1387 Lakeside Dry.., . . . -r +f' •.. y-.... .. . ;,!!15)€ , . a ,. ..
? CITY OF EAGAN
?
?
?
. , 3830 Pilot Knab Road, P.O. Box 21-199, Eagan, MN 55121 ``?• "' '
`'
? PHONE:454-8100 . -, -
BUILDIIVGPERMIT Receipt #
To be useAor DECK Est. Value Date AUG ZZ ,1991
Site Address 1387 I.AiCESIQL DR
Lot Z Block I Sec/Suh. CNBS MAA 13T OFFICE USE ONLY
PafC@I NO. Occupancy - FEES
Zoning
W Ndm@ --RD?O TESSIN (Actual) Const - Bldg. Permit Zs•?
Addf@SS 1?7 L.A?SIDE aR (Allowable) - ?
O Surcharge •
Cilty ZAGAN PhOf18 667-963 1 # of Stories
,0 ? plan Review
Length
o Name UxMIM" CONSTRu =iCM Depth SAC
Cit
? ,
y
o
q Address 4330 IJl10N AYE S S.F. Total
-
v SAC, MCWCC
? CIty MPLS Ph011@ 922-2M S.F. Footprints
-
Water Conn
On Site Sewage _
W W Name On Site Well W
t
M
t
- a
er
e
er
Address MWCCSystem _
i W City PhOn@ ` Ciry Water Acct- DePosit
S/W
PRV Required _ Permit
I hereby acknowlege that I have read this application and state that the 8ooster Pump - g/yy S,rcharge
information is correct- and -Agree to comply wi a11 applicable State of
Minnesota Statules,and City @I Eag n Ordinance . ?
f? Trealment PI
!
^'
Signature of Permitee =---r?" ?--
? APPROVALS
Road Unit
A Building Permit is issugd to: U1111MM" CMTR=10" Planner - Park Ded.
on the express conditiori that all work shall be done in accordance with all Council __ •
applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City ol Eagan Ordinances. gldg, pry. _ CoPies
?
Building Official
Variance -
TOTAL
25•50
Permit No. Permit Holder Date Talephone #
WATER
SEWER
PUJMBING
H.VAC.
ELECTRIC
Inspection Oste Insp. Comments
Footings I
Foundalion .
Framing
Roofing
Rough Plbg.
Rough Htg.
Isul.
FireplaCe
Final Htg.
Orstat Test
Final Plbg. Plbg. Inspector - Notily Plumber
Const. Mefer
EngrJPlan
Bldg. Final
Dedt Ftg. • Z 2 - D.S
Dedc Final
Well
Pr. Disp.
.
BUILDING PERMIT
3795 Pila!
;ITY OP EAGAN
:nob Rood Eapon, MN 55121
PHONE: 454-8100
Receipt #
Ts 6s wed for Est. Volue Dnte 19
Sits Addreu - ' E?ect p Occuponcy
Lot Block Sec/Sub. /?Iter p Zoninq
pamel # Repoir ? Firo Zone
Enlorye ? Type of Canst.
W N? Move p # Stories
; Address Demolish ? Length
?
Ci Pfione Grode ? Depth Sq. Ft.
? Nwm Approrak Few
=o
/lddress
r?w
Nome _
/lddress
I hereby ocknowledge that I have reod this applicution ond state that
the information is torrecf ond ogree to comply wifh all applicoble
State of Minnewtn Srotutes and City of Eagen Ordinences.
Asussment _
Woter & Sew.
Pol ice
Fin
Erp.
Planner
Coundl
Bldp. Off. _
APC
Per?nit
Surcharge
Pian check
SAC
Water Conn.
Woter Meter
Rood Unit
Torol
Sipnoture of Permittee I
/1 Building Permit Is issued to: on the exprcss tondition thnt
oll work shnll be done in accordante wirh all applicable Stote of Mlnnesoto Stntutes and City of Eopon Ordinonces.
Bufldinp Officiol
Permit No. Permit Holder Misc. Permit No. Holdsr
Plumbinp o l q? DW yl? Y- -30 -?j 2
H.V.A.C. 31 (? ' ` ' `
-
g -30
wmi
w.ce.
Diap.
S?war
Elsctric Li2`t S7(p ow 11.. f-c- $-3a -f7
Inspection Date Insp• Othe?
Footinos
Foundati
Fremi
np F
Rouqh Pi ;?176
?
Rouqh HVAC p.To•gL c.tj
???lation ? y ?-
Final Plba
Final HVAC
Final
R?
A??Y T?r?t
Water ,
Wscribe Locati
MWII
5ower
Pr. Dhp.
Receipt
7. Date
?
Permit No.
Fee
S/C
Tot. 3. Job Address -F7 Lot - Blk. Tract
4. Owner - ?;
5. Contractor Phone '
6. Address ?' ? • :
7. {?.Ity .St8t6 Zlp .
8. Building Type: Residential O Commercial O Institutional ?
9. Work Description: New ?
10. Describe
11.
Add ? Al;er ? Repair ?
Fuel Type
No. Equioment BTU - M. Ea.
Forced Air No. E ui ment CFM
Air H
dli
Mfg. " an
ng:
Boilers
Mfg. Mech. Exhaust
Unit Heater
Mfg. Other
Air Cond.
Mfg.
Gas, Piping Outlets
12. I hereby certify that the above information is true and correct, and I agree to
comply with all ordinances and codes governing this type of work.
Signed : for
Rough Final
Inspectians: Date Insp. Date Insp.
This is your permit when numbered and approved.
Approved CITY OF EAGAN 464-8100
MECHANICAL PERMIT
CITY OF EAGAN
FiII in numbered spaces
Type or Print legibly
2. Installation Cost
Receipt ' PLUMBING PERMIT Psrmit No.
CITY OF EAGAN •-
Fee -
Fill in numbered spacea S/C
Type or Prinf /egiWy Tot .
1. Date 2. Installation Cost
/
3. Job Address Lot _ Blk. ? Tract
4. Owner i
5. Contractor !_1
Phone . , A ' ?S' 1 c
6. Address - 7. City State Zip
8. Building Type: Residential ? Commercial ? Institutional 11
9. Work Description: New D Add ? Alter ? Repair ?
I 10. Describe
I 11.
No. Fixtures
Water Closet No. Fixtures
Cesspool/Drainfield
Bath tubs Septic Tank
Lavatory Softner
Shower Well
Kitchen Sink
Urinal/Bidet Other `
Laundry Tray :.i -t L ..?
Floor Drains '
Drinking Ftn.
Slop Sink
Gas Piping Outleu
12. I hereby certify that the above information is true and correct, and 1 agree to
comply with all ordinances and codes governing this type of work.
Signed: for
Rough Final
Inspections: Date Insp. Date Insp.
This is your permit when numbered and approved.
Approved CITY OF EAGAN 454-8100
CITY OF EAGAN Remarks
Addition CEIES MAR lst ADDITION Lot 2 Rlk 1 Parcel 10 17100 020 01
owner ` - 9treet 1387 Lakeside Drive StateESgBA, MN 55123
I ? % •.'S .? 9 i
Improvement Date ?A'tnount Rnnual Years Payment Receipt Date
STREET SURF.
STREET RESTOR.
GRADING
SAN SEW TRUNK ? 28 140.81 A011296 7-30-82
* SEWEF LATERAL ? it it
•
WATERMAIN
• WATER LATERAL 1977
* WATER AREA 1977
* STORM SEW TRK 1977
• STORM SEW LAT 1977
CURB & GUTTER
SIDEWALK
STREET LIGHT
?-WATEFI CONN. 420.00 31830 8-27-82
SUILDING PER, 7471
SAC +t it
PAR K
cirr oF Ea6aN WATER SERVICE PERMIT
3795 PiEot Knob Resd PERMIT IdO.:
Eagoa, MN 55122 DATE:
Zor.ing: - No, of Units:
Owner;
Address:
Site Address:
Plumber:
Meter No.: Connection Chcrge:
S'1e: Account De
osit
p
:
Reader No.: Permit fee:
1 agroe to aomply wlth the Ciryr of Eagon Surchorge:
???nem• Misc. CFwrges:
Totol:
BY Date Paid:
Date of insp
CITY OF EAGAN SEWER SERVICE PERMIT
3795 Pi1ot Knob Road PERMIT NO.:
Eagan, MN 55122 DATE: nZoning: No. of Units:
Owner:
Address:
Site Address: _ •:r ? ?,
Plumber:
1 agrse M eomptr with !he Ciry of Ecgon
Ordinoneer.
Bv
Darte of Insp.:
Connedion Charpe: ,
Account Deposir:
Permit Fee: Surcharge:
Misc. Charges:
Totol:
.' ' , ' = •5
+J•
1 S ?
. `'?} ? •
'' ?t • •
?
.?
? ??.. . . . _?,,,, . . • .
?: ?.- : _;.a;? '_ .. _ _ ' . • _ `! • p _ .
_ ,?t ? - • - . , -
.. ;?- - •- •
• ? ' .
57*- ? • • . " " • ? . ' ? • • •
•
? y - - • .~• • • •• •
w
A Building Permit is i u to: U'1GERMAN CONSTRUCTION
on the express contlifro?ihat all work shall be done in accordance with all
applicable State of Minnesola Statutes and City ot Eagan Ordfnances.
Building Official piJf I I111
1 l
noao vnrt
Planner - Park Ded.
Council
BIdg.Off. _ CaPies
Variance - TOTAL 25.50
CITY OF EAGAN N? 19589
3630 Pilot Knob Road, P.O. Box 21-199, Eagan, MN 55121
? PHONE: 454-8100 p.
BUILDING PERMIT Receipt # ? I?rl Cl
To be used for DECK Est. Value Date AUG 22 , 19 91
Site Address 1387 LAKESIDE DR
Lot 2 Block i Sec/Sub, CHES MAR 1ST
Parcel No.
w IName RONALD TESSIN
o Address 1387 LAKESIDE DR
city EAGAN Phone 687-9631
o Name UNGERMAN CONSTRUCTION
$a Addre55 4330 UPTON AVE S
' City MPLS Phone 922-2800
?W Name
t3Address
<W City Phone
I here6y acknowlege that I have read this application and state lhat the
information is corr nd ree m comply 't all applicable State of
Mmnesota Statute and City 1 Eag n Ordin nce
Signawre ol Permi e
A Building Permit is i u ?o: ?GERMAN CONSTRUCTION
on the express condiY thai all work shall be done in accordance wrth all
appliwble State ot Minnesota StaWtes and City of Eagan Ordinances.
8uiltling ONicial
Occupancy
Zoning
(Adual) Cons[
(Allowable)
# orstones
length
Depth
S.F. 7otal
S F Footpnnts
On Sile Sewage
On Siie Well
MWCC Syslem
Ciry water
PRV Required
Booster Pump
APPROVALS
Planner
COUncA
BIdg.Ofl
Vananca
OFFICE USE ONLY
20'
in,
FEES
Bldg. Permn
surcnarge
Plan Reviaw
SAC, Cily
SAC,MCWCC
Water Conn
Wetar Meter
Accl. Deposit
SM! Permit
S/W Sumharge
Treatment PI
Road Unn
Park Ded.
Copies
TOTAI
25.00
.50
25.50
CITY OF EAGAN
7795 Pilef Knob Raod Eegan, MN 53142 NO 7471
BUILDINGVERMIT PHONE: 434•8100 Rece'pt # ???3cJ
Te 6s uad fe. SF DGIG/GAR Est.tal,e $63,000 pote Au9ust 26 _ 1 q 82
Siee Address 1387 Lakeside Drive E
r 9 O
- R-3
rec [ ccuponcy
Lor 2 Block 1 See/Su6. Ches MdY 1St Alrer p Zoning R-1
Parcel # 10 17100 020 Ol Repotr ? ?Zone NA
V
Enlarpe ? of Conn.
n Name Wal.tai Raro kbv ri
•
# St
W e ? o
es
2 Address 3262 Vallev 12idge Drive Demolish ? Length 54
ci Ea gan 55121 pham 452-1910 Grode ? Depth 42 Sq. Ft.-
o Nome ?er AOVrovoh Faea
?? Addrest
Nome _
Address
1 hereby acknowledge that I haVe read fhis applicafion ond stote that
fhe information is correct and agree to wmply with all oppiicoble
Stata of Minnewtu Stotutes ond City of Eogon Ordinances.
Sipnolure of Pertnittee
A 8uildin9 Permif is issued to:
oll work sholl be done in accordance with
Bulldinq Official /
Assessment
Water 8 Sew.
Police permit 3[L . V V
Surcharge 31.50
Plan check161.00
Firs sAC sas.oo
Erq.
Plonner
Council Water Conn.420.00
WaterMeter 60.00
Road Unif NA
Bldg. Off.
APC Total S?51,.50
on i he express condition thai
svtS3tatutes ond City of Eagon Ordirwnces.
/
?0
'W ?ql-C
CITY OF EA('?AN ? Include 2 sets of plans,
1 site plan w/el.evations &
BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION 1 set of energy calculations.
ed For ? F I?ul (?q ? Valuation
To Be Us
? ??/1 Q a Date
OFFICE USE ONLY
Site Adr3ress: ????,y?s,:?• '?,-?-
Lot ? slock ? sec./sub.ekcs Mar'1--'?-
Parcel #: (D t-71 C,C) Oc'A p I
Owner= /T ? a
P.cidress • 5114&,
?1.at
City/Zip Code:
Erect X mcupancy
Alter Zoning
Repair Fire Zonp
EYilarge _ 7]pe of Const.
Move # Stories
Dennlish Front ? ft.
Grade Depth ft.
Phone #: - /9/ d APPROUALS FEE'S
Contractor: QWY\P-`r
Address:
City/Zip Code:
Phone #:
Arch./F7ig.. _
Address:
City/Zip Code:
Phone #:
_
Assessments
WatEr/Sewer
Polioe _
Fire
Eng.
Planner
Counc:il
Bldg. Off.
APC
Pezmit
Surcharge ?
Plan Check
SAC
Water Conn. -Yjn ?-
Wat,er Meter _Z_0 .?
Road Unit &N
RaTAL
This repuest.void
niiii
-Z'3404 --?} -M6.`0z;-%
Request DaZte?
? Fne No. Requ mGl?nspeciio? ?Raatly Nowlfil Will Not?fy Insper
f
$ ?Y?s ?No torWhenlReady
? i
? Licensed Electrical ConVactor I harebY requast msuecLOn of above
?,Owrier elec4wal work instelled eY. ? ??' ??
Street Atldross. Box or Home No. City
? ??
eclwn o. TownsMp ame or Na. FnnBn o. Caunty
Occuv.r-t (PPWT) Phont Ne.'
2 96
Power SupVlrer c Address
Electrical
ontraMOr lCOmpanv Namal
C racmr's License No.
1
w
MdilinB AtlJress (Contractor or Owner Mnkmg Insiaila on)
? C...
Authori ed ignature (Convact Owner Meki Instell bonl Phone Number
L? ? BI , ckFS MA N I S? C3 I lo (l7
>
MINNESOTq SSATE 00AflD OF ELECTRICITY . THIS INSPECTION HEaUEST WILL NOT
Gri9§s•Mitlway Bltlg. - Room N-797 BE ACCEPTED BY THE STATE BOANO
UNLESS PROPEH INSPECTION FEE IS
1827 Vnivarsity Ave., St. Peul, MN 65704
.... ,.- .,.. ..... ENCLOSED.
(/'?, REQUEST FQR ELECTRICAL INSPECTION ,i; ??oooo?
L? joa
?? f 5?"s ? See instruchans for comp1a1in9 <his form on back of yellow copy. ,? ?I7
"'X?? Belaw ?ark Covered by This Requesr 31 ? ''i -I
B Aad Rep. Type af 8wlding ' AppiiencBS Wired EqmpmBn[ WirBd
Home " Range: Tempoiary Service
Duplex Water Heater Lighiin Fixtures
Apt. Bwldmg Dryer Electric Heatun
Commercial Bldg. Furnace Silo Unloader
Industnal Bldg. Air Conditioner Bulk Milk Tanlc
Farm omer oeci v) in"„ (sNec,ry)
ther Suer,i y Othcr Otho3r
Computelnspecbon fee Below -
k Fea ServiceEntmneeSize k Fee Feedars/Subfeeders U Fee Cvcwts
6, 00 0 to 100 Am s 0 tu 30 Am s 3O1 0 to 30 Am
101 to 200 qmps 3112 100 Amps ip 31 to 700 Am s
Above 200 Amps Above 100_Amp Above 100_Amps
Transiormers Remote Control Circ + SO PartiaNOther Fee
Signs Speciai lnspection , ?
t
$
Remarks ? T AL
Rouyh-m
el
Fi na l certdy thac the nbove
nsp en
? e.
This request wid
18 nionchs finm ?`? aJ?
?ttr?'tftrtt#r vf Orrupttnrg
I Citp of (Eagan
IOrpbrttnrnt nf +?uiiding 3nsprrtimc
Thu Cati firatt iltued Purtuanr to the nqurremrntt of Sertion 306 o) the Umform Builrling
Codt arti fyrng that at t!x time of irsuantr lbir rNUrturr wuf in tomPlianre wit6 the variour
ordinuruer of thtCity rcgulating 6uilding rontt+utrion or utc. For the fo!/owing:
SF DWG/GAR 7471
Bld& Rmuc No.
U.
o?w? rra R3 riroc?w? V F?R? NA zo?w?' -
eaa.ea?1387 Lakeside DriveL,wnYTot 2 Btock 1 Ches Mar lst
Thsl&.J>I E'??"^- ? December 14, 1982
e.ddft o? SA_ mw
.a.. .. . .1c.a,. ...,..
1991 SIIIIUqPLICATION
CITY OF EAGAN
SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS
HULTIPLE DWELLINGS
ftC i s
COMMERCIAL
?
?
2 SETS OF PLANS 2 SETS OF PLANS 2 SETS OF ARCHITECTURAL
3 REGISTERED SITE SURVEYS REGISTERED SITE SURVEYS - & STRUCTURAL PLANS ?
1 SET OF ENERGY CALCULATIONS (CHECK WITH 9LDG. DEPT.) 1 SET OF SPECIFICATIONS
1 SET OF ENERGY CALCL3IATIONS 1 SET OF ENERGY CALCS
OF RENTAL UNITS
_# OF FOR SAI.E UNITS
YENALTY APPLIES WHEN: TYPING OF PERMIT IS REQUESTED, BUT NOT PICKED UP BY 1.4ST WORKING DAY
OF MONTH IN WHICH REQUEST IS MADE.
IAT CHANG E IS REQUESTED ONCE PERMIT IS ISSUED.
NOTE: ADDRESSES FpR CORNER IATS - CONTRACTOR/HDMEOWNER MUST DESIGNATE WHICH ADDRESS IS
DESIRED. NO CHANGES WILL BE ALIAWED ONCE BUILDING PERMIT IS ISSUED
PROCESSING TIME FOR 5EWER & WATER YERMTTS IS TWO DAYS ONCE A PERMIT HAS BEEN COMPLETED.
PERMIT MUST SHOW A LICENSED PLUMBER.
To Be Used For: Q e LK- Valuation:
Site AddYess 13 S-7 La k cs -? zrr5-
Lot Z Block ?
Pazcel/Sub C-HE5 /N,*k 1$7--e41a&
Owner R ana L d rQi,S S!L-'
Address ? ? oO7 Lct I `? 'rJ ? a 'c
City/Zip Code 6?41 1 4 h v1,3
Phone b b' 7- 9 6_3 I
Contractor UWl q e r' mQl.0?,,5
Address qJ 3e? vpL, p\+Q.,S
City/2ip Code SJ\ L?jU
Phone _L 2- 2- - 2-o
Arch./Engr.
Address
City/Zip Code
Phone #
Sewer/Water Licensed Contr
Date:
IISE ONLY
Occupancy
Zoning
Actual Const
Allowable
# of stories
Length
S.F. Total
Footprint S.F.
` fl
On site sewage_
On site well _
MWCC System _
City water _
'Booster Pump _
APPROVALS
Planner _
Council
Bldg. Off.
Variance
FEES 1S ofl
Bldg. Permit '
Surcharge •?
Plan Review
SAC, City
SAC, MWCC
Water Conn.
Water Meter
Acct. Deposit
S/w Permit
S/W Surcharge
Treatment P1.
Road Unit
Park Ded.
Trail Ded.
Copies
SUBTOTAL
Penalty
Lot Change
TOTAL o75• S o
agrees that all work ahall be done in accordance with
(Signature of Contractor)
all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances.
,4 ,
i
i
I
?
--?.
?h
?
. !?
I
. ?
PROPERIY
LINE
REAR PROPERIY LINE
PROPERIY
3 ? LINfi
/Y
(v
; Feoet ?
' a .
Garage
n
tor ?-----? BLoac r- ? T
L
dUps IVIAR
FRONT PROPERTY LINfi
?12 LARRYS.SEVERSON
JAMES F. SHELDON
1. PATRICK WILCOX
MICHAELG.DOUGHERTY'
MICHAEL E. MOLENDA
SEVERSON, WILCOX & SHELDON, P.A.
A PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION
AITORNBYS AT LAW
KENNETFIR.HALL
SCOTT D. lOHNSTON
LORIN M. SOLFEST
ANNEITE M. MARGARIT
EDWIN R.HOLMES
BRADLEY SMITH
DANIEL M. SHERIDAN
SHARON K. HILLS
600 MIDWAY NATIONAL BANK BUILDING
7300 W FST 147TH STREET
APPLE V ALLEY, MINNESOTA 55124
(612) 432-3136
TELEFAX NUMBER 432-3780
June 2, 1993
Thomas H oyd
Winth p & Weinstine, P.A.
-EI 0 Minnesota World Trade Center ?
32
East Seventh Street ?
St. Paul, MN 55101
Re: Bingham, et al. v. Karo, et al.
Dear Mr. Boyd:
OFCOUNSEL:
JOHN E. WKELICH
This letter is a follow up to our telephone conversation of June 2,
1993. At that time, I indicated that I have asked Mr. Bill Bruestle
of the City of Eagan not to sign the Affidavit you proposed. I have
no objection to Mr. Bruestle statinq that he prepared the report that
was in the City's files. However, I have asked him not to participate
further than that.
While we have no
party, competing p
to verify their
circumstances, it
"taking sides".
intent to cause additional hardship or cost to any
irties have contacted Mr. Bruestle, each asking him
particular version of the facts. Given those
is appropriate that the City not appear to be
,.QJ
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
Very truly yours,
SEVERSON, WILCOX & SHELDON, P.A.
James F. Sheldon
JFS/wkt
cc: Tom Hedges, City Administrator ,
Doug Reid, Chief Building Official j
Bill Bruestle, Lead Construction Inspector
INOIVIDUALATiORNEYSALSOLICENSEDINIOIXA. WISCONSIV.CALIFORtiIAORNEBRASKA
•CERIIFIED REAL PROPERTY LAW SPP.CIAlIST. MSBA
vi
SHERMAN WINTHROP
ROBERT R. WEINSTINE
RICHARO A. HOEL
ROGER D. GORODN
STEVEN C TDUREN
STEPHEN J. SNYDER
HART NULLER
DAV10 P. PEFRSON
THOMAS M. HART IV
OARRON C I(NUTSON
JOHN A. KNAPP
MICNELE O.VAILIANCOURT
DAVID E. MORAN, JR
DONALD J. BFOWN
JONJ.HOGANSON
SANORAJ MARTIN
GART W.SCHORMILLER
TODD B. URNE55
SCOTT J. OONGOSNE
PETERJ.GLEEKEI
ROBERT S.SOSKIN
EDWARO J.DRENTTEL
JEFFREY W. COOIt
JEFFREY R.ANSEL
LAURIEP..NNOCKE
WILLIAM F. MOHRMAN
August 20, 1991
/ - , 2 4/ CJCa-
W I N T H R O P & W E I N S T I N E
ATTORNEYS AND COVNSELORS AT LAW
3200 MINNESOTA WORLD TRADE CENTER
30 EAST SEVENTH STREET
SAINT PAUL,MINNESOTA 55101
TELEPHONE16121290-6400
FAX 16121292-9347
DIRECT DIAL
(612) 290-8435
Protective Inspection's Department
City of Eagan
3830 Pilot Knob Road
P.O. Box 21199
Eagan, MN 55122
LLOYD W GROOMS JOPNNE L MATZEN
JULIE N. WILLIAMSON TIMOTHY H. MASTERSDN
MARK T,JOHNSON EVAN O COOBS
BETSYJ LOUSNIN THOMASA.WPLMER
OROONS F POLEV GINA M. GROTHE FOLLEN
JULIE WIDLET SCHNELL E.JOSEPH NEWTON
CHRISTV JO CASPERS PATRICR W. WE6ER
TMOMAS H BOYD CHARLES A.OURANT
JOSEPH C NAUMAN CRAIG A.BRANOT
DANIEL C. 6ECH OAVIO P.KRISTPL
ERICJ.NYSTROM KARLA.WEBER
BRIAN J. ItLEIN ALOK VIDYARTHI
HRISTIN L PETERSON
OANIEL W.HARDY
OFCOUNSEL
HAND DELIVERED
Re: Inspection
1387 Lakeside Drive, Eagan, Minnesota August 10, 1991
Dear Sir/Madam:
Our office has been retained by G. Dennis Bingham who was involved in an accident
at the above residence on August 9, 1991. Enclosed please find an executed
Authorization Form allowing our office to examine any and all records regarding the
above incident and investigation of this matter. Additionally, we request any and all
building permits that were issued for the above property.
If you have any questions regarding this request, please do not hesitate to contact
me at your earliest convenience.
Very truly yours,
WIIVTHROP & WEINSTINE
/
Bv
Anthony J. Kulinski
Legal Assistant
AJK:ehm
Enclosure
cc: Robert S. Soskin, Esq.
AUTHORIZATION FORM
TO: Protective Inspections Department
City of Eagan
3830 Pilot Knob Road
P.O. Box 21199
Eagan, MN 55122
RE: G. Dennis Bingham
Date of Birth: 10/1/46
You are authorized to give the Winthrop & Weinstine law firm, 3200 Minnesota
Worid Trade Center, 30 East Seventh Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55101, or their
representatives, any and all information which they may request regarding the home
accident which occurred at 1387 Lakeside Drive in Eagan, Minnesota on August 9,
1991 on my behalf. You may allow their representative to examine any records you
may have regarding the above incident and/or investigation and to make photocopies
of films or investigatory reports. You may also discuss the investigation of the
above incident with them.
A photocopy of this authorization is as valid as the original bearing my
signature.
Dated:
.
G. ennis Bingham
MEMORANDUM
TO: DOUG REID, CHIEF BUILDING OFFICIAL
FROM: BILL BRUESTLE, LEAD CONSTRUC'I'ION IN3PECT'OR (BUILDING)
DATE: AUGUST 14, 1991
RE: INSPECTION OF COLLAPSED DECK
1387 LAKFSIDE DRIVE
On Monday morning, August 12, 1991, at approximately 10:30 a.m., Dale Wegleitner, Fire
Marshal, and I made an inspection of 1387 Lakeside Drive of a deck that collapsed on
Friday evening, August 9, 1991, at approximately 8:30 p.m. We met Mrs. Zoe (tenant) and
took some pictures of the deck which was lying on the ground appropmately 20' from the
house, resting against a tree. Mrs. Zoe stated they had a party at the home, 10-12 people
were on the deck, when all of a sudden it started pulling away from the house and crashed
to the ground. When it hit the ground, no one was left on the deck. L.ooking at the
construction materials used, and how it was attached to the home, it appeared that all
materials used were allowed by Code. The rim joist of the deck was attached over the top
of the siding, plus the frieze board; the fasteners used were either a 16 or 20 penny d nail.
There were six nails used to nail the deck to the house; the deck was approximately 16' +
wide. The width of the deck would show that amount of fasteners was not sufficient enough
to withstand the load of the deck. It appeared that over a period of time, the deck started
to come away from the house so when it was used for a number of people, it gave way.
Mrs. Zoe stated that the neighbors commented the deck was added a year or two after the
home was constructed.
Our records indicate the house was under construction in August of 1982 with an occupancy
permit being issued on December 14, 1982. There is no indication oF any deck footing or
deck inspections, indicating to us the deck was not put on during the month of December
and a separate deck permit and inspections were never called in.
It appears that over a period of time the deck began separating from the house and when
a number of people were on the deck, it loosened up and pushed away from the house. By
collapsing from the house, it put pressure on the posts and sheared them off at the ground.
The pictures will remain with this memo for review.
Lead Construction Inspector (Building)
WB/js
?
y
EXTERIOR rINELCP"-- AVERAGE '-U ` COPt?liTATIO?I
041NER
SITE ADDRESS_/
CONTRACTOR (J?[f41E,e- DATZ PHOFJE_
Determi.ne rrorking square footage of each.
1. Total exposed wall area ... 1 ?'/ Z sq. ft. x.19 = 373
2. Total roof/ceiling area ... /'VE sq. ft. x.04
Total exposed wall area above floor =
a. Total wall winZcw area ................. /70
b. Total door area ........................ #2=
c. Total sliding glass area .............. 8S"
d. Total fireplace vtall area ......... . ?
e. Total wall framing area (average 10%)...?
f. Total net wa11 area above floor ........
S. Total rim ,joist are2 .................. /22
Total exposed fcundation area = JD 7
h. Total foundation rrindow area .......... -
I. Total zet foundation area above g^ade . / 0,7
Determine "U' value of each wall segment.
a. 170 X "U':
b . ?? X "U"
c.?? X "U"
D. X "U'
e.? X 'U"
f X "U':
P• X IlU..
h. X "U'
s'
a ?
.09 = L
. o Z = S, 1
i. / 0.7 X': '' ? a O? 3
3............................................ Total R o2 7 8
I: item #3 is tne same as, or less than item N1, you have met the
intent of SBC E006(c)2.
Total exposed roof/ceiling area
J. Total akylight area ........... ...
k. Total roof/ceiling frar.;in.m area (average 10%
1. iotal net insulated roof/ceilir.C area ........ J,o 7 ?.Tl=
-r
Determine "U; value for each roof/ceiling'segctent.
e e-
,nZs @ z?.
4 .........................................Tot81 Q ?=
J X "U.
k. J I S X"U"
1. ?o33_X .Upr
If total of l.'a is the same as, or less than 92, you have met the
intent of SHC 6006(c)1.
Alternate Buiidiiig Envelope Design
To utilize the total envelope systera method, the values established
by the sum of items N3 and N4 shall not be greater than the suz2,of
items ffl an3 92.
i. 373 + z.
3. z??' + 4.
. i ?
? ' • ? ' . ' FS.[.4?1,
? ' ' . ?"•''-Lh.
• ??-
l , laT•?,I? ??`i?;??'o {G°? ?/?.??Gf_ s:?O?'c?>`7 = ,
"y?,:
TiG HT A' jf / ?= S7`f S, iC"
- L4?T- x
. ZZ .s?
/2 ,9) = '
C
, i o ? o
?-.: .
_ .. . . . .. . _ . ? ' ,
: 5•1 - "'t` _::.:: ' li. Y.. ? _ - - _ _ _ :.,'?:
??:::• _
. . . . . . . . . .?.LY ?r,_ 1 .?
'." _ _ ._ . ..... . . .. ." ' ' ?..?" _ ' J?_. .
,?o:"' .'"'....,. •? .......... ....?-?_ ?.,,?'...-.'__'._..,_..._.._.__.?.:.__.. _..._........_? ? .,
F',?o,v7- ?Lc ?/ ,
u=,sz , 11(PsNi?l6),
cx u=SZ, PEMNC?)
tJ ?PEN14
e ?Fs,?.
3,>,? 7
.? . ?f??c ??zH??r?? ?,??? = o l (yy?-7r-?.??;?.z? ).=?? s F
Y q S -. 7/ - .2 C- 33 -- 2-7 = ??? s F
a"I SF
i
Ai??aE GR.9 `
t?-xT05r--D F o u N D?r?? ?(1'?V ocJ/ a)?ocv_= ?? 5F
?. ?
c z3S-? U?, sz?? .9 =%.9 s?=
2G. . ,.. sF
161A LL F?jzA /!-! / ?JG ?%/z??9
3el S,F;
?
? -GZ ? fifJiAJ.1?or?s ; yt?o ?vE'
.?. , A49 ?rylz-
OfaLL AR6e4 393 5F
?
3 Se s,F."
U
_ Ex Po Sc-D /50,f ?0/) T/oltl ?No
,
2? Gt???r.va?vs ? Co2s?Z, v=?sZ, /?='?o,sl ??
32.s 3 sr-,
-
73-S5=2?=. ?.6' SF.-
? /1/?i .1lJ?GC /? Iz? ?- = ??[ ?f 8 ?7 3 -?s- zG -Z7>'= .?3'? sF
_ i
. ,
'50 4??D 6R4E avR _
A F
n
-41 , -
'r"?' ` / ?'Js ?o hl?? = ? ?
-- ---
--- -- Sil
3/t/ '". !t/av? i??J?V?C = • 9S-
l N
. ? , _ . I.)A
G'x T: ?? 2 F'ru?, , 1 7
'. . ?LylvooD ,oy,7
"
Z.
II(/ sv49Ta?l
.1NS?D?-?J?/Zlz?Cr?
Ez .5
, 1 t-t
VL U
(/ A L1JI?S
E oN.? ,Dt?^ ?? ..
ST
?s "PLa-T?>
iINS 73d
/ i Woo17 /? ? g - -
?-----
- - - ! NT, % rR
? oyZ.
-?2??53.:. ?...
--?. , /:Fo u rv b6r1n A/ K)A[. (- ; , -? -- .
/2'1 l?.Loc1?- l ,.2?5 _ ,.
--- ?_ . 105 ? Di5-A i 7Z, f i LfK
. ?
.^..... 2?15 = o4(7
;471zlq,k«N6
? : -- - - _ 3j7
ve-,9T/? ?v
.--- -- -- - - ?
,? = - -- --_
e9s ?_ .
.,
?', G -- - -- _. .--
3 ?-
. o ? S. .- -- ---- -- _ -. - - --
Of9
- ? --
co?.,?- ?
-k FXT/9?R FiUh ?e Z2_
__ .._ . . .: Y-3?
_k
?-.
!
t
?
?
.??
z o.'s
PROPERTY
LINE
i
ELV.
SITE PLAri
M
m
m
?r
i REAR PAOPERTY LIN£
PROPERTY
LINE
at
?
?
DZ, ) i ?b
IAI' t?? ! BIACK
r ?
2-
d?ps MAR !s
?
1
RONT PROPERIY LINE
)?+ 1 4w
a
n
1?k dty oF cagan
3795 PILOT KNOB ROAD. P.O. BOX 21199 BEA BLOM9UiST
EAGAN, MINNESOTA 55121 Mavor
PHONE: (612) 454-8100 THOMAS EGAN
JAMES A SMITH
JERRV TNOMAS
THEODORE WACHiER
DA"_'F.: May, 29., 1484 CouncilMembees
THOMAS HEDGES
CIN Atlminshator
EUGENE VAN OVERBEKE
Gry Ciere
PENmrrlc AssESSrmvT saARM
RE: Ches Mar lst, Lot 2, Block 1
1387 Lakeside priye, F,agan, hW 55123
Parcel # 16 171QR Q2Q 01
Reguesteci by: Universal Title Insurance CQ.
14500- 6urnhaven Drive
Suite 159
Burnsville, MN 55337
I CERTIFI' THAT ACCORUIIVG 910 THE RE?CORDS OF SAID OFF'ICE, '!?: F0=9IP?G II"II'ROVII`nI'I'S
ARE 0017TEfIPLATID OR PENDING AFTIIt HAVINTG BEEN APPROVED, AND ARE NOW IN ',"FIE PROC._'F'SS
OF PLANNING OR (.'C'iPI,ETION.
xinq o* Iicprovenent Approximate (iate of Compledon Approximate cost
NONE
T'II12VER:
Neither the City of Eagan nor its enployees guarantees the accuracy of the above in-
formation which was requested by the person or persons indicated. Nor does the City
or its employees asstmie any liability for the correctness thereo£. In consideration
for the supplying of the indicated infoxmation in the above form, and for all othPs
consideration of any nature whatsoever, any claim against the City or its employees
rising there fran is hereby expressly caaiveci. Levied assessmenfis to be paid to the
COUA]TY TREASUREF2 AT HASTINTS, MN. 55033 or CI'"Y Or EAC'zAN.
Very tsuly yours,
SPECIAL ASSESSNM'C DIVISION
THE IONE OAK TREE. .THE SYMBOL OF STRENGTH AND GROWTH IN OUR COMMUNIN
PERMIT
City of Eagan Permit Type:Mechanical
Permit Number:EA146154
Date Issued:10/11/2017
Permit Category:ePermit
Site Address: 1387 Lakeside Dr
Lot:2 Block: 1 Addition: Ches Mar 1st
PID:10-17100-01-020
Use:
Description:
Sub Type:Residential
Work Type:Replace
Description:Furnace
Comments:Questions regarding electrical permit requirements should be directed to State Electrical Inspector, Mark Anderson at (952)
445-2840.
Please call Building Inspections at (651) 675-5675 to schedule a final inspection.
Fee Summary:ME - Permit Fee (Replacements)$59.00 0801.4088
Surcharge-Fixed $1.00 9001.2195
$60.00 Total:
I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State
of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances.
Contractor:Owner:- Applicant -
Angela Packard
1387 Lakeside Dr
Eagan MN 55123
Haley Comfort Systems
4320 Hwy 52 N
West Frontage Rd
Rochester MN 55901
(507) 281-0138
Applicant/Permitee: Signature Issued By: Signature
Use BLUE or BLACK Ink
•
WFor Office Use -1
CAA" of
F1] ll
Permit#: i7zj DEL 21241 /:�,—
3830 Pilot Knob Road Permit Fee: •
Eagan MN 55122 Date Received:
. Phone: (651) 675-5675
Fax: (651 • - .94 L Staff:
J
2017 : ' SIDENTIAL PLUMBING PERMIT APPLICATION
Date: •� ._- , Site Address: )31q 3 %L.-.21-kivkm/ J'4-'- I
(t
Tenant: ` Cts, e
,�,T y t'r t n , Vim`'��'� Suite#:.
r1 4 1 Name: n ` ��vi., l
KIPhone:li , y ( ,5 �i1f1
h't� tl,( :�).f4;, Address/City/Zip: , R ' ) ?
t�f 7110")",:,-Ict i t ((� I� ,,_ I �u�/ �� � t 1{ 44 I � + - Name: V U l��l�'V y ��, l� r — l 1��
s �� License#:
o rim,'lti.fli xia . �s Address: (� \"� , Co 1
aC:�,es,.�t,�'�ar � �O � -� �� City��y'� I �f/�� 1
•'k1-41 �{�°�5�s�jt'y'w �;; tit,: ,.
Sq$ 1iai:t' ` 'f' rtr ' State: r( �0 )/ _ ( t ��'��� (
! Zlp: � Phone:
y'i=ft. + 4 I
io t;' 11t`%t•�t{�,'' l .l Contact: 4 • hi t.' l __ lel�IJII G
Email; Lu. • Q r
ri J
u_1.0 �. —New —Replacement Repair Rebuild Modify Space Work In R,O.W.
,i!+II :-•tit i,,AP nikiliI,-,,,1 Description of work:
i iii`ii.i, RESIDENTIAL
•; x f5 Water Heater
6 :` , iftit
iii+ • y Water Softener
A-
t-Ji -, '+;fit Lawn Irrigation ( RPZ/ PVB) —
y + Ype
Ilt. r" x —Septic System —Add Plumbing Fixtures ( Main/ Lower Level)
,. "h } r' r- G' Tt New Water Turnaround
tt�%tis`Apt,,h,`�4�h�'ifri�k"{kntf>i_�r>�;ii�;st'` —Abandonment
RESIDENTIAL FEES:
$60.00 Water Heater, Water Softener, or Water Heater and Softener(includes State Surcharge)
$60.00 Lawn Irrigation (Includes State Surcharge)
$60.00 Add Plumbing Fixtures, Septic System Abandonment, Water Turnaround* (Includes State Surcharge)
`Water Turnaround (add $280,00 If a 3/4"meter Is required)
$115.00 Septic System New(includes County fee and State Surcharge)
TOTAL FEES $
CALL BEFORE YOU DIG. Call Gopher State One Call at(651) 454-0002 for protection against underground utility damage.
Call 48 hours before you intend to dig to receive locates of underground utilities, www.gopherstateonecall.orq
I hereby acknowledge that this information is complete and accurate; that the work will be in conformance with the ordinances and codes of the City of
Eagan; that I understand this is not a permit, but only an application for a permit, and work is not to start without a permit; that the work wit be in
accoorddaance)with
thheeaapproved plan In he c se/of wworrkk.wtyich requires a review and approval of plans,
xA.,w,
Applicants Printed Name Applicant's Signature
+(4fSI,i ( A IS:?liiF'}I�'>�iy"Y(kY s\,'44411{-�s�'�i+`F;1;i<7>��t-°}��i:?lY,�ij1),t Irt f1)) iN��� �'V�j_��} e14 t` `•�,lr)(: . j�zl�,ydt :.w y): .:4'74/'
a _
+� r at 11)1 4.,.Y4 f I<6 tl E t F, si? r is�4� tv f_,t,'� ,I 4, f 44 s Y 1`` 'fit ,, kl
F.`,f Q Fci r C''r S; 7 . . ;'•�c.} 6 1,yc} 1, 3+y, ?t R w C`_ x i P` �t(u �;t: t,: ' 1, ,` 1 y, it
if�����, �.- 1�)2.ow, + �i�j^iJ tl,i�•''�Idi!r�(rl`•y,5)��'ti�l'��(t�t�t(. Y�7 Q(..tQ;d��y ,..x. ����5 �1..YY,X.:I.t!ial4�i4� ��yt -, ,?,..w.y��' t,{ �t,
r,„ .0 B `Ijt,, r, {Eq. t f,,,:ji:,,,, ,,I....4,A, ..,1,`;is'tnrityrtji,:f� .�+ci ;, s6,-,0 ) t ,i, i ,A;) .n k3 t.k:.) f rJ,k,01Ltn ` �;', e .; , , 8;r Grqu I dsi4 o ,� o ugh' ([, ?t 1p49 ;>p ,��fficl , _ ,,. :' � a , y,� ;, i ti jl . ; 03410,1004V111441%
rt)li(I+i�- P j ,t(:C{y !„`�_IL 4. 9. } 1 lits .9jj l (y f i.:.,, , 4 5..',I 1}'•'.i= ,h ,." Sit
M!elNE4,�1,,tz! }( 4,0040,4' h iF.5; f 0 4 d2 i�.. 1 is j y& ii lIrk�t�'?'fC I fV 4f' + , ( ° /pill `'.'
$. ate Ite .$� {! I. hcli " + I„,2� N k 51 4sa +?��t . . t[i'ot . v ,t'. ¢ ”" '1 !' r$
„„u ,'ti$,.,.,:, �:,,,v1�1, , 4X�rt, . e} ,t.<�.,� :tuV-M a•di161:R;e�,dM�.,.f,.4,,Ma_o:•ehe 4?k�•.:t:,it . : r, . . t t
PERMIT
City of Eagan Permit Type:Building
Permit Number:EA162561
Date Issued:07/20/2020
Permit Category:ePermit
Site Address: 1387 Lakeside Dr
Lot:2 Block: 1 Addition: Ches Mar 1st
PID:10-17100-01-020
Use:
Description:
Sub Type:Reroof
Work Type:Replace
Description:Does not include skylight(s)
Census Code:434 - Residential Additions, Alterations
Zoning:
Square Feet:0
Occupancy:
Construction Type:
Comments:Please print pictures of ice and water protection and leave on site.
Carbon monoxide detectors are required within 10 feet of all sleeping room openings in residential homes (Minnesota State
Building Code).
Valuation: 5,000.00
Fee Summary:BL - Base Fee $5K $118.00 0801.4085
Surcharge - Based on Valuation $5K $2.50 9001.2195
$120.50 Total:
I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State
of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances.
Contractor:Owner:- Applicant -
Angela Packard
1387 Lakeside Dr
Eagan MN 55123
Xlnt Built
8500 Normandale Lake Blvd., Suite 350
Bloomington MN 55437
(612) 562-1487
Applicant/Permitee: Signature Issued By: Signature