The URL can be used to link to this page

1740 Cliff Rd PERMIT City of Eagan Permit Type: Building 3830 Pilot Knob Rd Permit Number: EA086231 Eagan, MN 55122 . Date Issued: 09/19/2008 (651) 675-5675~~~ EPermit Category: ePermit www.ci.eagan.mn.us lflflUl tflflLLL Site Address: 1740 Cliff Rd Lot: 6 Block: 1 Addition: Section 32 PID 10-03200-060-01 Use Description: Sub Type: e-Reroof Construction Type: Work Type: Replace Description: House & Garage Census Code: 434- Occupancy: Zoning: Square Feet: 0 Comments: If there is no ice protection inspection prior to final, you must meet inspector with ladder and flat bar. Pictures are not acceptable in lieu of inspections. Fee Summary: BL - Base Fee $3K $88.50 0801.4085 Surcharge - Based on Valuation $3K $1.50 9001.2195 Valuation: 3,000.00 Total: $90.00 Contractor: -Applicant - Owner: Action Roofing & Siding LLC Steven H Mustad 1315 Southview Boulevard 1740 Cliff Rd S St Paul MN 55075 Eagan MN 55122 (651) 457-2642 I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Applicant/Permitee: Signature Issued By: Signature CITY OF EAGAN Remarks c?cs Addicion Lot Blk Parcei 10 03204 060 41 owner-` treet 1740 Cliff Rd, state Eagan,MIN 55122 Improvement Date Amount Annual Years Payment Reeeipt Date p ? STREET SURF. ' Imp. 1981 1128.60 112.86 10 -• ?? STREET RESTOR. GRADING SAN SEW TRUNK 198 0 1180.00 78.67 5 1022.68 A069739 12/3/80 SEWEFi LATERAL WATERMAIN WATER LATERAL WATER AREA 1022.68 A009738 IZ 3$a STORM SEW TRK STORM SEW LAT CURB & GUTTER SIDEWALK STREET LIGHT WATER CONN. BUILDING PER. SAC PARK I ?--? _ --- - --- CITY OF EAG ?L 3830 Pilot Knob Road, P.O. Box 21. PHON E: 454-8' ;. BUILDING PERMIT To be used tor Est. Value c Name 3 Address a GitY Phone .o Name 0 u ? Address ? City Phone_ City Phone I hereby acknowledge that I have read this epplication that the f nformation is correct and agree to comply with all State of Minnesata Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinani SianBture of Pnrmittaw AN 199, Eagan, MN 55121 00 Rece+pt # Date ,1 g OFFICE USE ONLY On Site Sewaye _ Occupancy MWCC System _ Zoning On 5ite Well _ Type of,Const City Water _ (Actual} (Allowable) * of Stories Length depth S.F. Tota4 , Footprint S.F. APPROVALS FEES Assessments _ Permit Water/Sewer _ Surcharge Police _ Pian Review Fire _ SAC, City Engr. _ SAC, MWCC Planner _ Water Conn. Council _ Wgter Meter Bidg. Otf. _ Road Unit APC _ Treafinent P1 Variance _ Parks Copies TOTAL on the express condition that nnesota Statute ? s and City of Eagan Ordinancea ? , PERMIT # PLUMBING PERMIT RECEIPT # - CITY OF EAGAN 3830 PILOT KNOB ROAD, EAGAN, MN 55122 DATE: - )NTRACT PRICE PHONE: 454-8100 ' Site Address ?11 L' L--u k r &.1- Lot Block , Name ? Z??-- ? Address Iq'S`? c City Phone L Name c Address ? C ?• l'ot- , p City Phone ?,: • COMM/IND FEE - 1°k OF CONTRACT FEE APT BLDGS - COMM RATE APPLIES TOWNHOUSE & CONDO - RES. RATE APPLIES MINIMUM - RESIDENTIAL FEE - $12.00 MINIMUM - COMM/IND FEE - $20.00 STATE SURCNARGE PER PERMIT - .50 (ADD $.50 S/C IF PERMIT PRICE GOES SIGNA7URE OF FOR: CITY OF EAGAN BLDG. TYPE WOqK DESCRIPTION Res. ?- New Muft. Add-on ?- Comm. Repair (11hor Water Closet - $3.00 $ Bath Tubs - $3.00 i Lavatory - $3.00 Shower - $3 00 :7 ' . - Kitchen Sink --$3.00 Urinal/Bidet - $3.00 ' Laundry Tray - $3.00 Floor Orains - $1.50 Water Heater - S 1 .50 Whirlpool - $3.00 Gas Piping Outlets - $1,50 (MINIMUM - 1 PER PERMIT) Softener - $5.00 Well - $10.00 Private Disp. - $10.00 Rough Openings - $1.50 FEE: , Cf ?T STATE S/C: A • ?Z '`= , L GRAND YOT 7his request void iB munths from . / d 44368 Request Date F're No. Rouph-in Inspeetion Required? E]Ready Nuw?Will N tify Inspec- 1'es ? No tor When Ready ? ticensed Electrical Contractor I hereby request insDection of above KOwner etectricai wwk installed at: MiNnESDTq STpTE BOARD OF ELECTRIdITY TH Grigga-Midway Bldg. - Room N-191 BE 1821 University Ave., 5t. Peul, MN 55104 UP Phone (612) 297-2111 cru '911REQUEST FOR ELECTRICAL INSPECTlON N. ?ErB-Otl(?1.(14 111' See instructions for completirp thia torm on back of Ysllow coDV• ? 4 4'11; R -X- Below Work Covered bv Thic Ronrinel W. Rep. Type ot 64ilding H me ADDliencea Wirsd Equipm@nt Wired o Range Tem rar Po y Service Ouplex Water Heater Lightin y Fixtures Apt. Building Dryer , Electric: Heat„i Commercial Bldy. Furnace Silo UnloadPr Industrial Bldg. Air Conditioner Bulk Milk Tank Farm Othr.r peci y 7ther (Sper, t er uecify Other Other ompuie /nspection Fee Below N Fee ServiceEntranceSiie H Fee Fepdars/Subfeeders t! Fee Circuits 0 to200Am s 0 to30qm s 0 to30Am Above 200 Am )s 72. 31 to 7 00 Amps 31 to 100 Anvs Swinuning Pool Above 100_Am s Above 100 AmP 1. TransformerS 5i n frrigation k3ooms _ - Partial- Other Fee g s Speciallnspection emarks $ ? . TO7A L. ? RouOh-in ate ihe lectric 'T Inspect reby Final .? Oate cefy that the abava Paction has been de This roquest vold 18 months from . RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION tq VJ 3830 PIL'OT KNOB DN 55122 76•x 651-681-4675 New Construction Renuirements RemodellReoairReauirements • 3 regisrered site surveys showing sq. A. of lot, sq. ft. of house; an?ll roofed areas • 2 wpies of pian (20°6 maeimum lot coverage albwetl) • 1 set of Energy Calculations for heated addihons . 2 copies of plan showing beam 8 wmdow sizes; poured found design, etc ) • i stle survey for extenoraddihans & decks • lseto(EnergyCalculations . Indicale'rfhomeservedbysepticsyslemforaddrtions . 3 copies of Tree Preserva6on Plan d bt platted after 711193 . Rim Joist Detail OpUOns selechon sheet (hldgs with 3 or less unds) ? _ 1a / f V?]AWAfION t?/'?(?? DATE &Q(/ 69 " j 10B SITE ADDRESS? ??y(? ?, J!'-?? AQ GYcK- IF MULTI-FAMILY BUILDING, HOW MANY UNITS? ? PROPERTY OWNER , TYPE OF WC APPLICANT ADDRESS _ PAGER # E# FrIACE(5) _ 0 Z-1 _ 2 PHONE# fZIPCODE? FAX # NEW RESIDENTIAL BUILDING ONLY- FILL OUT COMPLETELY Energy Code Category (check one) Plumbing Contractor: Plumbing Systein Inclucles: Watcr Softener lawn Sprinkler Fee: $90.00 Water HeaLer No. of R.I. 13aths No. oF Baths Mechanical ConNactor: Mechanical Systcm Includcs: :1ir Conditioning _ Heal Recovery SysLem Sewer/Water Contwctor: Phone # ?? 90-Q? Pec: $70.00 Phone # All above information must be su6mitted prior to processing of application. I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application, state that the information is correct, and agree to comply wiih all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Or ' nces. l Signature of Applicant ` Certificates of Survey Received _ Tree Preservation Plan Received _ t Required _ Updated 1/01 MINNESOTA RULES 7670 CATEGORY 1 - Residenfial Ventilation Category 7 Worksheet Submitt gd_ - Energy Envelope Calculations Submitted ) i i' MINNESOTA RULES 7672 - New Energy Cade Worksheet Submitted Phone #: ,' - --- - --_-_ ib o.?oo 06P6 o) TOWAI OF EAGAN 3795 Pilot Knob Rcad st. Paul, A'Linn: 55111 PEAMIT N0.:27 The Board of Supervisors hereby grants to SCeven H. P4arstad nY 391 Dld Hwy._Rildew ilri?hton ? a Cesspool and ceptic tank Permit for: (Otmer) same at 1740 Cliff Road pursuant to application dated 10/19/70 ____- Fee Paid: 14,00 Dated this 19th day cf Oetober , 19 70, -?----- ---- Suilding Inapeetor ? ^ EAGAN TAWNSHIP BUILDING PERMIT Ownex ..:Xl? ..... ?{-'? ..-""'------------'--------- Address (present) .•39/....!lY??.... ---.e" ------ Huildez -------- q!7_? --------?--..-'-,".?-'........... Address ....... .......................... °.---------.__. DEBCRIPTION 11T° 2303 Eagan Township Towa Hali nete .............................-.---.....-----.- Siories To Be Used For Fron! Dep2h Haigh! Es2. Cos! 'Perari! Fee Remarka `If ?o,°? ? -5v'?' " LOCA ?•-?t ? Ns-%y Je. •.? z_ ?ju. 1Od d 6/ /o 03 a? o a This permit does not auihorise the use of alreele, soads, alleys or sidewalka aoz does it give the owner or his agen! the righlfo cteale anp siluaYion which is a nuisanCa or which presenis a hazard !o the health, safely, convenieaca and general welfare !o anpone in the eommuniiq. THIS PERMIT MUST BE JCEPT ON THE PREMISE WHILE THE WORK IS IN PROG/g ESS. This is !o eerlifp, fhaf.?4 ......1?5(Sr.9.??-=------------------'--..haspermission !o ereet a. ....?-?-rv,?.....n...... ........................ _upon the above deserihad premise Qubjee! !o the provisions of the Suilding Ordinenae for Eag/T Towns p adopled April 11, 1955. .................. ---?- •?-"`-'".`.^..--------------------- .-------- Per ......... ....jl........?...?^-..._..?°..-:.-............................................... Cha rman of Tnwn Board g Suiiding Inepeaior ? CITY OF EAGAN N2 13971 3830 Pilot Knob Road, P.O. Box 21-199, Eagan, MN 55121 PHON E: 454-8100 BUILDING PERMIT RESIDENTIAL _ Receipt# Tobeusedfor ADDITION Est.Value $29,000 Date JtiLY 24 1987 Site Address 1740 CLIFF RD Lot 6 Block i Sec/Su6. SECT 32 Parcel No. 3lName STEVEN MARSTAD ? ? Address SAME ° CitY Phone 5 -7481 ,o Name SAME z? ?a Address ? City Phone F w Name `z? Address U $w City Phone- OFFICE USE ONLY On Site Sewege _ Occupancy MWCC System _ Zoning On Site Well _ 7ype ot Const City Water (Actual) (allowahle) # ot Stories Length Depth SF Total Footprint S.F. APPROVALS FEES Assessments _ Permrt $219.30 Water/Sewer _ Surcharge 14.50 Police Plan Review 1 n9. 6S Fire _ SAC, City Engr. SAC,MWCC Planner _ WaterConn. Counal Water Meter I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state 81dg.Off. _ Fioatl Unit thattheinformationiscovectandagreetocomptywithallapplicable APC - TreatmentPl State of Minnesota Statutes a 'gd CiTy of Eagan Ordinances. Variance _ Parks , y Signature of Permittee "a? ? copies TOTAL A Building Permit is issued to: STEVEN MARSTAD on the express condition that all work sball be done in accordance with all aAPliceble t f Minnesota,S t tutes? nd City of Eagan Ordinances Building Official ? ? J ??? ? --- - - --- - -- - -- ---- ? =-?_-? --- - --- ----- ---- -----C? ---- ---- -- - ---' - --- - ------- - ---- ---- - ---------------- ----- - ------ - - ?.??-.?---- ? - - -- --- --- o_?--"-- -- l7`f0 ? ---,PQ-- - ?--- ? --- - - -- - --? -- -- -- - --- - - - -- `-? ? - - - _ ? - ???? - - - - - -- --- -- - - - -- ---- - - --- ? - - --. ---. _?.ee-?- -= ?--- ??-?-?.- ?- Aj? ? -? io?s?a ._- - --------- - -- -- - --- - ?''? v -- a-? - °?' 4 6- - - -- -? - -- - ??,??? /?.°. -- - ?-- - - ---- ---- ?-?-?? ? ---??` ??- -- -- - ---------- - --_- - _ ---- - ------------- -? ---- ---------- --- -- ---- -- --- ----- - - --- -- _------ ?- - • a .\\* ? Ta = Eoc?o„ c,ty HQA ?. _ ??o Ev,a?s?e \1o.rove.(- ?830 'P;\ot kr%Z?o Rc?, Eo,c?cxr, , M? c,r? 5512.2 Fnor?•. `Pzv,? ac?d No,c?c;? `?rooks, Eaoaac,\ , M,c?? 5,51ZZ RE- ac\s?, pco ?Cse6 ass?ssr.??. • PA?, vox?o??s`?oeke. ? %a septat ? w?s? ov.c? o'?oaerrtio?(s) ?o be ee.cArdecl c-eT rd,c? t? Qco?psQ\ to 0.ssesS o? pm?ct,.? ,n Qxcess o?C ?baao.oo due to t?ne fo1lp?,o ? c1C? : a ?) tln.s os?sSrrnrt w.\1 not ?c?cc?eA? -t?e valv?e. aF o?.c- proper?y b-A the 9caposeL-?, o.?%AT'?L) 2) Out` Qropec`t.? w.\1 nG-t ben?.?, \t-\ ?ceeSS of 5\°7o, as o, cv%u\t df s?e??d?o.sn sysl?n?; 3? we t?ue?ved no peioc? rot???co.?c? n? c?h-tS ky,'teA-- dScOOer.+ of assesscr-lfmr??C WioS o- teo.?tors S ??1?e comp?S. sQO.cc11; ? ?? o• s-?o,JFF P-??kuo.'tklan ?e?,?t waS den?ed b? To? C.olba?t; . ?, poo,dr- aveca\\ " ?ccof of .?o.\v.Z. . z req?es?. t1-?e. pco posed o S??sr??.. ,. _ o ut' be. ?_. PmVestj,ac\tl u+r?a_c?sto.nc) °? c? i??nt (s) to apfjeo.\ ', n D?s? c?c,t approas Qc(s*\, _ Str-?a?`el vr, QS, we W'A \oe (A Li,Ak? e?11 , se,.pt t, -?or cpv.'c\c,A Mae?6,rA, . a ?? ?• ?? Hwv. 6%8 -q010 ??k: 2?I1- S-4-1:1 R1so , ad?o?rn? wes? _ sr& o'f is l(t ct;w Ra ( t83b Uffi Ra) ,\-C?6 ?o- ?ec"t Sq 2, W??? be. Q'f `? 1?tt,\e to c.o .?\v.e?? .to ov.c' pro?ec?ty+. 0 0 ! ? -__ ? ------ _--._---- --? C ? -C N a'y?WI ' ` '?' / ? ?l ??? __» ? i `_ ? +¦ ? ! :' ::.• ? ? fit I \; . ;t:;;:::: ? ? ? ? ? ? •` ` a:.?;;:k :: 1 ? 1 ! / I 30 ,:;:<• : :.4_;ti::;:?i;: ? ? .:??...;: I ............. . G ? ? 1 1 ?- ? ? ? ? ? - •;:: .. .::?:>1;::j::::?::.?;ti_: : ::. ? ? I I 1 ` - s ? ? ? \ • ;:;.::x?\"y?{:'s;:::•:? L::k2::: ::<:?:>:?:: . t:: ? I ? ?c;A N -::?_'^:_? %?•. . vo: S .. . .'h?:? ?:?::•:•.,. :..; \ b2o -k'' i / ' • • > ? r :.:::?r.;?:?e:?'??;::5;: ? 1 ?'? ;?X:i:c;i';:'-.r.` :<i:.:>'r5:?;:::::. ?;. •: • ?: >1 ?? 1>•.: ?:..: • ,r ?':. ? <?+:t. i \ \ 4 ;;:..>?, l? » ?::' ' ?. ? r ??3::?; •<;:.::f.:;;f_:;:??.'??i:'3;1?:a::^: 1 ??>:?:; ::t::::-.:. ..':;"i:., ti!!:k:`:,l•i1?'; I ?? ? 1 ? ?: ;r'`::{i;t:kii .:<;? ??1: ? ? / ::•"r.i?::?XG> f2.: ?.:...%:.??::i':`?:;?"•i'lk??' k:.. w: 1 :. .....?...f -:: • . ?:_.!.: ; : ?: ?;;>' S i•? ? ? ? ? ?:;?;?>: i.>i{>:;::i;?:?:??:?i? .?>?.:•:::::? .?i?i?:?:f. ? i 2=>?>;:;`??;.?<?'-::: ?>:;i;i g:.:'•?;?.:.. ?..::: ... • ? f..:: ?'' ? / <i22?:>:1:5?';:?::::,>i::?i: ` :•:. ::. ?E . . .: ... / p ?? _ -' _ .?.,. F:::.,:.;;;.:. i } r F<,:??..?.:l?:ti.•.tj4;l i ? i ti ! ? _ '? ; -_ = = ? ? .; '":: ?:::#.:.:? >: ;::?:::;:? <?::?;:• ';:;;:f>:?':?:??:k?t?L?:;?:1 ? i ? ,, i? ::?:y. ??: ?:? ::.. . .... ...... 9 6 0 - ? _ ? ` ? ? ''?:?i:=:?:?{:?:?';•..??'':?::: :: ? / , . . . ? I I Tm ll\/ r ? ?-_i/I?I?? I /? ?- --? ' `?- •../'::\1 ? ???? ? ? ? ?? / ? ? / ? II ?Il??`??\?-I?/?? J?J11?/?? -////?? --? -_ i ._ ?` ?^?'?? ? ?. ?-ssm % i /! ?,r, ` :? ? ? • __; - ,? ? , ? ?,• ?__ ? , / ? ? \ ?--• _ B \ ^ ` / ' \ \ ~ • ?C .? n 3y- P ?' a- \ V (?-`? U? ?r aq SEPT 9) 'To: Eocaan G?t.A ?1a11 ? clo E\-?rwa Var.we.c-l:)elce, C:ty Gec-k, ?.- ` ? 3830 ?.,?o-t Krob ?? Eoc?o.??M??n 55ti2Z 1_ F cxom _ `+ ?ti\ anc+? Na?c? `??ks, . ' ?? E acao.n, ?-?;,.,c, sS,zZ Q\ • RE= `?tZCaec.?. ? S92 , Storrv? SE..?e? 1 ru.?k Cn?. var?o.?e?beke, T t.e pao-p-Se. oF -t?s lettr c- is ?o ??E?cm \au ti the Ma..`ot?, C,nv.rc,rlrer`,A- bets v.? a?l co*?'cwsl vzx?vlas of ov.c' '%r-\- tet?t*mr\ 'cO o.q)eo.1, irN .?auP' c?eL?s?c•?(?? tc? o.s?ss ou-<' PcnC.?t?..1 f°?- ?.?e o.boue ?ent?o+?ec1 pc-o?t. Ov.? ?oo.??c pcesn?sejs) ?s -t??t t}?e ussess- r-v`?t ?) uc?c?nab\.? ti?ca1,; a) not o'F a?+? ber?e?'?t -jo? ou? Psc?ec?,.l o,s less 1 3) ?,E, ?roaet,t ,..0.?1 cw-t, odd -t?,e assess?l Wlue A-o? our Pc'oeet-t,?; as?d, q) dct:?r.?? a?'eo,S wece d?nec? L.i;?1-? ?1d Mo.P, be. lQx8a.\1U1 -??a -tei pu?? -ty;vs cons?d??a- ?;o? ?GM ?lolb?c'? tb cL" %toSll? eoo.\u?o_t?o? dts?la,?s 8?1 -5TO I?K ? P HONE ' - fi - - --' - - -- ? J?L`? `77? ? Zt??v le ? ?. /CA'WL?t? ?v4 Ue?-?'? 64/h-?? a-- _ uof -? GJ%e .? c_ -- It? : `.?CQ?L }1;???c''?5/?'1 - - ? -?C t ? ? Zi.r ???.--tti` - .4.0"WLv?. 0-) ?._ . - 40013 v4voLl- 4-1 . c?? ? - -_ .__ - - - .- - -- -- ? . __.___._- - -. -?-- - - . - --,_--- - --- - . c ? 0.\ C:_ ? n ?- \o??• ?? ? STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT( COUNTY OF DAKOTA - FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT ________________ Case Type 10 - Other Civil ----------------- ----------------------- George Stertz, Jeanette Stertz, Steven Marstad and Gail Marstad, Appellants, NOTICE OF APPFAT• V. OF SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS City of Eagan, File No. Respondent. ----------------------------------------------------- TO: City of Eagan, its mayor, city council and other officials: NOTZCE IS HEREBY GIVEN THAT pursuant to Minn. Stat. Section 429.081 and all other applicable law, appellants hereby appeal to the District Court from the determination and adoption of assessments by the City of Eagan on September 16, 1991, which adopted and ratified the assessments concerning the City of Eaqan's Special Assessment Project No. 1OP592 for a storm sewer. This appeal is of those assessments levied against the property of appellants George Stertz and Jeanette Stertz which is identified in the Special Assessment Project 10P592 records as property No. 10-03200-050-1, and of those assessments levied against the property of appellants Steven and Gail Marstad which is identified in the Special Assessments Project 1OP592 records as property No. 10-03200••060-1. This appeal is on the grounds that: 1. Appellants are each residents of the City of Eagan, in Dakota County, Minnesota. 2. Respondent is a municipal corporation organized under the laws of the State of Minnesota, and is located within Dakota County, Minnesota. 3. On September 16, 1991, respondent, by its City Council adopted special assessments as part of Special Assessment Project No. 1OP592, which assessments are against petitioners property as further described herein. These assessments are apportioned for costs of a special improvement for a storm sewer. , ? 4. Appell.ant George Stertz and appellant Steven Marstad each interposed siqned wrftten objections of the proposed special asessments at the hearing to adopt and approve the special assessments. 5. Appellants Georqe Stertz and Jeanette Stertz are the owners of property identified in the records of this special assessment project as No. 10-03200-050-1 (hereinafter referred to as the stertz property). The Stertz property was assessed for special improvement costs in the sum of $6391.39. 6. Appellants Steven and Gail Marstad are the owners of property identified in the records of this special assessment project as No. 10-03200-060-1 (hereina#ter referred to as the Marstad property). The Marstad property was assessed for special improvement costs in the sum of $4193.56. ' 7. Respondent has violated appellants' constitutional rights under both the Fourteenth amendment of the Federal Constitution and the Minnesota Constitution, Article X, Section 1 and Article XIII, Section 4, in that the special assessments exceed the special benefits conferred, and, therefore, as to such excess, constitute taking without just compensation. 8. The method used by the City of Eagan for apportioninq the special improvement costs is contrary to law because costs apportioned to and assessed against the Stert2 property and the Marstad property are entirely disproportionate to present or future special benefits received by such properties by reason of the special improvements. 9. The special improvement conveys no present or future special benefit on either the Stertz property or the Marstad property. Wherefore, appellants pray: 1. That the Court make its Order and Decree declaring the above-described special assesement as illegal and void. 2. That the Court adjudqe that the assessments against appellants propertiee are unjust, excessive and unequitable, and direct that those assessments be redetermined in accordance with law. 3. That the appellants have costs and attorneys fees in this action. 4. That the appellants have such other and further relief as is just and proper. Dated: October 11, 1991 ,5 l ? urt St rtz Attorney for Appell ts 315 Waite Ave. S., 1302 Waite Park, Mn. 56387 (612) 251-3060 Attorney Reg. # 105363 ? , y • ? ? \O ? ? ?,. • ? I .? LV STATE OF MINNESOTA W\o DISTRICT COURT \ COUNTY OF DAKOTA - FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT Case Type 10 - Other Civil --------------------------------------°-------------------- George Stertz, Jeanette Stertz, Steven Marstadland Gail Marstad, Appellants, NOTICE OF APPEAL v. OF SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS City of Eagan, , File No. Respondent. ------------------------------------------------------------ TO: City of Eaqan, its mayor, city council and other officials: NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN THAT pursuant to Hinn. 5tat. Section 429.081 and all other applicable law, appellants hereby appeal to the District Court from the determination and adoption of assessments by the City of Eagan on September 16, 1991, which adopted and ratified the assessments concerning the City of Eagan's Special Assessment Project No. 1OP592 for a storm sewer. This appeal is of those assessments levied against the property of appellants George Stertz and Jeanette Stertz which is identified in the Special Assessment Project 10P592 records as property No. 10-03200-050-1, and of those assessments levied against the property of appellants Steven and Gail Marstad which is identified in the Special Assessments Project 1OP592 records as property No. 10-03200••060-1. This appeal is on the grounds that: 1. Appellants are each residents of the City of Eaqan, in Dakota County, Minnesota. 2. Respondent is a municipal corporation organized under the laws of the State of Minnesota, and is located within Dakota County, Minnesota. 3. On September 16, 1991, respondent, by ita City Council adopted special assessments as part of Special Assessment Project No. 1OP592, which assessments are against petitioners property as further described herein. These assessments are apportioned for costs of a special improvement for a storm sewer. 4. Appell.ant Georqe Stertz and appellant Steven Marstad each interposed signed written objections of the proposed special asessments at the hearing to adopt and approve the special assessments. 5. Appellants Georqe Stertz and Jeanette Stertz are the owners of property identified in the records of this special assessment project as No. 10-03200-050-1 (hereinafter referred to as the Stertz property). The Stertz property was assessed for special improvement costs in the Bum of $6391.39. • , 6. Appellants Steven and Gail Marstad are the owners of property identified in the records of this special assessment project as No. 10-03200-060-1 (hereinafter referred to as the Marstad property). The Marstad property was assessed for special improvement costs in the sum of $4193.56. 7. Respondent has violated appellants? constitutional rights under both the Fourteenth amendment of the Federal Constitution and the Minnesota Constitution, Article X, Section 1 and Article XIII, Section 4, in that the special assessments exceed the special benefits conferred, and, therefore, as to such excess, constitute takinq without just compensation. S. The method used by the City of Eagan for apportioning the special improvement costs is contrary to law because costs apportioned to and assessed against the Stertz property and the Marstad property are entirely disproportionate to present or future special benefits received by such properties by reason of the special improvements. 9. The special improvement conveys no present or future special benefit on either the Stertz property or the Marstad property. Wherefore, appellants pray: . 1. That the Court make its Order and Decree declarinq the above-described special assessment as illegal and void. 2. That the Court adjudqe that the assessments against appellants properties are unjust, excessive and unequitable, and direct that those assessments be redetermined in accordance with law. • 3. That the appellants have coets and attorneys fees in this action. 4. That the appellants have such other and further relief as is jnst and proper. !: October 11, 1991 urt St rtz Attorney for Appell ts 315 Waite Ave. S., 1302 Waite Park, ?In. 56387 (612) 251-3060 Attorney Reg. 1 105363 ? SEVEA,SON, WXXI.CCO%& SH=10N, P.A. A PAOY%!@it[)NAI, A6`SUC1fi110N A'1'IORHhYIi /i! LAW I,AR1t1'9.3F.VP.R4(1x• KF$dN6'fll Il IINd, JAMO /511F.I.ppN Bpp MIUWAY NKf10NA1.RANK RUn.18NC •••8(XYrrll.JU1IN4RNI J. YA'[RICK W?I.C,f.)x• T?IX} WElff NY?'N NTRY?R7' It/NYN M. Nf11TYti7 MICI WiL G DOUCf1Y,1YfV MICHAY.L tl. FIULk:tiUA" , ppPLy, yuU,LY. M1NNY90TA b6W ANNi:'IR'l. M. M ftf:ARtt t61E1 674•5196 1iANIRI. M. AHRAIR4N AXAIMN K H17.IA 77tLL"YAX NUNUK% 43197N0 MAR1t0.R1F.NPFf7C •ALN?> U?:LNkY.n IN ItttVA ••N in LIf'l.NiliA IN Wltil'UTivIN (tYl; WN}iq,: ...AIJkI I.N`NKSi'P IN NR719AiIU MIQI P. \41A1i1J(]I DATE: ..l Tpxpy AGES: 7 (Including This Page) FROM: ?{?l??tL? ? f TO: Oriqinals foxwa=ded via: Firat Class Mail Fedexal Express C/' Oriqinals Not Forwarded 'FELEFAX NO. CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: THE DOCUMENT(S) ACCOI+PANYINd THI5 FAX CONTATN CANFSDENTIAL INFORMATION WHICH IS LEGALLY HRIVILBGED. TAE INPORMATION TS INTFNLEA ONLY F'OR THE USE 08 THE INTENDF.D RECIPIENT NAMED ABOVE. IF YOU ARE NOT THE INT=D RSCSPIENT, YOU ARE 1iE12EBY NOTIFIED THAT ANX AISCLOSURE, COPYING, DISTRIBUTION QR TfiE TARZNG OF ANY ACTION IN RELIANCE pti TSE COD1'.CLNTS'OF THIS TELBCOPISD INFORMATIpN E7CCLPT IT6 DI&ECT DELIVERY TO TM INTSNDED RECZPIENT NAMED ABOVE IS STRICTLY PROIiI$ITLD. IF YOU HAVS RECSIVED '.CHIS FAX IN ERROR, PI.EA5E NOTIP'Y US IMEDIATELY BY TELEPHONE TO ARRANGE FOR RETUFtN OF THE ORIGINAL DOCUMENTS 2'0 US. RE: J7?' fz I?S '?.Q OITR PILE NO. : R.mmarka • rraR e9 's¢ es:az ave Pe2 STATE OF ]SINNESOTA COUNTY OF DAKOTA ---------------- ---------------- Gaorge Stertz, Jearlette Bterts, stovan Marstad and caail Merstad, ApDellants, DZSTRICP CQURT PIRST JITDICISL DISTRICT Case Types other Civil Court File No. I2E6PQNDEN'L' '8 ANSWSR INTSRROGATORIE& TO vs. City of Eagan Respondent. -..'?????_-m ---------r-r-- m .w. m TOs Appellants above-named and their t?ttorney, Rurt Stertz, 315 Waite Avenue SoUth, Suite 302, Waito Park, Minnosots 56387. QSTESTION 1: state the name, addrese, teleghone numbeT and job title oY eaah person whom you have had physically wcemine eny of Yhe appellants' property, whether aa part oP thfa special aaaesement project, !or purposas of makirn3 an aaoaasmant dntarmination, or Por any othar purpose. For nach person, aet lorth the lolloving: iL.f a. The Aate of t.heAamfnation; b. A description of how the examiaation qes conducted; c. The nama, address and telephona number of any ritneeaea to tha oxamination; . fl• AnY reports, notes, writtan memoranflum or other raoorda of the eacamination, and s+•mm•rize the aubstance of each dOCUment. / ANSSPER: Mike Foartsoh, Assistant City Sng3neerJ (612) 681-4637; 3830 Pilot Knob Roa4, Eagan, PRf 56121. The C1'ty has not yet choseri its appraisar and wi11 so i.nform Appellt?nt aa soon as possible. QuESxiox z: State the total aoata and benefits of this apecial assessment projnct, deBaribinq in detafl the metnods used to fletermine both costs and benafits, Givs the names, afldresaas, telephone muabers and job titla of those persons who partieipated in determining the oasto "d benefits. ANSKSR: Please find a break dovn oP the costs at page 9 0f the enclosed final aesgssment roll dated 5eptombar 16, 2991. The persons participating and datermining the cegts and benefits are: 1. Tom Colbert, Direator of Public Worke Por City of Eagan (612) 681-4635; 3830 Pilot Knob Road, Eagan, ?Qi 55121. 2. Mike Foertsch, Aseietant Enginser Por City of Sagen (612) 681-4637f 3830 Pilot Knob Road, Eagan# ARt 55121. 3. Thomas E. Angus, Conculting 8nqiaeex aith Bonestroo, Rosene, Anflerlik and AssDOiates, Ina. (612)636-4600; 2338 West BighYray 36, St. Pnul, NIIi 55113. 4. Gerald R. Wobsahall, Finance Consultnnt for City of 8agan (612) 681-46241 3630 PilOt Knob RoaA, Ea9an, MN 58121. QDESTION 3: Describe in fletail the method uaed to npportion costs of this special assesament projeat. ANSWER: MRR 09 '92 08:44 478 P04 Total costs of $298,417.62 vere apportioaed at the rntes as indioated on page 2 oi tha Pinal assesenent roli a+hich had been proposefl in the feasibility roport. QUESTIQN 4: For each of the appelYants' yroperty, desaribe the folloaings a. In dollars, the benefit to appellante' Dropatty of this speciel asseesment projeot, anQ the baeis Por that determination. If an nppraisal was nada, state the name, address and teiephone number of the appraieer and summarise the cont9ltts of any reports, notas, raemoranda or other records which were made. b. The percantnge oP appellants' property which ia drained by triis special assessment projact. iTse maps to ehovr how the property flrains. c. if you claim thBre are potential future benefits to eppellants' property, state vhat proportion of the benaPitr. described in your Ansver to InCerroqatory 4.a. ara attribuCable to tuture benetits. d. If you claim there ara patential future benefite, flescribe any conditions vhioh must be eatisfied betora thase future benefits ara anjoyad. If you alaim that appollents can enjoy future benefits by making improvements to their property, d0saribe in detaii, qivinq the basis for your opinion, the nature of those•improvementa, the cost of those improvements, anfl tAe value of apyellaats p7roparty ao a result of ttiose improvaments. IiNSOPII2 4: \ ryiR 09 '92 08:44 ' 478 P05 a. see answer to numbar i. b. Over 51$; aae attacheQ topograpAical sap. c. uNrnown at this tima. d. Unknowp at this time. QuESZxox s: If there ara aay parcels of property vhich are drained in atsy part by thia epecial aeeeeement proj0ot to which wsts have not baan epportioned according to the method described in your Ansver to Interragatory 3, identify the proparty, the amount of the perael whicn ia drained by thia special asseggment projact, and the bnsis !or not apporCioning aoste on the preperty. ANSWII2 5: 1. Parcel No. 10-03200-020-01; less than S1t of the paxdsl vas louad to lie within the drainaqa district. §gg anclosad copy 8eptember 16, 1991 City Council minutes. 2. PSTC01 No. 10-03200-030-01p oves' 51%; At the February 4, 1992, City Council meeting, the Counail reassessed the parcai to $0 iastead choosing to pick-up Minn. Stat. Section 444 oonngation lees as codiPied at Chapter 3 of the Engan City Code if and when the pascel hooks up to City utilities. 3. 9everal parcels in the Clearview Addition and CleaYView 2n8 Addition vere not assesaed as 51% of the various pareela did aot flrain into the drainage district. QIIESTION 6: Set forth the names, addresses anfl telephone numbers of ell individuals rhom you expect to aall as an expert at trial and with regard to each auch individual, etate the lollowingt a, The subject matter npon which thQy sre expBeteB to testifyp •••• ..? x ao:q7 478 p05 b• The substanoe of facta upon tirhich they are axpectetl to base their opinions; ? C. The aubstance oR the opinione to w6ioh they are exp@ated Lo teatify. ArrswEts i. Tom Colbert, Director of Public Worlcs for City of Eagan (612) 681-6635; 3830 Pilot ISnob Road, SdgBrf, HN 551216 2• Mike Foertsch, Assi6tttnt 8ngineer !or Citp of Eagan {612} 681-46371 3930 Pflot ICnab RD3fl, EBgen, itN 58121. a. tme °t""'tttV-Cw°-u6ov1J 1wwu1 F,nirw+d wLll L:t,stiL'p at trial an Lo the nature of the projscE and ite aonstruction; b• The facts upon which t.hey will baee t.heir opinions ara aotual knowledge in plarninq the projeet No. 592, the faasibility report, and the informtstiet? provided in the final asaessaent roil; C. Tiie engineers wfil QYpress no opinion ac to the benefit accruinq to the subject paraele from the projeat. Dated: Idike Foertsch STATE qF MINN&SOTA ) COt1NTY OF ) ss. ) On thie day of , 1992, before me a Notary Public within and for said Cotitlty, peraonaliy appaared Hike goortsch to me personally kno?m te be the per6on descrfbed ih anfl whp executed the loreqoing instrumnnt and ackriowledged that he executed the Bame ae Ais lree acC 8nd fleefl. Notary pµblic ? ? ? rM e9 @92 ee:as a-re P07 DIBCCVERY CSRSIlICnIOni Tha urnlersigned aertitiee that these Arisvers to Interroqataries comply with Rule 26.07 of the )linnesota Rulea of Civ31 Prxedure. Dated: SEVERSON, 1PILCOX & SBELDONF P.A. Sy: Annatte M. l2argarit, #184448 Attornsys !or 600 1Sidvay National Bank Building 7300 iPest 137th StT98t Apple valley, Minnesota 55124 (612) 432-3136 9 OS'AUp-91 fTORM $EIER TRUIIK !!1 MW 2ST1692 SIUI 2210 1'EARS 15 IMT RATE .OES IpS 15T tR IMT 15 tEAR 1991 REC PROVERTT Gpp5g MMBR IDEMTN CL UIIITS I 10-02800'012'76YC 1056000 z 10-02e00-01e-soWc o 3 10-02800-020-50NF %5970.7 4 10-02900-016-75YC 36233 S 10-03200-070-O15F 4lE41 6 10-03200-020-O15F 10E9B5 7 10•03200-030-OtSF 117713 E 10•03200-040-015F 117E88 9 10-03200-OSD-O15F 114132 10 10-03200-060-O/sF 74885 11 10•17150-070•035F 44460 tt 70-17750•020-025F 30336 13 10-17750-020-03Sf 54560 14 10-1)750-030-07SF 35389 15 10-17750-060-03SF 69896 16 10-17750•070-03SF 69427 17 10-17150•OSO-035F 5089 19 10-inso•090-030 sbooo 79 10-17T50•140•020 S6980 20 10-17751-010-Otff 2E560 21 10'17751•020-015F 2e420 u 10-4rn0-010-00uc ezno 23 10•64i30•010-OOSF 0 32b4Si.7 ASSESSMEMT C06T BREA190YM CRW MAM YfLWS MOTIqI PROJ MUN i592 sA wuE ssrKSVz f CREDITS -1056000 0 O 0 0 0 0 •109D0 0 D -K460 -30336 •54560 -35309 0 •13700 -27<00 0 -2l560 -2g.20 0 0 -13957pS 17750 Clearviev Addition 17751 Clearview 2nd Addition 47250 Mallard Park lst Addi[ion 84450 Willmus Addition SF NF CI IIC SUBTOTAL FA 01 ot %5970.7 1 36233 1 iE8G7 1 108985 7 177773 1 97988 1 N<732 1 74885 t 0 1 0 1 Ot 01 69896 1 SS727 1 51109 7 56000 1 01 01 01 62270 1 Ot ta53229.7 0.056 /S.F. 0.070 /S.F. 0.063 /E.f. 0.028 /S.F. NET UIITS iR0-RAT11 ASS'BIE fXARE Ot 0 1 965970.7 1 36235 1 4E841 1 108985 1 117113 7 97988 1 114132 1 74885 1 Oi ' 07 01 . Ot 69ED6 1 55727 7 3/1!9 1 sbooo t Ot 01 01 siz7o 1 01 ASSESSMENT RATE NIOUNi .s.srss:ss..eae?..e::vs 0.023 0.00 0.028 0.00 0.070 67617.95 0.026 1014.52 0.056 2735.10 0.056 6103.16 0.056 622233 0.056 5467.33 0.056 6391.39 0.056 4193.56 0.056 0.00 0.056 0.00 0.056 0.00 0.056 0.00 0.056 3911.16 0.056 3120.77 o.oss n".sa 0.056 3176.00 0.056 0.00 0.056 0.00 O6D56 0.00 o.oze :sos.se 0.056 0.00 It3,il637 e ? : pS-lwp-9t ASSESSIMMT COST tREIIRDG4M pROJ NMff YIILMR ADDTIOM PYOJ IYI i592 fR MNE tST1692 F $jpigl SEYEi TMJMK M WIE f5T1692 so 2210 tF 0.056 /S.f. TEARS 1S MF 0.070 /S.i. INi RATE .085 CI 0.063 /f.F. Iq5 1ST l'R 1MT 15 MC 0.028 /f.F. 1185ESSMEMT 1991 rEAa MET IM1T5 iR0-RFTA f11TE MIOUMT REC ?ROiERTt /R 1DENT/ CL Nt054 UMITS CREDITS iIATOTIIL M sXARE Af5'BLE if °"""" ¦ 1 10'028GU'012•76YC 1056000 '1056000 0 1 O i 026 0 0.00 t 10-02800-016•S01?C 0 0 0 1 0 1 ?'q . O.p?p 67617.95 3 10-02800-020•SOMF %5970.7 0 ?9?'7 1 ? 026 0 tO1?.S2 4 70-02900-016-75YC 36233 0 36233 1 36233 . 056 0 2755.10 S 10-03200•070-OtSF 4w1 0 4m? 1 4mi 1 . O p? 6?03,16 6 10-03200-020•015F 10l985 a l0l?5 I l0m5 I . O ? ?,? 7 10-03200-030•O15F 111113 0 111113 1 1 13 ; 111 . 0 ? y,87.33 6 10-03200•040•01SF 117888 '1? 9? 1 ? 9 . p56 O 6391.59 9 10-03200-050'01SF 116132 0 114132 1 11i132 1 . 056 0 4193.56 W 10'03200'060'O15F 74l65 D 74!!S 7 74lBS 1 . 0 056 0.00 11 10-1Tl50-010•035F 44460 '"460 0 1 01 0 1 . 0.056 O.pp 72 10•17750•020-025f 30336 -30336 0 1 0 1 0.056 ?-? 13 10'17750•020-035F SiS60 '56560 0 1 ? p 0.056 0.00 t< 10-17750•030•035F 35369 '35369 0 1 ? ?_ p,p? j914.16 15 10-17750•060•035F 60696 0 ?? 1 $5727 1 0.056 3120.71 16 10•17750-07D-035F 69427 '13700 SS727 1 0 ? 1746.5! 17 10•17750-0l0-035F S!589 -27400 31169 1 ;7 ? ; . 0 ? 3136.00 16 10-1T150-090-035F 56000 0 56000 1 ? ' . 056 0 0.00 . 19 10-17756-1?0-02sF .36980 ''?6? 0 7 01 . O p? 0.00 ?1o•1m+-o1o-oisr tesbo -ze?o 0 1 0 1 o? . o.osb o.oo 21 lo-jr?sI-ozo-oIsr ?eczo -? o? eum 1 0.028 zeaa.sb u 1o•<reso-o1o-oa+c ezzm o mm 1 o? o.oss o.oo 23 t0-66?50•010-ODSF 0 0 o 1 115,9l637 32L04Sr?.7 '1395705 1653229.7 17750 Clearvier Additioa 17751 Clearviev 2nd Addition 47250 tlallard Park Ist Addition 84450 Willmus Addition smRsom wiwog& sHELDoN, P.A. A P![OFPS870NAL A390CIK170H ATTOlwe" eT Ww I.A[iRY9.AEVBIIHON' ,rnnna r.axBLDON J. PAl'AICK WiLCAX* lelcxAEL G. DDU6HEICl'f tEetu¢L R xoiacNDA•• •NEOI.xmmsU IN IQtisA ^AL90 UCPNSBD IN M1600MN -AL90 WORN86C W MN)NABKA DATE: ? Fl20M : TO: RE: TCT 4Ci14 1.11"1 • B00 1lIDWAY NwrIONAL 8AH1C 8lI1LDIN6 7800 WS3l' 1477'x s7'rt6B.T App1d7 YAWJi}L MR1NF60YA 561U 191E1 49b886 71IAWpY N09UF.It 4314780 I(HM6TH R. HALL '•'8C07T D. i0HN6RON IAEltN M. BOLFBBT CNR1677Nt M. SCQrtL1.0 ANNCi7'6 M. MARGAAtT DANiBSlASONBIMdB ?J` TOTAI. P4GBS: -.L/--(InCluQing This Paqe) ouR FILS ND.: O7COIRML gFIIlY WKG.iCN Originals foxwarded via: Fixet class Mai7. Federal 8xprese oriqiaals Not Foswarded CONFIDENTIAY,ITY NOTICE: TEM AOCUDI&NT(S) ACCOMPANYINCi THT3 $x17C CONTAIN COtZF2AENTIAL INFORMATIOZi WHS.EH IS LE.QAIJ.7C PRNTLEGBD• TF1E INP'ORMATIOt3 IS TNTFsHAE13 DNLY FOA T8E USB OF T8E INTElIDEI] RECIPISN't NAMED ABOVE. IF YOU ARL NOT TfiE INTSNDE} RBCIPIBN'1', YOV AEtL+ HMHY NOTIP'ZEl] THAT ANY DISCLOSURE, GOPYING, DTSTRIBUTZOtZ OR TSE TA&INCs OF ANY ACTION IH REI.IANC& ON THE CONTL+tifiS pF THTS TELECOPIBfl INFORMATION EKCBPT I''S DIR&CT D$I.IVERY TO THS IN'I'ENDM RECIPIENT' NAMED AHOVL IS STRICTI,Y pTtOHIBITEA. IF YOU BAVE RECENm THIS FA8 IN ERRQFt, PLEA58 HOTTB'Y US IMMEll7ATE:I,Y S7C TEr.rr.rKaHB To AARANf3E. FOA RE1AF2N OF R'HE ORIGTNPS DOCUMEN',CS TO US'. s .rar e7 •92 ee:zs ? ' . OOrr Pez s ? ?gtcxt.?.. ? M?r?rw5?ito. cAwXNAL . . _... ._._..---.. .;.:.._ • --.. _ . .... ?; . . . . . ...._. ..._ . .. . :, ., . . .. ?- _... ...... _.. _._. .- . .. A pQ??.?lo_nts ?vS?... . !;. O?str?c.t Cpu.c-t.. istS?d???D?st. take.. aA- Oo.lcata Cauc?t.•?.. ?ro cv-, o?-?- ' oc, Sept l?, ?Cq1 0 .c-lsAL ?-:.., .. .;:: .... . Y•?-t. A$zl 4JR . . ? : .... _ .. . E°`W ? Jfri 07 ' 92 09:23 , •? L? , s ?.C?rC 1G Cs?r?ul?C?S ...O.m O.S ?c o\1aua?= 007 P03 \4 o,rpAaht s appQ':)l .,.t?.? sxtecct 4?R sQ:d a?sonent . ..M , 2The to't.o.\ w?ts oc t?n? ; rn p cau?ec'?ec?'t.s 1pe.n?s'?t- ,_'tec? bv1 t'Yee. sb.?d ?m(?rov?mac?ts. ??? .exc?ess»? ?c. s?pe o?? c-e ?les?odc•?ea to `Fo.?r. ..,o-t?r \o.c? a?At?rsAu?ho o.c-?. rot ?+^? •`??'?`'?? .:?r? wr•-t:?v?c? ?, th? oJoo? as?s?'C. - ,:;rx+?t?or ? : .. ?J?s?e.?Cac?, A??\ax?ts oak -t??s Go.At?,L A.o vhe a-box. ?esc??bed o,ssessn?.e?t re- `(o?readv, ptad ?co o.?ek ?.<,,.......... , ., .... ?:..?u_..,._._:...__._r ..:. .. _._ JpJ 07 ' 92 09:24 007 P04 . . .. ... ... ... . .. .. . . . ? .r.. _. ? . M?s,t1 . ^??a• ._._......C?.s.esgc+,"e?''?, ??. o.tcAC?o.r?C?e w 'Yh ? _..?_'?:.. _ .. _._.Aa?... t \r.,, . . ,.. . .. ? .._. ...,.. .. . . . mv.Al ?o , Qf*f'6 . Az.uk r-- . 8eookz.. bcco? ?rl?ao.sa 5EA23 (,?n?-?y ef ?914 Gi EF Rrx? ' EO?^•? SS12Z-? ....?.._..? , . _. ?...,_.__....... . Recg c.to. cne.\Mec? atErach?ran-t,ls?. Aaa:?•o?•a.? brx???}.s •- .?__. METf MEPRp TIYU ppgppgpTION ? 05 405 Sibley Street Suite 10.S' ` St. Paul, AR 55101 _ --- - - - - - 6 7 <4 Mlou?--j ? ?41.? City of qrl* ?Po County of ?p ? Subject: Pending Assessments We are hereby requesting as of JO dp --l„J to determine whether there are any pending assessments not certified to the office of the County Auditor pertaining to the following described property: and-or special assessments. `rC?C1 d- c ,?c?_(I? ?H ?'D %c-6 3.ze0 ,z.? &a-Dl Assessed in the name of: Property Address: ? The following improvements are contemplated or pending after having been approved, and are now in process, or completion. Nature of Approximate Date Approximate Cost Improvement of Completion of Improvement CLerk C'?E12zsssr_ftn y -fact--ys -,6, glde YnluzancE Co2Potatton - ? City of Eagan 3795 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, MN 55122 Date: Novembor 10, 1980 Metro Title 6oxpoYatioIISPECIAL ASSESSDIENT SCARCH 405 Sibley Street RE: St Paul MN 55101 Section 32 1740 Cliff Road, Eagan MN 55122 M10479 Parcel #10 03200 060 01 Enclosed herein is the search which you requested made on the above described property: Kind of Improvement Runs Beginning Original Amount Balance Due Straet Imp 10 Yrs, 1981 $1138.60 $1015.74 San Sew Trk 15 Yrs. 1980 $1180.00 $1022.68 Water Area 15 YRs. 1980 $1190.00 $1022.68 I further certify that according to the records of said office, the following improvements are contemplated or pending after having been approved, and are now in the process of planning or completion. Kind of Improvement Approximate date Completion Approximate Cost None Waiver: Neither the City of Eagan nor its employees guarantees the accuracy of the above information which was requested by the person or persons indicated. Nor does the City of its employees assume any liability for the correctness thereof. In consideration for the supplying of the indicated information in the above form, and for all other consideration of any nature whatsoever, any claim against the City of its employees rising there from is hereby expressly waived. Levied assessments to be paid to the Couhty Auditor at Hastings, MN 55033 Very truly yours, SPECIAL ASSESSMENT DEPARTMENT , . i' 1987 BQILDING ?PERMIT APPLICATIOH - CITY OF EAGAN _ SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS INCLDDE 2 SETS OF PLANSp 3 OF SQRVEY, 1 SST OF ENERGY CALCQLATIONS HOTE: ADDRESSES FOR CORNER LOTS - CONTRACTOR/HOMEOWNER MQST DESIGWATfi AHICH ADDRESS IS DESIRED. NO CHANGBS WILL BE ALLOWED ONCE BDILDING PERMIT IS ISSIIED. MULTIPLE DWELLINGS - RFSIDENTI6L RENTAL OHITS FOR S9LE ONITS INCLUDE 2 SETS OF PLANS, CERTIFICATB OF SDRVEY - CHECK WITH BLDG. DEPT., 1 SET OF ENERGY CALCULATIONS COMKERCIAL INCLUDE 2 SETS OF ARCHITECTURAL & STRUCTURAL PLANS, 1 SET OF SPECIFICATIONS AND 7 SET OF ENERGY CALCULATIONS, • $2,000 LANDSCAPE BOI?'n?5, ???? / To Be Used For: Valuation: vc ? O?? Date: 7- Site Address ?7 LO L/ywr OFFICE OSE ONLY I Lot ? Block / Parcel/Sub JO,4 ?- owner ST'Fl/_Fi,/ /1/IAPST? Address City/Zip Code Phone 7s?- 717 0 / , Contractor ?4A?E Address City/Zip Code Phone Areh./Engr. Address ?L 3,5- N, 'c0/5 eaa City/Zip Code C?zc??f ?ii/ Phone 4l On Site Sewage_ MWCC System _ On Site Well _ City Water _ 9PPROYALS Oecupancy Zoning Type of Const (Actual) (Allowable), 41 of Stories Length Depth S.F. Total Footprint S.F. FfiSS Permit Surcharge Plan Review SAC, City SAC, MWCC Water Conn Water Meter Road Unit Treatment P1 Parks Copies TOT9L 14 ID9 .'s Assessments Water/Sewer Police Fire Engr Planner Council Bldg Off APC Variance MASTER CARD Ll ; Permit No. Issued Issued To Contractor Owner BUILDING PLUMBING ? 1- 3 -. -? ? ? CESSPOOL - SEPTIC TANK 27 WELL ELECTRICAL - 314 ?' %'71 HEATING GAS INSTALLING SANITARY SEWER OTHER I OTHER I . FOOTI NG FOUNDATION FRAMING Items Approved (initial) Date Remarks Distance o i V r SEPTIC ? CESSPOOL !?- ? TILE FIELD PT. ? HEATING GAS INSTAILATION SEPTIC TANK CESSPOOL DRAINFIELD PLUMBING WELL SANITARY SEWER DEPTH ?} ? OF WELUO. 3OJ i ? o ,7 S ft ? /. 27 7C"V?/ r 6 a rutat4 Violations Noted on Back STRUCTURE AND y IAND USED AS ow/O l y?/? ? D f STATE OF MINNESOTA DISTRICT COURT COUNTY OF DAKOTA FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT CASE TYPE: Special Assessment Appeal George Stertz, Jeanette Stertz, Court File No. C6-91-8544 Steven Marstad and Gail Marstad, Appellants, vs. STIPOLATION AND ORDER CITY OF EAGAN, Dakota County, Minnesota, a municipal corporation, Respondent. WHEREAS, Appellants Steven Marstad and Gail Marstad ("Owners") are the Owners of a parcel of land in the City of Eagan with the property identification number of 10-03200-060-01 ("Subject Property"); and WHEREAS, on September 16, 1991, Respondent City of Eagan ("City") assessed the Subject Property in the sum of $4,193.56 for storm trunk as part of Project No. 592; and WHEREAS, Owners brought an action in District Court appealing the sum of the assessments for Project No. 592, known as Georae Stertz, et al., Court File No. C6-91-8544; and WHEREAS, the parties have resolved all dispute over the assessments against the Subject Property. NOW, THEREFORE, the parties do hereby agree as follows: 1. The assessment levied against the Subject Property for Project No. 592 in the sum of $4,193.56 shall be reassessed in the amount of $0. 2. This settlement is made without prejudice to the City's assertion of any rights it may have in the future to claim storm sewer connection charges if and when the Subject Property connects to City utilities. The settlement is also without prejudice to the owners' right to contest any such connection charges in the event the same were made by the City. 3. The City shall direct the Dakota County Treasurer to recompute Owners' real estate tax statement using the new assessment figure of $0. 4. The Owners waive Notice of Hearing and Hearing on the reassessment of the Subject Property. 5. Upon the execution of this Stipulation, the Owners shall cause this action, Court File No. C6-91-8544 to be dismissed with prejudice. Dated: - CITY _,. i992 % gy. Dated: 9- .7 , 1992 Dated• ?J - 4/ , 1992 Dated• 5 , 1992 By: VanOverbeke Its: ty Clerk Steven Marstad Ac? o)a+,at.d)- Gail Marstad -2- APPROVED AS TO FORM: / " 1. City Attorn y' Off ce Dated: L APPROVED AS TO CONTENT: ? Dep ent of Finance Dated: S. Jr ASL STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF DAKOTA ss. On this 4LI-k- day of Publip within and for said and E. J. VanOVERBEKE to duly sworn, each did say Clerk of the City of Eaga instrument, and that the s by authority of its C acknowledged said instrume municipality. ? ?.dt.• ..?. ...ast-rt. ,:tas.=v ^V fL'. _..."A ro • C,."•>TAG=.U;JIY . € ...r, STATE?OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ?c ) On this K*? day of Public within and for said and Gail Marstad, husband persons described in and acknowledged that they exec , 1992, before me a Notary Coupersonally appeared THOMAS A. EGAN me personally known, who being each by me that they are respectively the Mayor and n, the municipality named in the foregoing eal affixed on behalf of said municipality ity Council and said Mayor and Clerk nt to be the free act and deed of said _, 1992, before me a Notary County, ersonally appeared Steven Marstad and wife, to me personally known to be the who executed the foregoing instrument and ated the same as their free act and deed. C ? ?`?? •???,,;?i??? ?. , 7OTA 1 ?'.-• 6ryC?:ana.:.r?E.•CrE.:.,-..27.t$^rt ......-....?.?. ,?„?..?.,?,+ -3- ORDER FOR JQDGMENT Based upon the foregoing Stipulation entered into by and between the City of Eagan and Steven Marstad and Gail Marstad; IT IS ACCORDINGLY. THE ORDER OF THE COURT THAT JUDGMENT BE ENTERED BY THE COURT: JUDGE OF DISTRICT COURT Dated: 1992 I certify that the above constitutes a judgment of the court. JUDGMENT ENTERED AND FILED THIS DAY OF (SEAL) BY THE COURT ROGER W. SAMES DISTRICT COURT ADMINISTRATOR , 1992. Deputy -4- SEVERSON, WILCOX & SHELDON, P.A. LARRYS.SEVERSON` JAMESF.SHELllON J. PATRICK WILCOX' MICHAEL G DOUGHERTY'**' MICHAF.L E. MOI,ENDA•* APROFESSIONALASSOCIATiON ATl'OItNEYS AT LAW 600 MIUWAY NATIONAL BANK BUILDING 7300 WF.3T 147TH STREET APPLF VALLEY, MINNEBOTA 55124 (812) 432-3138 TELEFAX NUMBER 432-3780 KF,NNETH R. HALL "BCOTT D. JOHNSTON LOREN M.SOLFEST ANNF.TTE M. MARGARIT DANIEL M. SHERIDAN 311A[tON K HILLS 'ALSO 11CENSF.D IN IOWA "ALSO LICENSED 1N WISCONSIN .••AI,SO LICENSED IN tiEBRASHA °°CERT[FIED REAL PROPF.RTY LAW SPECW.I3T, MSBA August 10, 1992 Judy Jenkins City of Eagan 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, Minnesota 55121 Re: George Stertz, et al. v. City of Eagan Court File No. C6-91-8544 OFCOUNSEL JOHN E. VIMF.LICR Dear Judy: Enclosed for your files please find the following documents in regard to the above-referenced case: 1. Entry of Judgment; 2. Filing of Order; and 3. Stipulation and Order. I apologize for the delay in sending you these documents but District Court sent them to the wrong address office and therefore we have just received them. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me. Very truly yours, SEVE ON, WILCOX & SHELDON, P.A. ???.?? Annette M. Mrgarit // AMM/wkt Enc. uG•lOOlala) . ••• , No'b dFIW.E,".Dx4Wq . ,,. (- KURT STERTZ ? ATTORNEY AT LAW 315 WAITE AVENUE SOUTH STATE OF MINNESOTA SUITE 302 COUN7Y aF DAKOTA L WAITE PARK MN 56387 NOTtCE OF: ' ? F1L.INC3 OF ORDER _ r ANNETTE M. MARGARIT , ATTORNEY AT LAw 64 EMRY OF JUDGMENT 7300 WEST 147TH STREET : P.O. BOx 24329 - p DOCKE7ING OFJUDGMENT APPLE VALLEY MN 55124 • L- Court Flle No.: C6-91-8544 _ lN RE: GEORGE STERTZ, ET AL VS. CITY OF EAGAN 0 Ybu ere hareby noUflad thai on - 18 an Ocder was duly fltad in the above entltted matter. ? ? You are herehy notiflad thal on ? , 19? a Judgment waa duly entered In the above entltled matter. ? You aro hereby noUfled that on - 18 e Judgment was duly docketed in the above entitted matter in the amount ot $ _ Atrue and eorrect copyof thia Notlea has been sarvad by mali upon tha partlas named hereln at the last known address of each, pursuant ta Mlnnesota Rules ot Clvil Procedure, Rule 77.04. DatROGER W. SAMES Court AdmtNstrator • Da"T?'tY ? luCA41f Fled r,is ? 15:;19 a.... HOr9ER'N. uc.-,oou+w - rwdm a s+Na Enr. Doc"&a ; r KURT STERTZ ATTORNEY AT LAW 315 WAITE AVENUE SOUTH SUITE 302 L WAITE PARK MN 56387 _ r ANNETTE M. MARGARIT ATTORNEY AT LAW 7300 WEST 147TH STREET P.O. BOX 24329 APPLE VALLEY MN 55124 L IN RE: GEORGE STERTZ, ET AL VS CITY OF EAGAN i STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF DAKOTA NOTICE OF: 9 FILINC9 OF ORDER ? ENTRY OFJUDGMENT ? DOCKETING OF JUDGMENT CouR Flle No.: C6-91-8544 ? Ybu aro hereby noUfled that on MAY 29TH , 19 92 an Order was duly tllad ln the above entitled marier. 0 You ars hereby notlflad that on , 19 a Judgment wes duly enterod In the ehove enlltled matter. ? You aro haroby notlfled that on ,19 e Judgment waa duly docketed In lhe above entlUed matter In the amount of $ Atrue and correct copy ot thla Notica has bean servad by mali upon the partles namad hereln at the iast known address o( each, pursuant to Mlnnasota Rulea ot Civll Procedura, Rule 77.04. Dated: MPY 29, 1992 ROGER W. SAMES CouA Administrator b. ? ils? ??) QJ/??G? Q4uty 4 Fiied this d!?e of 19L HOGFai W. SAMES, Cau Atlministrzd STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF DAKOTA George Stertz, Jeanette Stertz, Steven Marstad and Gail Marstad, Appellants, vs. CITY OF EAGAN, Dakota County, Minnesota, a municipal corporation, Respondent. STIPIILATION AND ORDER WHEREAS, Appellants Steven Marstad and Gail Marstad ("Owners") are the Owners of a parcel of land in the City of Eagan with the property identification number of 10-03200-060-01 ("Subject Property"); and WHEREAS, on September 16, 1991, Respondent City of Eagan ("City") assessed the Subject Property in the sum of $4,193.56 for storm trunk as part of Project No. 592; and WHEREAS, Owners brought an action in District Court appealing the sum of the assessments for Project No. 592, known as George Stertz, et al., Court File No. C6-91-8544; and WHEREAS, the parties have resolved all dispute over the assessments against the Subject Property. NOW, THEREFORE, the parties do hereby agree as follows: l. The assessment levied against the Subject Property for Project No. 592 in the sum of $4,193.56 shall be reassessed in the amount of $0. ?j Fiied ?iM d?' `.I .,'s of10('ER W. SAIAES, rt Adqmjq? i?'7?'Z; ---'- r r?UTY DISTRICT COURT FIRST JUDICIAL DISTRICT CASE TYPE: Special Assessment Appeal Court File No. C6-91-8544 2. This settlement is made without prejudice to the City's assertion of any rights it may have in the future to claim storm sewer connection charges if and when the Subject Property connects to City utilities. The settlement is also without prejudice to the Owners' right to contest any such connection charges in the event the same were made by the City. 3. The City shall direct the Dakota County Treasurer to recompute Ownersf real estate tax statement using the new assessment figure of $0. 4. The Owners waive Notice of Hearing and Hearinq on the reassessment of the Subject Property. 5. Upon the execution of this Stipulation, the Owners shall cause this action, Court File No. C6-91-8544 to be dismissed with prejudice. OF EAGAN ? Dated: ? ? 's 1992 By: Thomas Its: Mayo Dated• S ? S , 1992 Dated• 5 - / - , 1992 Dated: 1992 gY; VanOverbeke Its: ity Clerk Steven Marstad Gail Marstad -2- APPROVED AS TO FORM: City Attorn y',s O ice Dated: S?/ /?j APPROVED AS TO CONTENT: UISL Depa ent-,f F,}=q,na Dated: J °i STATE OF MINNESOTA ss. COUNTY OF DAKOTA ) On this llj?l day of , 1992, before me a Notary Public within and for said County, personally appeared THOMAS A. EGAN and E. J. VanOVERBEKE to me personally known, who being each by me duly sworn, each did say that they are respectively the Mayor and Clerk of the City of Eagan, the municipality named in the foregoing instrument, and that the seal affixed on behalf of said municipality by authority of its City Council and said Mayor and Clerk acknowledged said instrument to be the free act and deed of said municipality. ;e,y..fssa .?ter•••rra:tes::r^^ste?.?. `n ..w !!!.'"_5:1 L f:'-: _?. ?rY Np: P,av PC::'..J - 1.'••:I:::SJTA ,, j DA::7TA CCUNTY 2 Y. . ' i,.... ,-1 E: ] F S 9 i:,;l w ° ??` .. •° - ? ?i .• STATE OF MINNESOTA •), ) 5s. COUNTY OF On this .t?0" day of Public within and for said and Gail Marstad, husband persons described in and acknowledged that they exec, ??C-- , 1992, before me a Notary County, ersonally appeared Steven Marstad and wife, to me personally known to be the who executed the foregoing instrument and zted the same as their free act and deed. ,,?;:!1T?BA ? r50TA ? ^3 Z1.15? ? -3- ORDER FOR JIIDGMENT Based upon the foregoing Stipulation entered into by and between the City of Eagan and Steven Marstad and Gail Marstad; IT IS THEREFORE THE ORDER OF THE CO?/ THAT JUDGME T BE ENTERED ACCORDINGLY. / ? // BY T C LTR ' . ? Dated: 1992 Jt7 R VT HARVEY A. HOLTAN I certify that the above consti?u,te a judgment the court. Y?f? JUDGMENT ENTERED AND FILED THISprDAY OF 1992. (SEAL) BY THE COURT ROGER W. SAMES DISTRICT COURT ADMINISTRATOR o ? Deputy -4- BEA BLOMqUlST MAYOR THOMASEGAN JAMESA.SMITN , JERRY THOMAS TMEODORE WACHTER COUNCiI MEMBEPS ? CITY OF EAGAN 3795'PILOTKN08ROA0 " V.O.BO%3nN ? EAGAN,MINNESOTAssilt . PHONE 4S4-8I00 : ?MW . xlii` ..a..-??....._-- -- - SPECIAL ASSESSMEYT SEARCH xe : TNOMASHEDGES CITY AOMINISiFAiOP EUGENEVPNOVERBEKE CITY 0.ERK \ i? D?.?ov n?o oi ` Enclosed herein is the search which you requested made on the above described property. .. ... . .......... Kind of Imorovement Runs Raainnina n.,.......« o..i......,, n.._ ?o?rs 198i , I ,ft?.JLor I further certify that according to the records of said office, the foiloi:ing improve- ments are contemplated or pending after having been approved, and are notia in the process of planning or completion. Kind of Improvement Approximate date o Completion Approrimate cost ?Oh ?e WAIVER: Neither the City of Eagan nor its employees guarantees the accuracy of the atiove in- formation which was requested by the person or pcrsons indicated. Nor does tlie City or its employees assume any liability for tlie correctness thcreof. In consideration for thc supplying of tlie indicated information in the above form, and for all other consideration of any nature whatsoever, any claim against the City or its employees rising there from is hereby expressly waived. Levied assessments to be paid to the Coanty Treasurer at Hastings, DLy. 55033 Very truly y urs, ? TNE LONE OAK TREE ... THE SYMBOL OF STRENGTH AND GROWTH IN OUR COMMUNITY. . . ' ' . ` . . .. . ' . '?'Y._' . .. . . . ' ? . .. ?.: . .. _ . ' . ?: . .. _... ..' ..?.:'.. ' . . . _.i . - . ? r. ? ? : ?.'? ? +.._ ' _ , . : . oas r. ",'<':,-r....•. .r„+:•...;.>?. . _ :,r, ... . - ' " - ,_.ararb? ?d4?"?t.? .:f.,x:S, >.?..o?.q..v.:i::.<';....;??a"n_.r?;x??..' ;-.. . ,'.`,?/.,a9"'f..?t•.i ;x,':Ke'- ??'.X'??.Trv+??Yi" "tr", . . -- .. . . ._ ..... - ... ,......._..T.:. .- . ?ti> i •[ _ ..: . .'-: ...:.:.?'.:...'?.- ..-. . . '>: .. ? "_ .. .. y•"-.q • a:' !v-... ra. -. . ....:.^.a" : - :?j i??- '•)! _ _ .?k :[ - "?'Y•` _ :?1: _ .. . -. . 1 -O ' : Parcel A• /D 03a0 0 o? o D/ sle o 30 That part of the NE4 of Section 32, Township 27, Range 23, Dakota County, Minnesota, described as follows: Commencing at the Northeast corner of Section 32, thence West along the North line of Section 32, 1822,1 feet to the point of beginning, thence South at right angles 510.5 feet, thence West at right angles 256.0 feet, thence North at right angles 510.5 £eet to the North line of Section 32, thence East abng the North line o£ Section 32. 256.0 feet to the point of beginning. :;y: [• - ::t [5 _ '?`, PERMIT City of Eagan Permit Type:Building Permit Number:EA153453 Date Issued:12/19/2018 Permit Category:ePermit Site Address: 1740 Cliff Rd Lot:006 Block: 001 Addition: Section 32 PID:10-03200-01-060 Use: Description: Sub Type:Reroof Work Type:Replace Description:Does not include skylight(s) Census Code:434 - Residential Additions, Alterations Zoning: Square Feet:0 Occupancy: Construction Type: Comments:Please print pictures of ice and water protection and leave on site. Carbon monoxide detectors are required within 10 feet of all sleeping room openings in residential homes (Minnesota State Building Code). Valuation: 4,000.00 Fee Summary:BL - Base Fee $4K $103.25 0801.4085 Surcharge - Based on Valuation $4K $2.00 9001.2195 $105.25 Total: I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Contractor:Owner:- Applicant - Steven H Marstad 1740 Cliff Rd Eagan MN 55122 (612) 508-7113 North Lake Contracting 777 East 7th Street St Paul MN 55106 (651) 487-0000 Applicant/Permitee: Signature Issued By: Signature