes and Cily of Eagon Ordinances. Var. Date _ Sipnoturo o4 Permittea RUSCON HOMES INC on the axpress conditlon tho+ A Buildinq Permit Is iuued to: ?' r ?f ordunca with all oppliCObl Stote of M i ( tes ord City of Eaflon Ordimntes. [? / n acc oll work shall 6e done ? ?/ ? ? Buildirp Otficial 17 ? . - i 4.+ , . . AbBE ENGINEEAING ? COMPANY, INC. L woa uur ttien stnceT, COHSUtTINO tHOIHt(fIf PLANNlAS and IAHD ?URVIY011S EUfINSVILLC, IdIHHLSOTA 65337 PN 432'7000 Cer,?if?'ca,?c A S'r.La,Ye c jg4'aj Ih?cr'L,oc'tan • NORTH sulL£ I"= 3e `932,0 : CENOYES EXISTiNG ELEVA1?otA j 93Z16 ) DEUOTES pRGPpSEJ 6LEVATION --me--- INDICqTES DiRECTION OF SuRFACE 'DRAINA6'c FINISHED GARA6E r.EpoR eLEYAT10N = 935.5 LoT I 1 f BLDC.k l? 4ARK R\p6E 2ND ADPITtON/ DAKOTA covMT+(? MINNE2-0TA, ? coyiu?-roN l?A EN ? :? N O -? lP rq? •Q? J ) (940.0 L=(o5.00 i?` 9/?.la7 o ' ?935.5 _ l 2z.o I ? ? P J a I CI35 4 O pROPOSEF I I T HoUSE w ,4 W -? YM S? ?3o FKoN 7 BV ILDIN6 SE-TGpCK L.WE ' Z vi (? - - ? i ? o c, 7S Zff , ., Ss9°35 34 E DRAINAGE AND uT1uTY ErSEMENI I htroby ceMity that thi• is A trun and corriat rtprasintation ot a traet ot land as •hoxn'and describad htrton.. Ai pr.pared by m• on this `rd dar ot /1?.a??-?f ? 1 f 85 ? ' . • ' ltinne lon Not 11?Og'5 PE aosE ? NGINEEAING COMPANV, INC. L ^1000 [A7T 1461h STRECT, coksutTiHO iHOtHUns ' PIRHHtfIS ond AND ?Uf1YlYOflS EIMINSvILLC, M1HHC30TA 35337 PN 432'3000 Ce 7-91Z,I?'? 1.4amt .Dz•=ke? 0n . NORTH LoT i lI BL?CC k 1? PAFtK R\p?E 2Np ADD??o?i DAKOTA couNZy? MINNEZOTA, ?-- ? CGV?NGTON LAi?1E . .r_ 917.67 p4° 03' 30 931. 0 o_ - ? a ?? q3v,5 ? I ? \?C zz.o ?e I N ? e^ ? ?'c^?'ap md5 L6.o/ 0 pROA0SE0 vl w 4?.u -? ? 932CENOTEC )k1`-TINC. :G?V0.TtCN 432.e ? DEUpTES PRDP tD ?EVATiON -90-- +NDic471 es DiRtcTlGtv OF SufZFqCE DRAINA6E FINISHED fA6 LppR ELt YAT1oN - q3/e,5 I ?q3v•=-??, °- ?'3o FRcniT o gv??c?r?v SE'TC3ACK ' Z l vi { Z- !n W W ' -- i - (.qa?•?` I5 DRqINAGE AND ? I UT1lJTY EASfMEt,:? 7S Z60 , ., 58q°3S 34 E I heteby ctrtity thAt thli im a trua and com%tct roprasintation ot a'LMCt of land a• oho+m'and deicribed hereon,. Ao prep4rad by fie on this z?_ dar of /??+??1 ? 1! 85. ' • s ' _ ltinn e Itt o Xo, A610:5 . . .??.: , .. . ?; . . . . . , • -- - - ' EXTERIOR ENVELOPE kVERAGE "U" COMPUTATION ? _ '4, r . ? ? ? ' r, . _ ` . . -. ? . OWNER .. -- - . ? _ ?y. . . . ss: SITE ADDRESS _ . ' .. s` . OATE ?r l u . . ] - y .'. PHONE3Z= GOriTRACTOR °??or:? ?- d*?t? 1? . . . - . . . •?.. .., _ . . . • - •- Determine working square faotage of eacb. 1. Total exposed wall area ...... Z01 S sq, ft. x'tI1" ? 271 2. Tota) roaf/ceiling area .... I Zbb sq. -ft."*x Z.o 6 = ?I ;•2 Total exposed wall area above floor a. Total wall wtndow area ..................:........ loP, b. Total daor area ................................. ' • c. Total sliding glassdooraraa .................... . 7 8 ? • • d: Total fireplace wall area.......................... - e. Total wall framing area (average IDA)........... 119 •. : f. Total net wall area above floor ................. Isoz • g. Total rim joi st area ........................... l 2 2 Total exposed foundation area ... h. Tota1 foundation window area............ i. Toal net fioundation area abpve arade ............ Detenaine "U" value af eacn wal] s_e^ent. a. 104? X olUst ??- _ 35L(i X ??U" .13 = < l. - c. -7 2s x "u" a. ? X „o„ e. 119 X,lu° . 1 D = 11. 9 f. 15 03 x °u° 9. 122 x "u" h. x Plu's 1. / LI X uUn .n43 3. ...Total = I. 2.. • If item 13 is the same as, or less than item #1, you have met the intent of 53C 60015(c)2. Totalexposed roof/ceiling area N, , ` •? Total gross roof/ceiling area = . -- - • . :.. j. Total skylight area ........................ ?-- .. k. Tota1 roof/ceiling framing area ............ i 2a 1. Total net insuiated roof/cei7ing area....... lbE)o Determine "U" value for each roof/cei]ing segment. _.. • _.. . . . ... . . {? .. / .. V tllVlu « Q . ? ? /I k. IZO Xltust . 07-4' Q? 1. 1 Oe"A Xioull .. . 4 ..................................Tota1 ' r . ? Zxk e"OtD, IZ.3z14jusuj.ovEZ: .rz;sb i(-"e 3.i4 , If total of #4 is the same as, or less than #2, you have met the intent of 58C G006(01. . . . . A. . . . To utiltzed the total envelope system method, the values-established 6y the sum of items #3 and 04 shalt not be greater than the sum of itens 61 and /2. - '•. . .. } 2. _ 3, i- ¢, _ MATERIdLS Ezteriar Air 5lding Material 3heathing Insulatioa - Sheetrock InterioT Air 5tuds Rim Conc. Blka. Therm. Resistance "R" hl{r 4M?? . 17 1. 25 +it = ts-zl ? _. . . ? . :? . -XI CITY OF EAGAN 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, Minnesota 55122-1897 (612) 681-4675 SITE ADDRESS: P.I.N.: 10-56751-110-01 DESCRIPTION: PERMIT PERMITTYPE: auzLorNc Permit Number: 029994 Date Issued: 0 5/ 19 J 9 7 1859 COVINGTON LAN[ LOT: 11 BLOCK: 1 PARI< RIDGE 2ND ,",°>?? ? (ROOFZnic? ,9uilding-.,Permit Type +"Building k?ox,k Type G'EYtSi15 L'64t'2 -..? ? "•:?' ; 3a._,r,?. SF (MISC.) REPATR 434 ALT. RESIDENTIAI. t ? L'_ ! - , f?' F ;J i =C ai, REMARKS: FEE SUMMARY: VAI.UAiTON $1,200 Base Fee Surcharye Totel Fee $40.25 i:40.85 CONTRACTOR: - npplicant - sT. I.IC.OWNER: LAKEI'2 CONST 14473572 2005390 NEINRICH ROSERT ?16011. WEST PNE Sc :1859 COVINGTON LN ARIOR LAKE MN 55372 EAGHN mN 55122 4(612) 447-3572 (612)454-9045 ... . . . . _ ,._.. ._.. .;:. . . ,.. . . ... ._ .. ... I hereby acknaWledge thaz I haY:+e reatf` this appji0atiart an-d s.tate thct T.he infiorriation as corraat and agr=ee -ta camply !Jtsi.th a1l aPPlicable State af Mn. St????e and City, af Eag.an Ordarianc$srt ' ? ? ?i? Re?. m- ? -- APP ICANT/PERMITEE SIGNATURE ISSUED W. SI NAT E 4 1997 BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION (RESIDENTIAL) a? ? CITY OF EAGAN ? ? 3830 PILOT KNOB RD - 55122 ? 6874875 New Construction Reauirementa RamodeVReoeir Reouiremente ? 3 registered ake surveya • 2 copies of plens (indude beam & window sizea; poured fid. tlesign; etc.) ? 1 energy ealculations ? 3 eopies of tree prexrvation plan if bt platted after 7!1l93 roqu'ved: _Yes _ No/ ? 2 eopies of plan ? 2 afte surveys (ex[erior additions 8 dedcs) • 1 energy calwlations for heated edORions DATE: Sf (S `? 7 CONSTRUCTION COST: DESCRIPTION OF WORK: STREET ADDRESS: LOT -4-_ BLOCK CJ PROPERTY Name: L-t"JQU tt?ni2« Phone #: ?t L( - 70 owNeR Street Address• ES9 <-?;7, ys^ Lc-,? CitY: State: /4 ' Zip: S 5 1?- "? coNrRacTOR Company: Lrr kiliz Co ?- s '{2u Phone #: 1*4 -?- Street Address: I(a °t f4? License #: 70 °_S 3 90 0 City: C2 ? o? L Ic 5tate: 1M? Zip: S ?- 3 7'1 ARCHITECTI Company: Phone #: ENGINEER Name: Registration #: Street Address: City: State: Zip: Sewer 8 water licensed plumber (new construction ony): . Penalty applies when address change and bt change are requested once permit is issued. I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the iMorma ' n rtect and agree to comply with I applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. - Signature of Applicant ? - C OPFICE USE ONLY Certificates of Survey Received _ Yes _ No Tree Preservation Plan Received _ Yes _ No _ Not Required ?_ SUBD./P.I.D.#: SsAl+ R?Jnb Lk 2000 BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION (RESIDENTIAL) 1A CITY OF EACAN ?A 3830 PILOT KNOB RD • 35122 651-881-4875 New Conehuction Reaulremenb RemotleUReoair Reaulremenh > s regutered Yre wrveYs 3h4rAnp sq. IR of bt, 84 n. of twuse ? 2 coVie: a plan antl gfi rooled arew (20% rtwadmum tot covemae allowedl Q 0 1 sef of energy calculoMOns for haated addlXons D 2 coples of plans (ahow beam 8 window slzes; poured fnd tlesign; etC.) 1 site wrvey for exdedor additlons & decks > 1 tet of energy calcWaNOro > 3 caples W hea preservatlon plan U lot plalted aRer 7/1/93 DATE: 4?4/n? CONSTRUCfION COST: ???00 C;0 DESCRIPTION OF WORK: PP??k7'f STREEf ADDRESS: LOT: -?- BLOCK: ? SUBD./P.I.D. M: Name: Phone C PROPERTY I.cs1 First OWNER Sheet CNy Stafe: Zlp: ComPanY Phone p: 7e 3 (area code) CONTRACTOR Sheet Address: IJcense # .?O?Exp. .-3 car _ 5 T state: zip: ? ? 7G ARCHITECT/ ENGINEER Company: Name: Telephone N: ( ) Sheet Address: ReglshaHon Y: citY Sfate: Sewedwater licensed plumber (If lnstallina sewer/waterl: Phone #: Lp: I herebY acknowledye that I have read this appncaHon, state thaf ihe bformallon is cortect, and agree to comply wHh a0 appncable Stafe of Minnesota SMlutes and Ciy of Eagan Ordlnances. Signalure of ApplicanY? J OFFICE USE ONLY Certiflcates of Survey Received _ Yes _ No Tree Preservation Pian Received _ Yes _, No _ Not Required 2/44 CZTY OF EAGAN APPLICATION FOR PERMIT SESaER AND/DR WATER CONNECTIODJ (PLEASE PRINT) 1) PF.OPEfYtY ApDRESS: 18$9 COVinqt•+n r ano LEGaI. DESGRI°TIC:I: 11 - 1, Park Ridae %?vD1v.:xi.uDaivision or Tax Parcel I.D. Ntsnk ir E{?- '=_:G S`=CP :2E, DaT' G=' ORIGi 1AL : iiILDLNG P=--_•ST ISSU?NCz': P.4=S? :' :^`,Ii:r./Fro°CSZE) L=: El R-1 SDIGL.t: rPYLILY ...-.--•• -'--, ? R-2 CUPLE{ (ZS<O W ITS) ? R-3 TC4drII-IOUSE ('I'FIl2F^ + UNITS) ( WITS) ? R-4 FLpAR1I'=i'/CONID(1?]Ti]I[.nI ( Wi TTS) ? CCCIAEtCIAL/RETAII,/OFFICE ? LMUSZRLIL II INSTITUTIONAL/GOVF.RDpMENr 2) AppL_TC%N'T (PLEASE PRlHi) NAME; Ruscon Homes, Inc. ADDRESS: 1453U Pennock Ave. CITY, STATE, ZIP: Apple Vallev MN 55124 PxaNE: 432-z439 3) pi,[,^-igg; PLEASE PAIN?) r1P.ti1E: Star Plumbixtg , ADDRESS: 1018 Mound Springs Ter. CITY, STATE, ZIP; Bloomington, MN 55+20 PHOiVE: $$4-4149 pLUMBER LICENSE q 3329M a ) oc?Urarrr/a.rrez NAhfE: ADDRESS: CITY, STA'I'E, ZIP; PFfQ:IE: aatNr) FOR CITY USE 04LY PLUN.BERS LICENSE: ? Aetive Q Expired Q Nat af NecaSd arr tn 5) INpIG;TE WHICIi PEPh1IT IS BEII`'G R£QUESTEp: FLI CO:?TIECi'ION 'Iq CITY SES^TER E] CO:.^IEXTIOV 'Ib CITY WATER ? C1n'.ER (PLEASE DFSCRIBE) bl L`:DIGGa:: 0:X: 7) SIcz"ATL--?Z; ? PLEASE F?OID APPROVM PERtitIT FOR PICF:-UP BY OPIE ? p°IFaSE +TAIOVID PER,IIT TO 1, 2.(]3) 4 AEWE (Circle one) DATE: !?l61:?i11lA?i?l?Llfraala4?!ss.sai. . . .. .. . . . . . •. , " ' . ... r ? o r r:s?:a r!? a r.i wr E.?:r ?sri ? a? ? rsa?ica?ca?r s F 0 R C I T Y U 5 E O N L Y PERti1IT '-` ISSUED ? F°_ES: $ S°;qEn Ovp\lT?y (I;IC:.;;DE SUP.CHARCc) $ / 6•??Q . WATER PERMIT (INCLUDE SURCHARGE) $ WATER METER/COPPERHORN/OUTSIDE READER $ WATEP. TAP (I.ICLUDE CORPORATIODI S;OP) $ SEWE4 TAP $ ???"•-?--s? ACCOUNT DEPQSIT - SEWER $ ACCOUNT DEPOSIT - WATER $ WAC $ SAC $ TRUNK WATER ASSESSMENT $ TRUNK SEWER ASSESSMENT $ LATERAL•BENEFIT/TRUNK SEWER $ LATERAI. BENEFIT/TRUNX WATER $ OTHER $ TOTAL $ AMOUNT PAID/RECEIPT # AOES UTILITY CON NECTION REQUIRE EXCAVATION IN PUBLIC RIGiiT OF WAY? C? ES IF YES, THEN A"PERMIT FOR WORK WITHIN' PUBLZC ROADWAY" MUST BE ISSUED SY THE NO ENGINFERING DIVISZON. LSST AS A CONDZ- TION. i SUBJECT TO TFIE FOLLO;•7ING CONDITIONS: 1 APPRpVED BY: TITLE: DATE: ^ FJm "tin w w ! Ntsu mmoa mkft mt+ w mw aJ! wm Rw ow . m w m iq m iR OI.a fiFm 7a vklA w_a v! No O! s:A ws m 3 copies otTree Preservation Plan if IW platted affer 711l93 Rim Joist Detail Options selection sheet (bidgs with 3 or less unb Date 5 / Zg / bA Construction Cost " t SiteAddress 16"A Cc7wn q- }?n ?SiYIC UnidSte # ELl CW? (?1 5512L DescriptionofWork Lt(y)Ve• 9 mU11G1 pml Iri bQ?Aay-d Mulfi-Family Bidg _ Y_ N Fireplace(s) 0 _ 1 _ 2 Property Owner Ja5 1'1 01'd (.QL1.(Cl.. l r ?C Telepbone #((051) (051- ? 15(--A ?tl cc61- 5 2-(os5 Contractor Address i 5Ll5o City State Zip 55 12-Q Telephone Z) O / COMPLETE THIS AREA ONLY IF CONSTRUCTING A NEW BUILDING - Minnesota Rules 7670 Cateeorv 1 ota Rules 7672 Energy CAde Category . Residential Ventilation Category 1 Wo 7 Energy Code Worksheet (?J submissian type) Submitted i7?ed • Energy Envelope Calculations Submi V oA Have you previously constructed a building in Eagan with a si n? Y ? If so, 25% plan review fee applies. , ?Licensed Plumber Mechanical Contractor Sewer/Water Contrpctor elephone #( Telephone #( Telephone # ( I hereby apply for a Residential Building Pernut and acknowledge that the information is complete and accurate; that the work will be in conformance with the ordinances and codes of the City of Eagan and the State of MN Statutes; I understand this is not a permit, but only an application for a permit, and work is not to start without a permit; that the work will be in accordance with the approved plan in the case of work which requires a review and ' LQt,L.ra Trct.?)onWe. Printed Name \ Applj*Ys Signature OFFICE USE ONLY Sub Types ? Ot Foundation ? 07 05-plex ? 13 18-plex x 20 Pool ? 02 SF Dwelling p 08 06-plex ? 16 Fireplace ? 21 Porch (3-sea.) ? 03 01 of _ plex ? 09 07-plex ? 17 Garage ? 22 Porch/Addn. (4-sea.) ? 04 02-plex ? 10 08-plex ? 18 Deck ? 23 Porch(screen/gazebo) ? OS 03-plex ? 11 10-plex ? 19 Lower Level ? 24 Storm Damage ? OB 04-plex ? 12 12-plex Plbg_v or_ N ? 25 Miscellaneous Work Types ? 31New ? ? 32 Addition O ? 33 Alteration ? ? 34 Replacement Valuation o-o Census Code SAC Units # of Units # of Bldgs Type of Const _ Footings (new bldg) _ Footings (deck) _ Footings (addition) Foundation Drain Tile Roof Ice & Water Final _ Framing _ Fireplace _ R.I. _ Air Test _ Final _ Insulation Approved By: ? 30 Accessory Bldg ? 31 EM. Alt - Multi ? 33 Ext. Alt - SF ? 36 Multi Misc. 35 Int Improvement ? 38 Demolish Interior ? 44 Siding 36 Move Building ? 42 Demolish Foundation ? 45 Fire Repair 37 Demolish Bui{ding* ? 43 Reroof ? 46 Windows/Doors 'Demolition (Entire 81d g) - Give PCA handout to applicant Occupancy MCES System Zoning City Water Stories Booster Pump Sq. Ft. PRV Length Fire Sprinklered Width REQUIRED INSPECTIONS _ FinaUC.O. _ Final/No C.O. _ Plumbing HVAC Other ? Pool Jc Ftgs _ Ait/Gas Tests ?Final _ Siding _ Stucco _ Stone _ Bnck _ Windows _ Retaining Wall Building Inspector Base Fee Surcharge Plan Review MC/ES SAC City SAC Utility Connection Charge S&W Permit & Surcharge Treatment Plant License Search Copies Other Total PO(?L? S24.-1 s POOL PERMIT - APPLfCAT10N SUBMITTAL REQUiREMENTS Address: ZS5'1 U;7' ati e, Applicarrt Name: `10<?. £ ?-Gt,+afa Tr?.?r+on-?e- d GENERAL fNFORMAtION o ¢z ' v ? ,? ? ? Applicant - name, address, phone & fax numbers, signature p ? Property owner name ,0 ? ? Legal description and address of properry ? ? 0 North arrow, scale (1" = 30' or 40') and date ? ? Location and name of all streets adjacent to properiy ? ? 0 Site Plan drawn to scale showing location oP house, pool and other existing or proposed structures fd' 0 ? Direetional drainage arrows (existing and proposed) ELEVATIONS Existinsa ? ? ? House wmers ? ? Property comers ? ? ? On property lines at point of ineasured dimension to pool (see below) ' ? ? ? s greatest height If applicabte, ground elevation at each end of retaining wa11s and at wall Proaosed ? ? Finished pool deck comers C) ? ? Top of retaining walls (if any) and at each different elevation (if it changes) 0 ? ? Pool bottom (or max. depth) pd,ve, dr,,,,,d _ DIMENSIONS Existin A ? ? All property/lot lanes Proaased ? ? Pool ,2f ? Pool pius integrated deck/patio ,?ck to lot lines and house ??? Shortest distance from outside edge of poo Reviewed: _?.--- G:FORMS/Pool Pmnit ChadclisU06-02A4 . , OBe j`- eNGGlNCCfllNG CpFLnNHins° ?a°[nHoftziunvivons ? COMPRNY, INC. l ?..?1690 C113T 1461h STRELT, EUftHSViLLC, IIIHNC70TA 50337 1'H 432'7000 Cer0'C^Q,I? o n - NORTH O : CENOTES EXISTINC. EIcVA'ttoN 3Z .a ) UEUOTES pRfippSFp ELEVATIONI -r- fNDICATES DiRECTiCN pF SuPF'ACE pRA1NA6=- FINI5HEb GAPcqSE kLOCP r=LE YATlO N = 93 5- S LoT I I f BI..OCk 1j FARK R"L>E 2ND AooiTtior,?, DAKOTA Ccjr1TY? MINNE?fJ'fA , ? CcViNGTON ?ANE 17 ?.--- V? R= p = 4° 03' 30 ?g3i 2? _ ? L y ?931,1? ` mlo ?9'5.5) i 2z.o 43G.'• ? fi I 3 l' I ?•,`P -''? ?935.?? Z v- 9 u? z?..o I ? > A ? I ? PRUPOSE C E N 0 _ ? ? NOU? w t !A•0 ? ? ?y3 ¢• z? . r ?a 3 . ?935- Z ? I I `Y ? p I ? i 5 589 35?34?E ??° 3p' F 2pN T BVILLW'?? SE'TGACK Uro.1E • z N --- o W .? , DRqINqc-E AraD UYIUTY EASEMEta7 el/* hwrybr ctrti[y thAt thle !e A trva and correot rwprarontation oC a tract of nd as ihovn'And de.crtbed hvreon,. 11e preptir+d by me on thii zon/ da ot 19 85 , • . Y 19 RECEIVED ? HANBERY & CARNEY, P.A. ATTORNEYS AT lAW DONNA E. HANBERY DOUGLAS J. CARNEY ROBERT P. SCHWARTZ DOUGIASS E. TURNER August 9, 2006 33 SOUTH SIXTH STREET, SUITE 3725 MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55402 PHONE (612) 340-9855 FAX(612) 340-9446 Mr. John Gorder City of Eagan 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagar., b1N 55122-1897 Re: Joseph and Laura Tramonte, 1859 Covington Lane Cjur File No. 5272-001 Dear Mr. Uorder: AUG 14 2006 EHGHN ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT WRITER'S DIRECT DIAL NUMBER 612-338-7770 Enclosed is a subpoena duces tecum requesting documents that the City may have in regard to the Super Flood of 2000 that relates to 1859 Covington Lane and 1855 Covington Lane and other information it may have regazding disputes between the parties. This oftice represents Joseph and Laura Tramonte in a lawsuit against the Chodeks in which my clients have made several allegations against the Chodeks for damages they have suffered due to their conduct and behavior. My clients have filed the lawsuit in Dakota County District Court, Court File No. 19-C2-06-7025, and the parties are now involved in the discovery phase of this litigation. After speaking with my client, I understand there have been ongoing meetings and correspondence between the Chodeks and the City of Eagan regarding the Super Flood of 2000 as well as other real property disputes that Mr. Chodek alleged. One of the main issues in this lawsuit is a boundary dispute that has arisen between the Chodeks and the Tramontes whereby Mr. Chodek removed several trees on Mr. Tramonte's property, claiming that the boundary that had existed between the parties for years had somehow changed and the trees?hat Mr. Tramonte had planted were on Mr. Chntlek's property. One of the things we are trying to leazn in this lawsuit is whether Mr. Chodek ever mentioned or alleged to the Ciry of Eagan that there was a boundary dispute between t:ne parties and whether the City has any information as to an alleged boundary dispute between the Tremontes and the Chodeks. It is our position that the boundary has been well established and demazked for years and this was an attempt by Mr. Chodek to enact some revenge against Mr. Tremonte for reasons that are unknown at ihis rime. The subpoena I have enclosed includes the entire file the City of Eagan may have as it relates to the Super F'lood of 2000 and any information regarding the addresses of 1855 Covington Lane, Eagan, Minnesota, and 1859 Covington Lane, Eagan, Minnesota. In addition, I request any and all DET/cas070706 Johti Gorder August 9, 2006 Page 2 documents the City may have regarding any further correspondence that Mr. Chodek may have made to the City regarding any other disputes with Mr. Tramonte or any other neighbors with whom Mr. Chodek may have had disputes. If you have any questions, please feel free to give me a call. If there are advance copying chazges required for any of these documents, please so advise me and I will forward a check to cover those costs for the Ciry of Eagan at the same time I pick the documents up from the City. Very tr )urs, ? , % D GLASS E. cc: Joe Tremonte DETcas080906 State of Minnesota County of DAKOTA k Joseph Tramonte, and Laura Tramonte Plaintiff / Petitioner and Richard M. Chodek, and Jule A. Chodek Defendant / Respondent TO: 7ohn Gordec Citv of Eagan, 3830 Pilot Knob Road. E¢an. MN 55122 Name Address Minn. R. Civ. Pro. 45 El You are commanded [o appear as a wimess in the district court to give testimony at Cne place, date, and time specified below. Place of Testimony Courtroom Date and Tune ? You aze commanded to appear at the place, date and time specified below to testify at the taking of a deposition in the above case. Place of Deposition Date and Time ? You are commanded to produce and permit inspection and copying of the listed documents or objects at the place, date and time specified 6elow (attach list of documents or objects if necessary): Any file that the City of Eagan may have, including but not limited to: any and all documents that relate to the super flood of 2000 relating to the addresses 1859 Covington L,ane and 1855 Covington Lane, Eagan, Minnesota; any and all correspondence from Richard and/or Julie Chodek to the City oF Eagan regarding the flood or any alleged disputes with neighbors, specifically the neighbor at 1859 Covington Lane. Any correspondence from the City of Eagan to Richard and/or Julie Chodek; and any correspondence relating to Joseph and Laura Tramonte's property located at 1859 Covington Lane, Eagan, Minnesota. Any and all verbal and/or written complaints made by the Chodeks to the City of Eagan. Place Date and Time O° You are commanded to permit inspection of the following premises at the date and time specified below. Premises Date and Time City of Eagan, Pilot Knob Road 8/16/06 9:00 a.m. NOTE: FAILURE TO OBEY A SUBPOENA WITHOUT BEING EXCUSED IS A CONTEMPT OF COURT. Civil Subpoena Page 1 of3 Revised: 1/2006 District Court Judicial District: FIRST Court File Number: C2-06-7025 Case Type: Civil SUBPOENA IN A CIVIL CASE (COMMAND TO APPEAR) www. courts. state.mn.us/ctforrns Z d Signature of Cou dministrator lamti s ttome / Defendant's Date Attorney (Circle) Douglass E. Turner Hanbery & Carney, P.A. 33 South Sucth Street, Suite 3725 Minneapolis, MN 55402 612-340-9855 SEAL (if issued by Court Name, Address and Phone Number (if issued by Attorney as an Administration) Officer of the Court) Civil Subpoena Page 2 of 3 Revised: 1/2006 www.courts.state.mn.us/ctforms RETURN OF SERVICE State of Minnesota County of I hereby certify and retum that on I served a copy of this subpoena upon the person named thereon. Service was made by: ? personally handing to and leaving with him or her a true and correct copy; or ? leaving a tive and cocrect copy at his or hei usual place of residence Address with a person of sui[able age and discretion. Name of Person NOTARY STAMP, SIGNATURE AND DATB Subscribed and Sworn/Affirmed to before me on Date , 2a By Title NOTE: If served b someone other than a Law Enforcement Officer, si namre must be notarized. Rule 45, Minnesota Rules of Civil Procedure, provides thar. • A subpoena may be served by any person who is not a party and is no[ less than 18 years of age. • Service of a subpoena shall be made by delivering a copy to the person named in the subpoena or by leaving a copy at the persods usual place of abode with some person of sui[able age and discretion who resides there. • A witness who is not a parry ro[he action or an employee of a party (except a person appointed pursuant to Rule 30.02(f)) and who is required to give testimony or produce documen[s relating to a profession, business, or trade, or relating ro knowledge, information, or facts ob[ained as a result of activities in such profession, business, or trade, is entitled to reasonable compensation for the tune and expense involved in preparing for and giving such testimony or producing such documents and is entitled to have the anount of those expenses deterr.mined prior to complyine with the subpoena. ? A person is not obtigated to attend as a witness in a civil case unless one day's attendance and travel fees are paid or tendered in advance (see fees below), unless the subpoena is issued on behalf of the state oF Minnesota, or the state's officer or agent. Fees to be paid ro wimesses shall be as follows (Minn. Stat. § 35722): • For attending in any action or proceeding in any cour[ of record or before any ofFicer, person or board authorized the take examination of witnesses, $20 for each day. • For roundtrip travel estimated from the wimess's residence at 28 cents per mile. If a witness lives outside the state, travel costs shall be estimated from the bouridary line of the sta[e where Ihe wimess crossed into Minnesota at 28 cents per mile. (Additional fees may be available for out of state witnesses). In any proceeding where a parent or guardian attends the proceeding with a minor witness and the parent or guardian is not a witness, one parent or guardian shall be compensated in those cases where wimess compensation is mandatory under Minn. State. § 357.22, and may be compensated when compensation is discretionary under those sections. No more than a combined total of $60 may be awarded to the parent or guardian and minor wimess. Minn. Stat. § 357242. Civil 5ubpoena Page 3 of 3 Revised: 1/2006 www.courts. state.mn.us/ctforms