The URL can be used to link to this page

698 Northbridge Ct Use BLUE or BLACK Ink I ~Ir;Qf~etF L ~ j Permit q~ I I City of Eapn I 3830 Pilot Knob Road R E C IF I V E D i Permit Fee: Eagan MN 55122 NOV Q 9 ZQ~Q i Date Received: Phone: (651) 675-5675 Fax: (651) 675-5694 Staff: 2010 MECHANICAL ~ PERMIT APPLICATION Date: Site Address: `N T 1 V C" Tenant: 00_,W^ a \nr 1('3 Suite RESIDENT/ OWNER Name: `I - Phone: C0 S~-Us( 0 ~W e Address/ City / Zip: -R 1a4AhbnAAj l) b9cln 3 Name: BURNSVILLE HEATING & A/C, INC. License #6 1 CONTRACTOR 3451 W. Burnsville Parkway Address: Suite 120 City: Burnsville, MN 55337 State: Zip: Phone: "l C Contact: ~1~ y1 Email: TYPE OF WORK New X Replacement Additional Alteration Demolition 1r l Description of work: K,L AT( NOTE; Roof mounted and gnound moon mechanical egµipmerl is.toquited lo,tse'scrsened by City. . Code.- Please contact the Mechanical Inspector or information an permitted screening methods. PERMIT TYPE RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL Furnace _ New Construction _ Interior Improvement Air Conditioner _ Install Piping _ Processed _YL _ Air Exchanger _ Gas Exterior HVAC Unit _ Heat Pump _ Under / Above ground Tank Install / _ Remove) When installing/removing tank(s), call for inspection by Fire Other Marshal and Plumbing Inspector RESIDENTIAL FEES: $50.50 Minimum Add-on or alteration to an existing unit (includes $.50 State Surcharge) $90.50 Fire repair (replace burned out appliances, ductwork, etc.) (includes $.50 State Surcharge) $ - TOTAL FEE COMMERCIAL FEES: $70.50 Underground tank installation/removal OR Contract Value $ x1% $50.50 Minimum (includes State Surcharge) Permit Fee - If Permit Fee is less than $1,000, surcharge is $.50. - If Permit Fee is > $1,000, surcharge increases by $.50 for each Surcharge $1,000 Permit Fee (i.e. a $1,001-$2,000 Permit Fee requires a $1.00 surcharge). TOTAL FEE CALL BEFORE YOU DIG. Call Gopher State One Call at (651) 454-0002 for protection against underground utility damage. Call 48 hours before you intend to dig to receive locates of underground utilities. www.oopherstateonecali.org I hereby acknowledge that this information is complete and accurate; that the work will be in conformance with the ordinances and codes of the City of Eagan; that I understand this is not a permit, but only an application for a permit, and work is not to start without a permit; that the work will be in accordance with t approved plan in the case of work which requires a review and approval of plans. _ x ~ ~ x 1a lJU 0yV1 Applicant's Printed Name Applicant's Signature FOR OFFICE USE Reviewed By: Date. Required Inspections:, Under Ground - Rough In Air Test ^ Gas Service Test In-floor Heat flnal Exterior HVAC $cra-~'ning Inspection INSPECTION RECORD CITY OF EAGAN PERMIT TYPE: 3830 Pilot Knob Road Permit Number. Eagan, Minnesota 55122-1897 Date Issued: (612) 681-4675 .' SITE ADDRESS: APPLICANT: _,.. s,'': I ??Hi'r l l)t?1 ? i _ i i;.: i; l; I,:;i l I I'. ui `• 1 tiN1 1iR f I!6? 1 r. i.' 1 H `!H 1 1 i 4 . _ . . l?x' ; H?1 ?b ?.. • - . .. 1?. ; i. - f r?. PERMIT SUBTYPE: TYPE OF WORK: III i,, ii t,H', 1 ParmR No. Permit HoIdK Dete TNephone # ELECTRIC PLUMBING HVAC Inspection Dota Insp. Comments FOOTINGS FOUND FRAMING ROOFING ROUGH PLUM8ING PLBG AIR TEST ROUGH HEATING GAS SVC TEST INSUL GYP BOARD FIREPLACE FIHEPLACE AIR TEST -? 1,02 p; 7 FINAL PLBG FINAL HTG ORSAT TEST BLDG FINAL BSMT R.I. BSMT FINAL DECK FTO DECK FINAI CASH RECEIP7 ?. , CITY 4F.EAGAN • _?' ' 3830 PILOT KNOB ROAD ? EAGAN, AAINNESOTA 55122 oATE ' i AMOUNT & DOLLARS ,oo ? CASH 0..CHECK ?., ? r FUND I OBJECT I I ` AMOUNT Thank You - BY white-Payers Copy ?? Yelbw-Postin9 CoPY + ` Pink-File Copy BLDG. PERMIT NO. f ?.'.. . .?/ ?-- 1', i/!t` r j % 01-3210 Bldg: Permit 01-3422 Plan Check Oti-3445 Surch./Adm. ti 01-3446 SAC/Adm. , 01-2155 Surcharge ? 75-3860 Road Unit r?. 20-2275 SAC ?I 20-3865 Water Conn. 20-3868 Water Trmt. 20-3716 Water Meter 20-2252 Acct. Dep. 20-3713 Water Permit 20-3743 Sewer Permit 79-3866 Sewer Conn. 28-3855 Park Deci. A / 0U() /? ov y TOTAL CITY OF EAGAN 3830 Pilot Knob Road, P.O. Bax 21-199, Eagan, MN 55121 PHONE: 4548100 BUILDING PERMIT To be used for ?'i DW?8'f G.AR Est Value $122•000 1.6142 i Receipt # Date , 19 Site Address 648 NOR't'HBRIDGS GT Lot ??' Block 4 Sec/Sub. i3ILLS OF STvnlskll Parcel No. W Name ?ONTGfklERY DESIG`i4 6 BUILD o Address •'+151 :{??OA DR c;ty _?AGA?; Phone 681-9260 z? N?•e • L? 1?.:'9$ 0 ? Address _ City Phone Name _ Address Phone I hereby acknowlege that I have read this application and state that lhe infortnation is conect and agree to comply with all appiicable State of Minnesota Statutes and Ciry of Eagan Ordinances. Signature of Permitee A Building Permit is issued to: & A(1 ] on the express condition that all work shall be done in accordance with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City af Eagan Ordinances. Building Official OFFICE USE ONLY Occupancy FEES Zoning (Ac1ua1) Const Y-N Btdg. Permit 716. 0J (Allowable) v K Sureharge 61.00 # oi Stories Length 68' Plan Review 338• LQ Depth 7' SAC, City 100. L';" S.F. Total - SAC. MCWCC S 7S. liU S.F. Footprints - W 580.' On Site Sewage _ ater Conn .. On Site Well Water Meter ?y0 •:' MWCC System x-x ?Posit '°`? ?,-, • ?? Gry Water Y }: . PRV Required - SNY Permit LQ. , i Booster Pump - g,ryy Surcharge 1 Treatment PI 228,00 APPROVALS qoad Unit 340.00 Planner - park Ded. Coundi - . S? BIdg.Off. _ C°Pie' Variance - TOTAI 3 ,n99' 50 SEWER & WATER PERMIT CITY OF EAGAN 3830 Pilat Knob Rd. P.O. Box 21199 Eagan, MN 55121 OFFICE USE ONLY PERMIT DATE ' WATER PERMIT # I0280 METER # READEFi # METER SIZE ISSUE DATE SEWER PERMIT # B.P. RECEIPT # `"- 235 B.P. RECEIPT DATE 2 21 'A9 - PRV - BOOSTER PUMP SITE ADDRESS LOT 'BLOCK SEC/SUB APPLICANT: • ADQflESS:r CITY, STATE ' ZIP ' PHONE: - « PLUMBER: ADDRESS: CITY, STATE ZIP 55352 PHONE: OWNER: ADDRESS: CITY, STATE ZIP PHONE: PERMIT REQUESTED SEWER _ WATER - TAPS - COMM/IND v NEW A:L? RESIDENTIAL - EXISTING I AGREE TD COMPLY WITH CITY QF EAGAN ORDINANCES: SIGNATURE WHEN METER ISSUED PLEASE ALLOW TWO WORKING DAYS FOR PROCESSING. FOR STORM SEWER PER1111TS, CONTACT ENGINEERING DEPT. SEVYER & WATER PERMIT CIT'1' OF EAeGAN 3830 Pilot Knob Rd. P.O. Box 21199 Eagan, MN 55121 OFFICE USE ONLY I PERMIT DATE :>I r ' WATER PERMIT # = - - SEWER PERMIT ? METER # 419 97 B.P. RECEIPT+it ?Q?R ?74 5?/ 9? B.P. RECEIPT OATE 2 t-•`' ETER SIZE ?g ROGK ISSUE DATE ?-gr °,L - PRV - BOOSTER PUMP SITE ADDRESS ' _ - LOT • BLOCK SEC/SUB - APPLICANT: - ^ ` -? ? '• F t? ! j F ADDaESS: - - - ? r ? • • ' CITY, STATE - ZIP PHONE: - ? ? PLUMBER: + ADDRESS: CITY, STATE ZIP PHONE: OWNER: PERMIT REQUESTED `1 SEWER _ WATER _ TAPS - COMM/IND _ RESIDENTIAL ` NEW - EXISTING I AGREE TO COMPLY WITH CITY OF EAGAN OADINANCES: ADDRESS: - SIGNATURE EN METER ISSUED CITY, STATE ZIP ?-- PHONE: PLEASE ALLOW TWO WORKING DAYS FOR PROCESSING. FOR STORM SEWER PERMITS, CONTACT ENGINEERING DEPT. ?„? . . ? ? . .. __. ... --?.R W . . . ?? ? . '• . ?r. -Tex#i#trate nf (Orrupttnry . Citp of (Cagart aPpar#titPttf Df llI"t1t J JriSpPI'Yloli This Certificate issued pursuant to the requiremenu of Section 306 of the Uniform Buildixg Code cerrifying that at the trme of jsstyQ+rqe tp structure was in complrance witlt t)te various ordinances of the City regulating buildtng construction or use. For t/ie following.• u. cw?c?.ti? SEM/CAR Bas. ?t.m;, rro. 16142 ooc„p-cy rya ? 1M I 7*" DWict PD Tya Co- VN P,,?r of 8,,;ld;,g MMlOCiIM DESIGN &m.D. Add,, 4151 IQdc3B DRNE, EACaAN B„»;ng Addm 698 NORTURIIM OMM. LDC,,;ty L 12, 84, HIILS 0F SPOIEMID(E n,,: APRTL 28, 1989 sudding oeki.i POST IN A CONSPICUOUS PLACE' .. / _ ti . CITY OF EAGAN _•? :?, , , ?, E??. ?? .?' 3830 Pilot Knob Road, P.O. Box 21-199, Eagan, MN 55121 ' • PHONE:454-8100 BUILDING PERM(T Receipt # To be used for ` Est. Value ?12c r?` `? Date , 19 Site Address Lot Block SeclSub. Par2el No. W Name .;° lu:. +5 o Address . _ ? City Phone Name Address City Phone I hereby acknowlege that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State o1 Minnesota Statutes and City ot Eagan Ordinances. Signature of Permitee A Building Permit is issued to: •' 1 ' on Ihe express condition that all work shall be done in accordance with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Building Official OFFIC E USE ONLY occupancy F.-3 1 FEes 2oning ??+? (Actual) Const Y!!? Bidg. Permit ? 1 ?• t'` (Allowable) y=N Surcharge r• 1 • ?„ ^ # of Stories Length fia' Pian Review Depth 37' SAC, Ciry S.F. Total - SAC. MCWCC S.F. Footprints - t C On Site Sewage _ er onn ?Na On Site Well Water Meter MWCC System XX Ciry Water ? AccL Deposit PRY Required _ S'W Permit Boaster Pump - S11N Surcharge Treatment PI APPROVALS Road Unit Planner il C - park Ded. ounc BIdg.Off. - _ Copies Variance - TOTAL Permit No. Permit Holder Date Telephone # • WA7ER ?' y' ? ?. ? "/;• ? ??? ? ?)1i / C, . _y, ?I? SFV9ER PLUMBING `3 ? Xy l? H.V.A.C. ELECTRIC Inapection Date Insp. Comments Footings I 17 l?q l4 Foundafion ` 2, Framing p U Lo f? Roofing Rough Plbg. Rough Htg. Isul. Fireplace 3 2? 8 j? () S Final Htg. Final Plbg. Const. Meter Plbg. Inspector - Notify Plumber EngiJPlan Bldg. Final oor Deck Ftg. Deck Final weu Pr. Disp. RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION 1,6 41 f 5?J CITY OF EAGAN 5830 PILOT KNOB RD - 55122 851-681-4675 NewConshuction Reauirements • 3 registered site surveys showing sq. R of bt, sq. fl of house; ancg moled areas (20% macimum bt coverage albved) . 2 oopies of plan 5howing beam R w'uMw sues; poured pwM design, ft) • 7 set o} Eneigy Calala6ons • 3 oopies of Tree Preservation PWn H bt platled after 7/1193 • Rim Joist Defail Options selectlon shaet (bldgs wilh 3 or 185s uniLS) DATE ?IlE JOB SITE ADDRE IF MULTI-FAMILY PROPERTY OWN1TYPE OF WORK 1 APPLICANT FIREPLACE(S) _ 0 _ 1 _ 2 _ PHONE# _TD3I ADDRESS 9920 Zilla Street ZIP CODE PAGER # CELL PHONE # FAX #"AQ?" ?? L NEW RE5IDENTIAL BUILDING ONLY- FILL OUT COMPLETELY Energy Code Cate9ory _ MINNESOTA RULFS 7670 CA'I'EGORY 1 (check one) - Residential Ventilation Category 1 Woricsheet Submitted - Energy Envelope Calculations Submitted _ MINNESOTA RULES 7672 - New Energy Code Worksheet Submitted Plumbing Contractor: Phone #: Plumbing System Includes: _ Water Softener _ Lawn Sprinkler _ Water Heater _ No. of R.I. Baths No. of Baths Meehanical Contractor: _ Mechanical System Includes: Sewer/Water Confractor. Phone # Phone # Fee: $90.00 Fee: $70.00 All above information must be submitted prior to processing of application. I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application, state that e information is correct, and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan inances. Slgnalure o} Applieanf n , Certificates of Survey Received _ Tree Preservation Plan Received _ Not Required _ . . . . ` Updated 1/01 _ Air Conditioning _ Heat Recovery System 377q $ 2.60.75 RamodaUReoairReauhements . 2 copies o1 plan • i set W Eneigy Cakulations tor heated additions . 1 Sb survey tot eztltt edditi0n5 6 decks • Indkate N home seived by sep6c system for additions OFFICE USE ONLY -?? - < - •°, ? 01 'Foundation'' 0 02 SF Dwelling ? 03 01 of _ plex O 04 02-plex O DS 03-plex ? 06 04-plex ? 31 New ? 32 Addition 0 33 Alteration ? 34 Replacement ? 20 Pool ? 21 Poroh (3-sea.) ? 22 PorchlAddn. (4-sea.) ? 23 Porch (screened) ? 24 Storm Damage ? 25 Misceilaneous ? 30 Accessory Bldg ? 31 EM. Alt - Multi ? 33 Ext. Alt - SF ? 36 Multi ? 35 Int Improvement O 38 Demolish (Interior) O 44 Siding ? 36 . Move Bldg. O 42 Demolish (Foundation) ? 45 Fire Repair ? 37 Demolish (Bldg)• O 43 Reroaf O 48 WindowsJDoors 'Demolltion (Entire Bldg onl» • Give PCA handout to applicant ? Valuation Occupancy MC/ES System _ Census Code Zoning City Water _ SAC Units Stories Booster Pump _ Nbr. of Units Sq. Ft. PRV _ Nbr. of Bldgs Length Fire Sprinklered _ Type of Const W idth REQUIRED INSPECTIONS _ Footings (new bldg) _ FinaUC.O. _ Footings (deck) _ FinallNo C.O. _ Footings(addiHon) _ plumbing _ Foundation HVAC Drain Tile Roof Ice & Water Final Other _ Fraznnng _ Poo] _ Ftgs _ Air/Gas Tests _ Final _ Fireplace _ R.I. _ Air Test _ Final _ Siding Stucco Stone _ Insulation _ Windows (new/replacement) Approved By Base Fee Surcharge Plan Review MC/ES SAC City SAC 1Nater Supply & Storage S&W Permit 8 Surcharge Treatrnent Plant Plumbing Permit Mechanical Permit License Search Copies Other Total ? 07 05-plex ? 13 16-plex ? 08 06-plex ? 76 Fireplace ? 09 07-plex ? 17 Garage O 10 08-plex 0 18 Deck ? 11 70-plex ? 19 LowerLevel ? 12 12-plex Plbg_Y or_ N Building Inspector ? DATE: 2/23189 o?.698 Id0&THBRFDGS t:1'., L129 B4• HII:LS OF XX V Your Sewer & Water PermiT for the above property has been completed. It will be held at the Public Works Garage (3501 Coachman Road) until the meter is picked up. BE SURE TO CALL PUBLIC WORKS (454-5220) FOR YOUR PERMANENT WATER TURN ON. - Your Sewer & Water Permit for the above property cannot be completed for the following reasons: ^1,4 Your Sewer & Water Permit for the above property has been completed, but tbe meter cannot r 4e issued or occupancy allowed until turther notice. r. - COMMERCIAL PROJECTS ONLY: Please pay for meter at City Hall. Meter size must be confirmed by Bill Adams or Dirk House (Plumbing Inspectors - 4548100) before issuance. WARNING:'BEFORE DIGGING, CALL LOCAL UTILRIES - TELEPHONE, ELECTRIC, GAS, ETC. - REQUIRED BY LAW. . CONTACT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT FOR WATER TURN ON POLICY. Secretary, Building Inspections Dept. - DATE: 2/23189 RE: 698 EIOBTRBRIDGII v^1'.. L12e B4, HILL3 OF STOA7BBRIDGE ? XXY' Your Sewer & Water Permit for the above property has been completed. It will be held at tFie Public Works Garage (3501 Coachman Road) until the meter is picked up. BE SURE TO "CALL PUBLIC WORKS (4545220) FOR YOUR PERMANENT WATER TURN ON. l?our Sewer & Water Permit for the above property cannot be completed for the following N? ?, rlasons: ? ? a -Your Sewer & Water Perrnit for the above property has been completed, but the meter cannot be issued or occupancy allowed until further notice. - COMMERCIAL PROJECTS ONLY: Please pay for meter at City Hall. Meter size must be confirmed by Bill Adams or Dirk House (Plumbing Inspectors - 454-8100) before issuance. WARNING: BEFORE DIGGING, CALL LOCAL UTILITIES - TELEPHONE, ELECTRIC, GA5, ETC. - REQUIfiED BY LAW. CONTACT COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT FOR WATER TURN ON POLICY. . ,! Secretary, Building Inspections Dept. ° BUILDING PERMIT To be used for SF DWG/GAR Est.Value $122,000 Receipt # Na 16142 - 6X4 . 1s s9 Site Address 698 NORTHBRIDGE CT Lot lZ Block 4 SeGSub. HILLS OF Parcel No. ' SUONEBRID w Name MONTGOMERY DESIGN & BIIILD o Address 4151 ILNOB DR Ciry EAGAN Phone 681-9260 o Name SAME Address City Phone ww Name ? ; Address aw City Phone I hereby acknowiege that I have read this application and state that the intormation is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State ol Minnesota Stalutes @?ny?/?ity ol Ea e5? O?dinanc s. Signature of Permi?ek ? /nfA-1 ? OFFICE USE ONLY Occupancy R-3 I _1 FEES Zoning PD (ACtuai) Const V-N Bldg. Pertnit 716.00 (Allowa6le) V=N Surcharge 61.00 # af Srories - Length 68' PlanReview 58.00 Depih 371 SAQ Gity 100.00 S.F.TOtal - SAC,MCWCC 575.00 S.F. Footprinis - On Sire Sewage Water Conn 580.00 On Site Weii water nneter 90.00 MWCC System xx. Awt. Deposit 30.00 Ciiy Water ][$ PRVRequi2d - SIWPermit 20.00 Booster Pump - Syy Surcharge i_ nn % Treatmenl PI 228.00 APPROVALS Road Unit 340.00 A Building Permit is issued o: MONTGO Y D N& BUI D Planner - Park Detl. on ihe express condition that all work shall be done in aCCOrdance with all Council - .50 applicable Sta[e of M,\innesota Statutes and City ot Eagan Ordinances. Bldg. Off. _ Building OBicial Copias `IJ.?IAa Variance - TOTAL 3.099.50 CITY OF EAGAN 3830 Pilot Knob Road, P.O. Box 21-199, Eagan, MN 55121 PHONE: 454-8100 ? ?° ii 4 RESDENTIAL BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION 2 200 City Of Eagan ';7S,2P 3830 Pilot Knob Road, Eagaa MN 55122 ? ? Tetephone # 651-675-5675 FAX # 651-675-5694 New"CZnst ctionReauiremenis Remodel/ReoairReouirements 3 registered sile surveys shaving sq. ft of IoL sq. ft of house; and all roofed areas 2 copies of plan (20% maximum lotcoverage allowed) 1 set of Energy Calculations for heated add'N'ons 2 copies oi plan showing 6eam & window sizes; poured found desigq etc. 1 sile survey for addifions & decks i set of Energy Calwlations Add'dion - indirafe if on-sife sapfic system 3 copies of Tree Preservation Plan if lot platled after 711193 Rim Joist Detall Options selection sheet (bldgs wifh 3 or less units ?`-j0 c?c7 D?iceiis'e tir5v CeROiSirveyRecd N Trce P2s Ptan Recd : -Y -N TrilePresftegiiiYed { 7"Y IJ Da?teSeR6c:$Pstg.m Date '?' / F- l e `l Constructioo Cost zmU _ Site Address 7 r / U De Li?u v-V - UniUSte # Descriptiou of Work 24 / UUI ( Y eX141mg 4e)-&kIt- Multi-Faniily Bldg _ YX N Fireptace(s) _ 0 _ 1 _ 2 Property Owner Oi^il GI 0,?^6 JS k (> _ Telephone #(45$'/ ) ?/S'16 Contractor G, 4 Moeu,V1- E x4-i' 1O!^? ' EU Ci ??2 /Z Address 2729 9 ? FQlU' I/!P ty l pS U ) State ?l /n Zip Telephone # (W) &9 56 j?D COMPLETE THIS AREA ONLY IF - Minnesota Rules 7670 Cateeorv 1 - Energy Code Category . Residential Ventilation Category 1 Worksheet (J su6mission type) Submitted • Energy Envelope Calculatlons Submitted Have you previously constructed a building in Eagan with a similar plan? _ Y fee applies. Licensed Plumber Mechanical Contractor Sewer/Water Contractor Telephone # ( ? ?IERtl ? S Efler!12°2N4 I N If so, 25% plan review I hereby apply for a Residential Building Pernvt and acknowl ' is complete and accurate; that the work will be in conformance with the ordinances and codes of the City of Eagan and the State of MN Statutes; I understand this is not a permit, but only an application for a permit, and work is not to start without a permit; that the work will be in accordance with the approved plan in the case of work which requires a review and approval of plans. / ?1°i!/e epl r l?; 0 lil Applicant's Printed Name 412&? 4A,,r-? ApplicanYs Signature A NEW BUILDING Minnesota Rules 7672 . New Energy Code Worksheet Submitted OFFICE USE ONLY Sub Types ? 01 Foundation ? 07 05-plex ? 13 16-plex ? 20 Pool ? 30 Accessory Bldg ? 02 SF Dweiling ? 08 06-plex ? 16 Fireplace ? 21 Porch (3-sea.) ? 31 Ext. Alt - Multi ? 03 01 of_ plex ? 09 07-plex ? 17 Garage ? 22 Porch/Addn. (4-sea.) ? 33 Ext. Alt- SF ? 04 02-plex ? 10 08-plex ? 18 Deck ? 23 Porch (screen/gazebo) ? 36 Multi Misc. ? 05 03-plex ? 11 10-plex ? 19 Lower Level ? 24 Storm Damage ? 06 04-plex ? 12 12-plex Pibg_Y or _ N ? 25 Miscellaneous Work Types ? 31 New ? 35 Int Improvement ? 38 Demolish Interior ? 44 Siding ? 32 Addition ? 36 Move Building ? 42 Demolish Foundation ? 45 Fire Repair ? 33 Alteration ? 37 Demolish Building• ? 43 Reroof ? 46 WindowslDoors ? 34 ReplaCement 'Demolition (Entire Bldg) - Give PCA handout to applicant Valuation Occupancy MCES System Census Code Zoning City Water SAC Units Stories Booster Pump # of Units Sq. Ft. PRV # of Bldgs Length Fire Sprinklered Type of Const Width REQUIRED INSPECTIONS _ Footings (new bldg) _ FinaUC.O. _ Footings (deck) FinallNo C.O. _ Footings (addition) _ Plumbing Foundation HVAC Drain Tile Other Roof _ Ice & Water _ Final _ Pool _ Ftgs _ Air/Gas Tests Final _ Framing Siding _ Smcco _ Stone _ Brick _ Fireplace _ R.I. _ Air Test _ _ Final _ Windows _ Insulation _ Retaining Wall Approved By: Base Fee Surcharge Plan Review MClES SAC City SAC Utility Connection Charge S&W Permit & Surcharge Treatment Plant License Search Copies Other Total Building Inspector ? INSPECTION RECORD CITY OF EAGAN PERMIT TYPE: g u z Lo s NG 3830 Pilot Knob Road Permit Number: 0 2 6 6 2 3 Eagan, Minnesota 55122-1897 Date Issued: 10 / 2 5/ 9 5 (612) 681-4675 SITE ADDRESS: Lo r: 12 a Lo c K: n APPLICANT: 698 NORTHt3RIDGE CT S'iOVE & FTREPLACE GflLLERY HILLS OF STONE6RIDGF (612) 898-1174 ,. . r. ,. ° ., ..- .. ,?.. _ ..- I ? ....._.. _.__..._.. . ._ ? ..__..._ ...?_. __. ..:. . ....._.. __.:._._ ... . .___._._ "_._.._ ..."__ PERMIT SUBTYPE: TYPE OF WORK: FIREPIACE NEW DESCRIPTION (GAS) CITY OF EAGAN 3830 Pilot Knob Road Eagan, Minnesota 55122-1897 (612) 681-4675 PERMIT PERMIT TYPE: Permit Number: Date Issued: m40 ff 13UIl.UING 025623 10/<?5/95 SITE ADDRESS: P.I.N.: 10-32990-120-04 DESCRIPTION: 698 D7iJkT"FiBftIDGE CT LOl': 1.2 F3LOCKe 4 H7LLS OF STONEBkIDGE (sRS) PermLt Type FIREPLFICE k,q;rk Type NEW ?? Amw ?" ? ? , ? "".?r? ?!ffi m i:' _ ' !"?4, ?i ^a' ? n REMARKS: FEE SUMMARY: Base Fee $25,00 5urr.harge 'T"utal Fee $75.50 CONTRACTOR: - ApPiicant -- sr. Lrc. OWNER: STOVG & FSREPLACE CiAL.LEh'Y 18981174 20032084 GRFY GRAIG 1.278 COUNTY RQpD 42 G98 tJORTHBFtIDGE CT 6URIV5VxLl.E MN 55337 EAGAN hiN 55122 (612) 898-17.74 (612)681-9871 APPLICANTIPERMITEE SIGNATIJRE AM4 , O,t' ?, 'SSUED`C. SI ATUR - ? ? CITY OF EAGAN 3830 PILOT KNOB RD - 55122 1995 FIREPLACE PERMIT APPLICATION 681-4675 DATE: .-?Y? - ?? ? l S DESCRIPTION OF WORK: VINSTALL NE1}( FIREPLACE: _ WOOD BURNING GAS- _ INSTALL GAS LOG ONLY IN EXISTING FIREPLACE _ INSTALL GAS LINE ONLY IN EXISTING FIREPLACE OTHER: AREA TO BE INSTALLEC STREE"f ADDRESS: LOT BLOCK ? SUBD./P.I.D. #: APPLICANT: (circle one only) OWNER CONTf2ACTOR I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. PROPERTY Name: rCA-t?cv. C9 r-r-+a Phone #: OWNER AS* ""°T Signature : Street Address 6??g !Ue J?? 'CIIX City: Uk? State: ,V A. Zip: F6RcFi.FCE ?U.nGI_ Cnc? E't5c??e 1: INSTALLER ? 9 Si nature / a : ?•? - Street Address: 197'$ 61?4 L12 License #: -2-00 3.:?o ad City: GAS LINE Company : c?o'?,-v ?,-c 4- S?5 ?1hone #: ?' 7-`tI INSTALLER ( J Name: 5ignature : Street Address• City: 5tate: Zip: OFFICE USE ONLY BUILDING PERMIT TYPE ? 14 Fireplace WORK TYPE ? 31 New ? 32 Addition ? 33 Alteretions 0 34 Repair GENERAL INFORMATION Census Code. SAC Code REMARKS: Chimneylflue must be inspected before concealing. FEES Permit Fee Surcharge Other Copies Total: ? gw- 94? ? F _,.w...:; 1989 BDILDING P&RMTT APPLICATZON - CITY OF EAGAq' .. SINGLE FAMILY DWELLIN6S INCLUDE 2 SETS OF PLANS? 3 CERTIFICATES OF SURVEYt 1 SET OF ENERGY CALCULATIONS NOTE: ADDRESSFS FOB CORNER LOTS - CONTRACTOR/HOMEOWN&R MtTST DESIGN9TE FiHICH ADDRE83 IS DESIRED. RO CEANGES iiILL BE ALLOWED ONCE HIIILDING PERMIT IS I330ED. M[JI.TIPLE DWELLINGS ESNTAL ONITS FOB SALIi UNITS f OF 08IT3 INCLUDE 2 SETS OF PLANS, CERTIFICATE OF SUR9EY - C$ECg WITH BLDG. DEPT.r 1 SET OF ENERGY CALCULATIONS CONMERCIAL INCLUDE 2 SETS OF ARCHITECTURAL & STRUCTURAL PLANS, t SET OF SPECIFICASIONS AND 1 SET OF ENERGY CALCULATIONS To Be Used For: ? ?e h8 16 1989 valuation: z-Z 00 `=.) Date: 2. -/ C-a"g Site Address ?¢ ? Lot --tZ- Bloek ? Parcel/Sub Owner Address 746D City/Zip Code OFFICE OSE ONLY Oceupancy Zoning Actual Const YN Allowable V41 S of stories Length ?v?- Depth S.F. Total Footprint S.F. 74 T., c- Bldg. Permit 21 ? Surcharge 6,1 Plan Review 3 S 10 SAC, City (60 SAC, MWCC S) S Water Conn SI? n Water Meter 10 Aeet. Deposit 30 S/W Permit Zp S/W Sureharge /. Treatment P1. zz Road Unit 3 YO Park Ded. Copies SJ TOT9L MK5::9a S o Phone On site sewage site well Contractor ` d"C System ? City water ? Address Z// 5/ PRV required _ Q Booster Pump _ City/Zip Code [r.?2..,- APPROVALS Phone (. Q' I - 121, C) Plannex' Arch./Engr. Address City/Zip Code Phone 8 Council Bldg. Off. 7 ? °S ? Varianee Council NOTE: Sexer & Water Permit fees and aceount depoait fees will be ineluded in the building permit fee. Processing time for serrer and rrater permits is txo days once a licenaed plumber has applied for a permit at City Fiall. ?- z?- 3y = ?sz ??- ?oao r{- iv - 1s -4 lo?O'` S° " 2N? ?-- ?ykzP Gcr _r z'/,Y 2 y k 1 j ? ,? R?• ??, ??G Ya ?2??SZn ?., . ---------------------------------------------------------- FEB-1?-'?"-9 IqpN 11:20 tD:JGP1ES F,' HILL INC TEL N0:612 884-9518 #251 P02 SURVEYOR'S CERTIF'ICATE / , l/ / / ! ' a \ •C0 ? n O / _ iM \ ? V VO d, ? ? ? '' ?'q? • 3?+. 2 Q# / o M o ? }yii??"?! ? \'? 4 M f? ?O ?° ' ? ? ?c o. / k? ? ! , T ? t e v ? .-- --? r r ? ?40•Q0 \ ?-- ? o - O ? ' 1 J ao ? 10 _- -' - y00 .,' 53? 2 ?? E r r-? n N ?_(vS ?? ?V ? A T r , t y p I ` °. . .. . ? _ .T ; ?l G c?S l..- ? ? . "__..L___1in..n L EliVlALV 3....j • DENOTES PROPOSED SURFACE DRAINAGE I O DENOTES IRON MONUMENT SkT SCALE: 1 INCH - 30 FEEf 0 DENOTES IRON MONUMEMT FqUND PROPOSED QARAOE FLOOR - qt1.3 FEET xDOD.O DENOTES EXISTIN(3 ELEVATION PROPOSED LON/EST FLOOR - Q)3,(o FEET (000.0) DENOTES PROPOSED ELEVATION PROPOSED TpP OF BLOCK- 9Z1.7 FEEf WE HEREBY CERTIFY TO MOkTOOMERY DE81dN THAT THtS IS A TRUE AND CORRECT REPRESENTATION OF A SURVEY OF THE BOUtJDARIES OF: LOT 12, BLOCK 4, HILLS OF STONEBRIDGE, ACCORDtNG TO THE RECORpEl7 PLAT THEREOF, DAKOTA COUNI"Y, MINNESOTA. IT DOES NOT PURPORT TO SHOW IMPROVEMENTS OR ENCROACHMEN7S, EXCEPT AS SHOWN: AS SURVEYED BY ME OR UNDER MY DIRECT SUPERVISION THIS DAY OF FEBRUARY ,1989 PROPOSED ELEVATIONS SHOWFl IIERE TAKEN FROP1 THE DEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR hlILLS OF STONEBRIDGE, PRE- PARED BY PIONEER ENGINEERING AND LRST bATED 8-26-87. SIGNEb: JAA?ES`?14. L, INC. n BY: ` C?wLtic.-.? U? HAROLD G. PEfERSON, LAND SURVEYOR MINNESOTA LICENSE NUMBER 12294 cn _ m ? O '- r 0 ? ` ? o ? - p m - A n ? S rn O O y D R7 ? O O V m ;u O m -?G James R. Hill, inc. PLANNERS / ENGINEERS / SURVEYORS 9401 JAMES AVE. S. • 9LOOMINGTON, MN. 55431 • 612•884•3029 •. 1`'r,T1-FiIQR EPIVEt_OF'F AVLF;AGE "U" CQI'1F'UTATTIJIU ML7NTrpME_RY DFSIGN "< L'USLD CO =1151 f:h.if]L-; nR I_A(:iAN„ MN 55122 601.--9^30 MQDF'I._ CAF'TIVA 1 AREA U U X AF(Cfa REG!IJIF;EU 1. TGTF`?L_ P1AI_L. F;!=iEA 2404 .11 204 ... ROnI- AREA 1696 .026 44 ?,C:I-lIEVED Fl WINDnI,J AREA 245 .55 135 Ig nnar AREA 40 . 13 5 C; SI_.]:riTfdG GLA!,S AI;Efl =.:, .65 23 D rir-;EPLAcr (-1RF'A 36 .2 l E= WAL.L.. 1=F'AME Af•'tE"A 24O. R .095 23 f-' NET lniAl__L.. AREA 1207.6 v038 69 G RII°I jQ:f.ST AREA 140 .04_+6 6 f{ rniJNU WSNnOUT AREA C> .,- U I 1=0UhJD A}.tOV'f" GF'AnF_. 84 .068 b 3. T'OTF•1L Wf-1L.1_. AI':F_.F3 27' i St::YL..SI"E .5 C> f': FiOC7r FR(-1ME 169.6 .032 5 L h,IL.T ROOf= AREA 1526.4 .0227 35 4. 70TAL_ ROOF AREA 40 '3UM QF- 1 . +2 . 309 E;UM QF 3.+4. 313 *************************************** CITY OF EAGAN CASHIER: JS TERMINAL NO: 698 DATE: 05/08/00 TIME: 14:33:21 ID: NAME: SRADLEY D BRODSHO 3210 9001 698 NORTH BRIDG 60.00 2155 9001 698 NORTH BRIDG 0.50 Total Receipt Amount: 60.50 CR129442 USER ID: JAN I, .. t? n c? ?3 N 2000 BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION (RESIDENTIAL) arv oF E?caN ? 3830 PILOT KNOB RD - 55122 651-681-4675 > 3 reglatered sHe wrveys showMy aq. B, ol bf, aq. R. of houae and gU roofeG areaa (40% mo)lmum lot covaraae atlowecD > 2 coplea o1 plana (show beam & wlntlow aizes; pOUred Ind. deslgn; elc.) > t fet of enefgy caICUICNOn4 > 3 Coples of free preaervatlon plan II bf platfed aRer 7/1 /93 Name: ERb6Sto F'RPrh'C_EX PhoneJf:toSi -t4S(o-S7,IS lasf Flrst ?- DATE: Z/' "-OvV CONSTRUCTION COST: DESCRIPTION OF WORK: ? CGK /q-,Q4 /T/6 N STREETADDRESS: 69g NOQTti19121JJGE ?CJLf2! LOT: /.2 BLOCK: -/7/ SUBD./P.I.D. #: Niccs o F 5-Ta24E62166C PROPERTY OWNER CONTRACTOR ARCHITECT/ ENGINEER SheetAddress: (99?J NOR-T}}1v211???E ?u2T a+y F.46A-lJ sbte: t/1'1 /J vp: 5s17-3 Company. Phone A: (area code) Sheet Address: Ucense # Exp. Cliy u.?D C-OAS? RemodeUReoair Reauiremenfs 2 coples of plan 1 seT of enetgy calculoNOns tor heated addiMOru 1 fife wrvey for exleAor additlona 6 dBCka State: Company: Name: Telephone #: ( ) Sfreet City State: 6ewerlwater licensed plumber {if installirw sewerlwaterl: Phone #: I hereby acknowledge thaf i have read this applkatbn, sfafe lhaf 1he ,of Minnesota Stafufes and Cily of Eagan Ordinances. Signalure of Certificates of Survey Received ?/ Yes Tree Preservation Plan Received _ Yes OFFICE USE ONLY _ No _ No V Not Required RegisfraNOn #: ZiP: Z1p: wNh all appQCabte Statc 4,?? ^ 5 , , _ ... ..,.: . , OFFICE USE ONLY BUILDING PERMIT SUBTYPES ? 01 Foundation ? 07 05-plex 0 13 16-plex ? 21 Porch (3-sea.) ? 31 Ext. Alt - Mutti ? 02 SF Dwelling ? 08 06-piex ? 17 Garage ? 22 Poroh/Addn. (4-sea.) ? 33 Ext..Aft - SF ? 03 01 of _ plex ? 09 07-plex >- 18 Deck ? 23 Porch (screened) " ? 36 Muki ? 04 02-plex ? 10 OS-plex ? 19 Lower Level O 24 Storm Damage ? 05 03-plex ? 17 10-plex Plbg _Vor_N ? 25 Miscellaneous ? 06 04-plex ? 12 12-plex ? 20 Pool 0 30 Accessory BWg. woRK nrPE $?-31 New ? 36 Move Bldg. O 43 Reroof ? 32 Addition ? 37 Demolish (Bidg)' ? 44 3iding ? 33 Alteration ? 38 Demolish (Interior) ? 45 Fire Repair ? 34 Repair ? 42 Demolish (Foundation) ? 46 Windows/Doors • Give PCA handout to applicant for demolition permit GENERAL INFORMATION SAC Code 6 # of Stories sq. ft. No. of Units r2 Length S9• ft' No. of Buildings _ 1 Width Footprint sq. ft. Const. (Actual) Basement sq. ft. Census Code y3 y (Allowable) Main Ievel sq. ft. MC/ES System UBC Occupancy sq. ft. City Water Zoning sq. ft. Booster Pump ' PRV Fire Sprinklered MISCELLANEOUS INSPECTIONS O Stucco/Stone APPROVALS Planning Building Engineering Variance Permit Fee ?06 fi.SO Valuation: $ 1,200 Suroharge Plan Review License ! MC/ES SAC City SAC Water Conn. Water Meter Acct. Deposit ' S/W Permit S/W Surcharge Treatment PI. Park Ded. Trails Ded. Other Copies Totai: ?60.so i SAC Units % SAC BURNET TiTLE FS1e t+a. 11461 Froperty Address_ 688 NORTHBRIDGE COURT. EAGAN Buyer: BRODSHO Lepal: LOT 12, BLOCK 4, HILLS OF STONEBRIDGE PLAT DRAWING Insp. Date: 4128198 insp. By: PCT This Plat Drawinp ia not inten0ad to be used as a survey and shoulG not De relieC upon as auch. The lot dlmenslons ere teken from the reeofded plat or the county records and are aesumed to ba accurate. The location ot the Improrementa ehown on thia Arawinp are approximata anA are beaed upon a visual lnspection of fhe premises. A Ilcenaed survayor 6hould ba contacted ii an accurate survay Is deatred. Tfils plat drawlnp does not constltuts a liabllity of ihe campeny and is intended for use by lhe company only. ? IXNn.9. aiM UtL'ky Ea. . mant+ f?R V ? i ? r C'Q j ? O ArU O 2 ? i r=so• ? & ?h) 698 NORTHBRIDGE COORT 7-??37 L12, B4, HILLS OF STONEBRIDGE 'F3 j _ 9 Gj -7 -? 5/15/90 Meeting with Monahans to discuss concerns with home. 5/18/90 Monahans given a typed copy of ineeting report. 5/28/90 City received report back from Monahans, requesting changes. 6/1/90 Report revised and mailed back to Monahans. 6/6/90 Monahans returned signed copy of report and requested copies of information in the parcel file. 6/7/90 Copy of signed report given to Tom & MaryAnne Montqomery. 6/18/90 Montgomery Design cancelled 9:30 meeting 6/19/90 Montgomery Design set up meeting for 6/20/90 at 10:00 a.m. at City office 6/20/90 Montgomery Design came to office 6/20/90 at 10:25 a.m. until 12:00 p.m. 6/21/90 Left message for Pat Monahan I would call him on Monday, June 25. 6/25/90 Delivered draft of ineeting with Monahans to Montgomery's office 6/28/90 MaryAnne said they reviewed document once, but wanted to review it a second time and then would return to our office. 7/9/90 Left message with MaryAnne. Julie Monahan called and wanted to know if we had heard from the Montgomexys. 7/10/90 Called MaryAnne's office and was informed she would return my call. 7/11/90 Pat Monahan called for an update. 7/17/90 Bill Bruestle delivered letter to Montgomerys and Monahans. 7/25/90 Steve Hanson and Bill Bruestle made an inspection of the home at 9:15 p.m. with Monahans and Montgomerys. , MEMORANDUM TO: _?DOUG REID, CHIEF BUILDING OFFICIAL FROM: '/? ST'EVE HANSON, ASST. BUIL,DING OFFICIAL DATE: JL7LY 26, 1990 RE: MEETING OF NLY 25, 1990 698 NORTHBRIDGE COURT L- I:12, B4, HILLS OF STONEBRIDGE Pat Monahan, Steve Hanson, Bill Bruestle, and Tom & Marianne Montgomery met to view the condition of gypsum board on the ceiling where previous water damage had occurred at the above address. During the week prior to this meeting, attempts were made to arrange a meeting between the Monahans, Montgomerys, and representatives from the City of Eagan. to view this problem. As of Monday, July 23, 1990, I was informed that the Monahans and Montgomerys could not agree on a time so I scheduled the meeting with Pat Monahan, Bill Bruestle, and myself for 9:15 P.M. on July 25, 1990. At approximately 4:00 P.M. on July 25, 1990, Marianne Moritgomery called Bill Bruestle and informed him they would meet with us that evening. _ At approximately 9:15 P.M., Bill Bruestle and I arrived at the Monahans home at 698 Northbridge Court. The ceiling in question was visible from the foyer, and it was evident from that vantage point that the ceiling was indeed damaged. The lights in the rooms with the damaged ceilings were off, and the lights in the hallway leading to those rooms were on, casting several large shadows across the damaged ceiling that showed the imperfections in the ceiling. By using a flashlight, we shined light across the kitchen, dinette, and family room ceilings and noted similar damage throughout these areas. The damage was spread over an area of approximately 500-600 square feet. After viewing the damage for about five minutes, Marianne and Tom Montgomery arrived. They viewed the damage, but made no comment about it. At this point, Bill and I had made no comment to Pat Monahan about our opinion of the ceiling. , Other problems that were viewed and discussed included: 1. The cracking of the grout in the ceramic tile floor in the dinette , 2. The area of the basement where water still comes in during rainstorms 3. The crimped water service line 4. Settled areas in the driveway 5. Potential grading problems around the house There was no discussion of possible so]utions to any of the problems. Marianne asked Pat for a cunent list of problems. As we left, Pat indicated he would be on vacation for a week. I asked if he would call, me when he returned to inform me as to whether or not Montgomerys had agreed on a course of action. At this point, Pat asked Bill and I if the quality of the ceiling was typical. Bill and I both stated that it was not a good job. However from a Code standpoint, we do not have any authority to require Montgomerys to repair the ceiling. _ SH/js CC: Dale C. Runkle, Community Development Director Bil] Bruestle, I.ead Construction Inspector oF 3830 PILOT KNOB ROAD THOn+ns Ec w EAGAN, MINNESOTA 55122-1897 MayOf PHONE: (612) 454-8100 DAVID K. GUSTAFSON FAX: (612) 454-8363 PAMELA MCCRE/+ TIM GAWLENTY THEODORE WACHTER Council Members TiOM45 HEDGES July 16, 1990 City Administrator EUGENE VAN OVERBEKE Ciry Clerk MONTGOMERY DESIGN & BUILD 3786 WINDTREE DRIVE EAGAN, MN 55123 Re: 698 North Bridae Court; Lot 12. Block 4. Hills of Stonebridee The City of Eagan has met with Mr. and Mrs. Monahan and yourselves to review the concerns the Monahans have with their new home. The items that are of the most concern to the City of Eagan are as follows: 1. The dirt is less than 6 inches from the wood floor joists. Section 2516(c)7. Wood and Earth Separation "...wood used in construction of permanent structures and located nearer than six inches to earth shall be treated wood or wood of natura] resistance to decay..:" 2. There is water seepage into the basement--the grading around the house and garage is not correct. Section 2905(f). Drainage "Provisions shall be made for the control and drainage of surface water around buildings:" 3. The steps on the front porch are constructed with a 9'/z-inch rise and 9-inch run. Section 3306(c). Rise and Run "Exceptions 1. Private staircvays...may be constructed with an 8-inch maximum rise and 9-inch marimum run." I am requesting that either Maryanne or Tom Montgomery meet with the Monahans to go through their one-year punch list and correct the items listed above as soon THE LONE OAK TREE...THE SYMBOL OF STRENGTH AND GROWfH IN OUR COMMUNIN Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer MONTGOMERY DESIGN & BUILD JLJLY 16, 1990 PAGE TWO as possible, and it should be completed before Friday, August 3, 1990. When the above items have been corrected, please call our office for reinspection. Sincerely, 2O-e ? Reid Chief Building Official DR/mg cc: Mr. and Mrs. Monahan c - DATE: 6/20/90 MEETING: 10:30 A.M. EAGAN MUNICIPAL CENTER, PRESENT: DOUG REID, CHIEF BUILDING OFFICIAL STEVE HANSON, ASST. BUILDING OFFICIAL JAN SEVERSON, SECRETARY MARYANNE & TOM MONTGOMERY, MONTGOMERY DESIGN & BUILD RE: MONTGOMERY DESIGN & BUILD VS PAT & JULIE MONAHAN 698 NORTHBRIDGE CT. L12, B4, HILIS OF STONESRIDGE ADDITION This meeting was held to review the homeowner's complaints against Montgomery Design and Build. MaryAnne & Tom Montgomery, Owners, indicated their concern about their Company name in relation to the City's Building Inspections Department. At this time, MaryAnne submitted paperwork to the City as follows: warranty lists, one-year sign off sheet, initial walk-through signed by Buyer, documentation throughout the process, Buyer's letter from attorney, information on picketing, Valley Plumbing's response to picketing, etc. It was agreed the best way to address the concerns was to go through the homeowner's list of concerns item by item, as follows: One item of major concern to the homeowners was that Montqomery Design & Build did not personally take care of any concerns they had. MaryAnne Montgomery does not agree with this, stating she has been very involved with this home and any repairs that are necessary. There seems to be a personality conflict between Tom Montgomery and the Buyer, but either she or Tom were there to oversee what went on with this house. i 1. Dav before closina - dry wall screw went thru metal nlate and into vine, floodina basement. Montgomerys agree this did happen--dry wall screw did cause leak when water was turned on. Further information on flood problems will be addressed in items 6& 7. Montgomerys state they had essentially four leaks starting with the dry wall screw, Jacuzzi, toilet and shower. They items were corrected by the plumbing contractor, Valley Plumbing. Montgomerys were concerned as this was an unusual number of leaks; however they were all independent and random items. Regarding the leak from the dry wall screw, the Chief Building Official responded that this can happen; the problem with the Jacuzzi was traced back to a malfunction of the tub from the manufacturer; plumber responded that the joint on the shower behind wall was probably pulled on, or hit by drywall contractor during construction, and did not leak when water was turned on as it wasn't under pressure. Then when shower was actually used, the pressure from the water produced a leak. Montgomerys were concerned about quality from plumbing contractor, however, after checking feel confident Valley Plumbing is very capable and will continue to use their services. Regarding comment from Bob, Supervisor with Montgomery Home & Design, stating to Bill Adams, Eagan Plumbing Inspector, "we have done all we can do." Bob has advised Tom & MaryAnne he told Bill Adams they had fixed all the problems to date and would complete any valid warranty work that was necessary. Montgomerys believe an adjustment of words can take on quite a different meaning. 2. House not cleaned - Montgomerys agree it was not cleaned properly and exchanged wallpapering services for this. Homeowner wanted to do cleaning herself to get it done. 3. Ceramic floorina - Montgomerys agree grout did turn to powder and flaked. They sought outside opinions as to the problem and were advised there was a problem with the grout itself, or the installation. They were advised to take out all the grout. They asked the ceramic tile company to come back and make the repairs, but did not get the response necessary so at that point, had their Company employee, Jody, make the necessary repairs. Montgomerys paid for the Buyers to stay at the Residence Inn while this took place. 4. Air conditioner - Flare Heating tested the unit and could find no problem mechanically. Aspen Electric then followed up and spent 11 work hours trying to solve the problem for the Buyer. The end result was that the condenser was replaced. To date, Montgomery Design & Build has not heard any more if its not working. 5. Doors - Montgomerys agree--it is possible weatherstripping needs to be replaced as it sometimes does get beat up. Atrium door - Montqomerys did replace this door, however felt it was extreme and would not have normally done so. It was done in this case as Montgomerys felt the Buyer had an unusual amount of problems with their home and did it as a"good will" gesture. Front door - Montgomerys state their supervisor says it is well within industry standards. Door was adjusted and will not get any better. 6. Jacuzzi - Previously discussed in item #1. 7. 2nd Floor Bath: Previously discussed in item #1. 8. Marble vanitv - Montgomerys have not heard of this problem before. No comment - not on any walk through or warranty list. 9. Kitchen faucet - It was replaced. 10. Lower level bath - Montgomerys agree that plumber did use a mixture of brass and chrome fixtures as the brass fixtures requested by the Buyer were on backorder. This was done so the house could be closed and were exchanged once they came in. 11. Window sill - Not uncommon to have a window sill that gets damaged. Montgomerys do not recall what the damage was, but state that it certainly is not uncommon for something to get damaged during construction. 12. Garaae doors - Montgomerys agree there was a problem. They do not believe the doors kept warping, but they had a problem with the primer in that it didn't allow the paint to be accepted. They order all their doors thru Automatic Garage Door Company and have never had this problem before. The problem was taken care of by Automatic Garage Door Company. Many of the problems they experienced were caused as this home was built in winter on a very tight time frame. Drivewav - It did have a settlement in it, again perhaps due to winter construction and frost heave. It was repaired. Garaae door openers - It certainly is possible these were programmed incorrectly, but the problem was taken care of. 13. Foundation - To the best of Montgomerys knowledge, there was a foundation leak by the front door, near the closet. A corner of the carpet in the closet got wet, was pulled back and dried out. Gutters were furnished by Montgomery Homes, as well as filling in under deck, etc. To the best of their knowledge, there have been no future problems. Montqomerys made a phone call to the Buyer after a rainstorm to see if they had any further leaks. Their response was that they had not, however called a while later and stated they had a problem. After checking, it was found to be related to one of the leaks previously discussed and not to the foundation itself. 14. Nail noAS - Montgomerys state this is exaggerated. Their drywall employee, Tim, advised them there were maybe 40 nail pops which were repaired and the walls were repainted by Jody. 15. Plumbina - Insulating the pipes is not a standard practice by Montgomery Home and Design. It certainly can be purchased, but was not done so by the Buyer. Again at the expense of Montgomery Home & Design, they did qo back in and attempt to insulate the pipes to satisfy the Buyer. Jody's statement regarding the noise was again heresay. It was certainly a misunderstanding, or misleading statement. 16. Half bath - Buyer signed a purchase agreement for a home similar to the model Montgomery Design & Build had for sale at the time which contained a sink and vanity. The Buyer changed the sink to a pedestal type, but did not indicate they wanted the Iocation changed. It was installed in the same area as the sink in the model. It is simply personal preference; five people may choose to have their sink centered, five people may choose to have it off to one side. 17. Family,room bar area - Again, the model did not have a bar. This was a change requested by the Buyer. Montgomerys do not know of any way to change the door with installation of a bar. This is the first they have heard of this problem. Regarding swivel for T.V. - Montgomerys did not do this as they could not get the type the Buyer requested for the price allowed; labor was once again exchanged for this item. Montgomerys sealed their tile floor instead. 18. Vents - Flare Heating came out again this spring and re- balanced the system. Sheet metal around duct could have gotten bent if the vents are not carefully installed. Sometimes they are walked on during construction, etc. 19. Outside wall outlets - Montgomery Design & Build states this is normal and they did have someone spray around all the outlets. These could be sealed tight at a cost of about $2,000, but a heat/air exchanger would be required once the home is sealed that tightly. This is available as an option. 20. WallpaAer - handled. 21. Counter tob - Montgomery repaired. Zf there is a continuing problem, they don't know about it. 22. Supoort wall - Montgomery is not aware of ever using any rotting lumber. Bob DaVanni, Supervisor for Montgomery Design & Build, never heard of the problem, replaced a crowned studs in the dining room. Crowning is a completely different issue than rotting; they don't feel Shaw Lumber has ever sent them rotted lumber. 23. Floor sweaks - Fixed. 24. Holes in concrete block - Montgomerys never did see, or smell, any mice. This is theorized only. No holes were found in block. t3ormally the way mice get in are when a homeowner moves in, taking boxes from the garage, leaving the garage doors open, and mice are carried in with boxes. 25. Brick - Again, home was built during wintertime and some of the mortar did need to be replaced. 26. Ceilinas - in the kitchen ceiling, there were rusty sheetrock screws caused by the water leak mentioned in Item #1. Montqomerys spent approximately $800 to repair this problem. All of the texture throughout the family room and hallway was removed arid fixed this spring to give the Buyer the level of satisfaction they desired. Generally, when sheetrock is wet only for a short time, it does not stain. During construction, subcontractors are advised not to do changes at the Buyer's request; a Change Order must be agreed to by the Builder and Buyer and signed by both parties. It is the Builder's responsibility to schedule the painting of ceilinqs, or any other construction-related item. Regarding the 9:00 P.M. inspection, MaryAnne states that the Buyer had requested this time, which she agreed to, however cancelled as the Buyer had started picketing and had hired an attorney. It was her feeling that it was not appropriate to discuss this any further at that time of night. 27. Water softener - hoses stuck into the drain, discharge. 28. Another flood - Montgomery Desiqn & Build provides the Buyer with a handout at the time of closing, advising the Buyer how to take care of their plumbing system. It is clearly indicated on the handout that the hoses must be removed during winter and faucets should be drained. This matter has been turned over to their insurance company. Montgomerys do not know the results of liability at this time. MaryAnne states she was misquoted regarding the "lemon" issue. The reason Tim could not face the Buyer was because the Buyer verbally abused the construction people so badly that he refused to go back. He informed MaryAnne that he would not work there any more and she agreed with him that he did not have to take that type of treatment from a Buyer. Regarding fixing the flooding problems again stating that it is a major job digging out dirt, fixing holes, and putting in drain tile. Tom Montgomery states that this goes back to a conversation that took place a year ago when water was coming into the closet, that the fellow who was out making repairs started talking about all the things that could happen and the possible solutions that could exist. That's the only possible source of that. Digging down would normally be a last resort, if a number of other things don't work. Typically, there are 15-20 alternative solutions to dealing with water problems. MaryAnne Montgomery states that she initiated a phone , conversation with Pat Monahan to see if they had any leaks after a rainstorm. He stated to her that he felt the drain tile may have to be replaced. MaryAnne said she knew this was a last resort, and also knew they were having little, if no, water problems. Pat Monahan kept going back to the fact that he felt they had a foundation problem. It was his statement as to how he felt this should be taken care of. MaryAnne told him she would take care of his problems, and would not walk away from their responsibility. Homeowner gave contractor several lists of items to be corrected during the first six months and contractor has lost all records. Montgomerys have the records and submitted some copies to the City for review. Regarding the inspection by Don Hedquist: 1. The house was rough graded only at the time of the building final; the yard work was not complete at this time. When Montgomerys filled in around the foundation to alleviate water leaks, they may have filled the area a little high to allow for settling. It is typical for a home to settle for five years or more. That situation could exist now, but can be adjusted. Most builders anticipate settling. This is typical. 2. Again - rough grade only at final. 3. No front steps at final. Temporary steps were indicated on the building permit inspection card at the final inspection. The City of Eagan has asked Montgomerys to correct and they have agreed. . The Chief Building Official stated the rest of the items are not Code items. MaryAnne responded as follows: #4 has been done, this is the ceiling in the kitchen which was redone and the Buyer does not like it. They dropped a strinq line; there was no more than 1/4" of deflection from the bar wall in the family room to the south wall of the kitchen. The rock was sound, texturing and retaping was done. More details would be available from Bob DaVanni if needed. 5. This is the first they heard of it and will fix if necessary. 6. This was the fault of Peoples Natural Gas Company. Electrical disconnect was there first as Buyer was on propane when house was finaled. This has been taken care of. ? Reviewed• ` ?Tom & Date: l "'lU' 9U Reviewed: k06?_ gkQ Date: ! ` 13 - / z:) Doug Re , Chief Building Official . . ? May 25, 1990 Poat-It'• brand lax transmittal memo 7671 N ol papes . .e.. ;d Pat MonahaN 698 NorthbrS.dge Court Eagan, Minnesota Dear Mr. Monaham: These are a number of the items that do not meet the minimum requiremente of the Uni form S12i1 A9 nrr Codpa; 1• The dirt is less than 6 inches from the wood fzoor joists. See, 2516(c)7, k'ood and eartih separatfon. "••WOOd used An construction of permanent sCructures and located nearer than 6 3nches to earth sha11 be treated wood or wood of natural rasistancs to decay...to 2. There is watier seepage into the basement - the gxading around the house and garage is not correct. Sec. 2905(f). Drainage. "Frovisions shall kie made for the contral and drainage of surface water around buixdings." 3• The steps on the front porch are constructed with an 9 1/2-inch riae and 9-inch zun. 8ec. 3306 (C). Rise and Run. "Exceptione 1, Private stairways,,,may be constructed with an 8-inch maximum riss and 9-?,nch maximum run.ti ' 4. The ceiling in the kitchen is sagged as a result of water seapage from the bathroom. The repair was not dona in a workmanlike manner. 69$ Northbridge Court Page Two ?• The co ? pper water supply is primped at the basement ?fab elevation. i 6The gas meter hae been iqstalled in front of the el?ctrica2 dlsaonnect Box. E If you have any Purther questions, please cali, Sincerely, ? ? bon Nedquist ? DH:mr ! , . DATE: 5/15/90 MEETING: 5:30 P.M. EAGAN MUNICIPAL CENTER 1 PRESENT: DOUG REID, CHIEF BUILDING OFFICIAL STEVE HANSON, ASST. BUILDING OFFICIAL JAN SEVERSON, SECRETARY PAT & JULIE MONAHAN, 698 NORTHBRIDGE CT., L12, B4, HILLS OF STONEBRIDGE ADDITION Phone #228-4602 (Pat - Work) 835-9977 (Julie - Work) RE: COMPLAINT AGAINST GENERAL CONTRACTOR MONTGOMERY DESIGN & BUILD This meeting was held at the request of Pat & Julie Monahan to review construction concerns at their home, 698 Northbridqe Court. Their home was completed in.of 1989; Montgomery ,?-- - Design & Build was the general contractor. One item of major concern to the homeowners was that Montgomery Design & Build did not personally take care of any concerns they had. They always sent a sub-contractor, or Company employee, out to talk with them--no personal service. Homeowner transferred in from Iowa; wife could not go out and look for work for the first six months as it was,neces?ary to ??",? u?r???ryt?/?`?f? cr?-cm?y. Home is approximate y 3,200 sq. ft. The homeowners have comprised a list of 32-36 items that they 1-114 have given to their attorney. Doug Reid requested that a copy be forwarded to this department for review. In order to limit the time of this meeting, the homeowners gave an itemization of concerns, as follows: 1. Day before closing - dry wall screw went thru metal plate arid into pipe, flooding basement. A second and third flood occurred the day they moved in. When basement flooded, MaryAnn Montqomery informed owner they would send over fans and heater right away, but never did. Two days went by, carpet was still soaked. Carpet installer was in lower level and pointed out that a leak was coming through their ceiling. Toilet upstairs not sealed - leaked into basement and toilet had to be replaced. Tom Montgomery asked homeowner to give ceilings some time to dry out; homeowner agreed, but asked Montgomerys if they would fix if necessary. They agreed. Two or three days later, dripping stopped, ceiling did not ? discolor, but started warping. With light on in evening, itjf? -Btate f casts 2' to 3' shadow,;, ?I"' ?u?/'?t?n/?tc'!Y? /H?`T?QM6 "1l•e Awl"e ?4?e r 2. h??iise n? -clean6ed? X?/ o ner spent ?-7 h u?? ?leanin before being able to move in. Montgomery Design traded out Ann's services to paper in return for the cleaning. 3. Ceramic floorina - grout turned to powder--could be scraped out with finqernail; -d'a -e` h^'a "'°° '^ p'a°eJ tiles broke .and ' . Montgomery Design & Build by sending a cons?rp ?upt}o? worker, not a Q? •f/kt to correct.,XWree different colors__of ----- -- - - - -- hi different times. Finally, came of grout, breaking several tiles, could 3-4 days. attempted to repair tile installer, out -grout were used ?re- ------- --- and scraped out 330' as ((,5tj not use kitchen//jfor 4. Air conditioner - whenever unit turns on, the lights flicker, TV shuts off, and buzz can be heard in circuit box next to family room, terrible smell in walls, like something burning, and did not always cool.? Neighbor witnessed this. A/C unit ?0 was finally replacedAI1/89--has not been used since so unsure if problem is solved. Supplier of air conditioner stated to homeowners unit was not defective so they don't feel problem is solved. ,k times on lower 5. Doors - weatherstripping was replaced 2- level. Atrium door glass scratched. Needed to be??A? ? replaced. Front door does not fit properly . A III gap below door. Snow and rain coming in on floor. Montgomery adjusted, now there is a gap on top of the door (steel door) .a/ne Ae 6. Jacuzzi broke within one hour after cl?Ring, causing flooding. Took 10-12 weeks to fix. Factory rep. (Swirlway) finally called in to determine problem, then sent bill to owners to pay. Result: Circuit breaker had to be replaced. 7. 2nd Floor Bath: Day of move in, when son took,showe?r,n wat er p?? •tP ..-.°•,.t. came through ceiling; defective valve hac? to be replaced. 8. Marble vanitv - warped. hFn 9. Kitchen faucet - gouged, had to be replaced. S nk had a ,Cuy- OIC" in it pnG'I uV.° re?rfa c c°W• 10. Lower level bath - Plumber used mixture of chrome and brass fixtures, i.e. brass on shower, chrome on sink - had to be changed. 11. Windowsill had to be replaced. 12. Garage doors - double doors replaced four times, single door replaced three times; won't hold paint and keepS warping. (type: wood, stained, raised panel). Installer placed brace on it the last time. Service door f?? s??/??n?can see light through. When repairing gara oor, contract r damaged '" ?1h?` ??' door knob leading from house to garage so ? homeowner could not use door. Took thr-e week-4'to qet contractor back to fix. P D ive av caved in as owner backed out to tell Montgomery of these problems. Garage door obeners - homeowner was to receive two transmitters for each door. Waited three ? 0?- to four months fornthese. Guy, superintendent for Montgomery, ?ought transmitters, programmed, gave them to the owner, incorrectly programmed all four to open one door. 13. Foundation: Beginning Sune 1989, with each rainfall or when homeowner waters lawn, lower level leakns?.'. Carpet has to be `?,A„a,r.?•y.pAOGGtl! ??GtJ C.Mt?.2(" taken out and replaced each time (8). Walk-in closet and utility room get wet. Homeowner hired a private inspector, Don Hedquist, 5/15/90, referred to them by their attorney. It is this inspector's opinion grading is not properl n ? ? ^? OTJTiPY a a/rJd wal?ls could c/o?llapse at any time. jT^ • ,aj_q( {'W,?f.ZZL-ft7'L? vZf?? i wr, ttnn reppr_t--,' 14. 100-200 nail nons. Tim, con$truction worker for Montgomery Homes, hammered, re-?/? ever repainted or put paint only on spot of nail pop, thus wall is different colored, looks like checkerboard - sanded clifferently, left many dents. 15. Plumbina: pipes in bathroom not insulated. When flushing be?vr7 a)al/• toilet, pipes, ratt3.-a; pi6ing under tub area not insulated-- noisy. Montgomery Design & Build cut holes in guest bedroom closet and behind kitchen cabinets in an attempt to fix. Jody could not believe noise they were making. 16. ?a!n bath - homeowner requested pedestal sink instead of wall model on plan. Montgomery agreed to this, but pedestal sink was not centered on wall; it was installed in the same place as the wall unit, making it inconvenient to use. 17. Familv room bar area uniYsable ?a?s builder did not properly place door. Cannot open dooras wet bar is in way; must be closed in order to access this area. Swivel for TV and VCR was to be built in, owner still has not received. 18. Vents - sheetetal is collapsing inside - 1j2 of rooms are not receivingn heat or cool air. 19. Outside wall outlets - cold air blowing in. Design & Build corrected by spraying foam around outlets.6''?? d FA / 20. Walloaoer shrinking around countertops. Corrected by placing quarter round edging around countertops. 21. Counterton - snack bar, angle separated three times. ` Montgomery Design & Build had countertop installer a . rr?` It is his belief counter itself needstbracing to prevent this from recurring. f 22. Supbort wall - homeowner noticed two rotted 2x41s during construction. When questioning Tom Montgomery, they were told +f,ough ulr'rtn as p10.ced#?hrm?( -?f'rem. these were temporary only/? Homeowner has ? wince discovered `J they were never replaced. 1 ? OL-?•u?Q,v 23. Floor scxueaks - master bedroom, fixed, but has returned. Step squeaks as well. Homeowner observed bridging for floor was not connected when flooring was ripped up. Contractor stated they ere supposed to be connected and proceeded to hammer ?C 6t??S h?'. ? ? lo 24. Holes in concrete block - mice qet in. 25. Brick - mortar needed replacing. 26. Ceilinas - did not receive coat of paint before texturing. As a result, rusty sheetrock screws have popped thru all over. Painter stated to them that they had been advised not to paint the Monahans ceilings. He said they paint all other ceilings, but were told specifically not to paint theirs. He said they would be back more often than they wanted because they could not paint the ceiling. 27. Water softener - hose not put into drain so each time it recycled, it shot water all over. Supervisor showed homeowner how to use water softener and left the water running, not realizing he had turned something and it flooded inft the utility room. 28. 4/21/90 - another flood. Pipe leading to outside faucet burst in wall. Montgomery claims it is owner's fault. Owner states he has owned &-kr other homes and never had a problem. He turned water faucet off in utility room in the fall of the ? Ua year and opened the faucets to qrain. Waterover foot when ?h?- QtaZl'1l?!?1`' ?,{1,e/'c°- walking in lower level At 10:30 p.m. Montgomery's a-ata not home, owner called worker (3ody Shaefer) who called in Valley Plumbing. At 2:00 A.M. they knocked hole in wall and found burst pipe. Damage -$5,200 + one of a kind pool table and personal stuff, antiques, etc. Frost proof, freeze proof system used so it should not have needed to be drained. Sunday, 4/22/90 - MaTyAnn Montgomery called owner and stated, "Pat, Tom and i feel very sorry about this, but I guess you have a lemon". / ? ? i ?..v? o eo! G1a? i - ?o/!rc 11 S t ha d Yv ree wrk o?e oW ? asked them to m ol4se, h9wever did(fsOt offer to pa?y, / r #-/?"•?. They moved to Residence Inn for-two nights thr e •?(?/ 7)?. days? while a ceiling expert was brought in. T?y came over and 'Tim stated, "Oh, this is going to take 7 days; I am definitely going to have to take out all the sheetrock. i" G• I am qoing to have to replace it; that's all there is to it, Jody". In the end, all they did was scrap" the texturing off, pounded a few screws into the sheetrock, and re-sprayed. When owner questioned this, Tim stated, "T ran a line and this is plumb." They left and returned the following Monday to fix nail pops. Tim could not face owner, stated he did what Zo he was told. ??x i? U? ? Homeowner gave aontractor several lists of items to be corrected ? 7? ?C contractor has lost all records. ?U Reviewed• Date: Pat or Julie Monahan Reviewed• Date: •Doug Reid, Chief Building Official -,72? v?? 1?ze XLVI L / 2-16 ? ? ??LIGNT P? ? O?ITGOM?.RY I??SI?N ANO BU?LD ?NOME ?E ? AK Acio 0 WEVE HADO I ) J I X M ASOV?, 1nlTk.fZ1D(Z PIOODS lri LESS l NAN ONE ?ERR I 1 a 2•J REpEATED ELEt_ i iZICPtL PR06LEM5 3.) P\EPEATED PLooR P??2oi)--LEMS 4.) KEPEA-,ED Cei 6NCI A-No WAu. VRblSLEMS 5.) REPERTED PLuMPbiN6 k?Ro6?M5'° ?.? ?OU t? DF? i i?N PRDaL?MS • 1.F `(OU ARE CoNStDEIZiNCx HAVING A HOUSE 6u1LT YOU ARE WELCOME 70 ZNSPELT Ol1R HOME AND DELDE ?0 2 `I OU RSE LF. ,?-----? - 1173 ? (pal"e4) DATE: 5/15/90 MEETING: 5:30 P.M. EAGAN Mi7NICIPAL CENTER PRESENT: DOUG REID, CHIEF BUILDING OFFICIAL STEVE HANSON, ASST. BUILDING OFFICIAL JAN SEVERSON, SECRETARY PAT & JULIE MONAHAN, 698 NORTHBRIDGE CT., L12, B4, HILLS OF STONEBRIDGE ADDITION Phone #228-4602 (Pat - Work) 835-9977 (Julie - Work) RE: COMPLAINT AGAINST GENERAL CONTRACTOR MONTGOMERY DESIGN & BUILD This meeting was held at the request of Pat & Julie Monahan to review construction concerns at their home, 698 Northbridge Court. Their home was completed in April of 1989; Montgomery Design & Build was the general contractor. One item of major concern to the homeowners was that Montgomery Design & Build did not personally take care of any concerns they had. They always sent a sub-contractor, or Company employee, out to talk with them--no personal service. Homeowner transferred in from Iowa; wife could not go out and look for work for the first six months as it was necessary to be at home for repairs, replacements, and completion of projects unfinished. Home is approximately 3,200 sq. ft. The homeowners have comprised a list of 32-36 items that they had to replace and have given to their attorney. Doug Reid requested that a copy be forwarded to this department for review. In order to limit the time of this meeting, the homeowners gave an itemization of concerns, as follows: 1. Day before closing - dry wall screw went thru metal plate and into pipe, flooding basement. A second and third flood occurred the day they moved in. When basement flooded, Maryanne Montgomery informed owner they would send over fans and heater right away, hut never did. Two days went by, carpet was still soaked. Carpet installer was in lower level and pointed out that a leak was coming through their ceiling. Toilet upstairs not sealed - leaked into basement and toilet had to be replaced. Tom Montgomery asked homeowner to give ceilings some time to dry out; homeowner agreed, but asked Montgomerys if they would fix if necessary. They agreed. Two or three days later, dripping stopped, ceiling did not discolor, but started warping. With light on in evening, it casts 2' to 3' shadow. Bob, Supervisor with Montgomery, stated to Bill Adams, Eagan Plumbing Inspector, "we have done all we can do." Montgomery's have yet to see our problem after repeated requests from us to see it for themselves. 2. House not cleaned - homeowner spent 6-7 hours cleaning before being able to move in. Montgomery Design traded out Ann's services to paper in return for the cleaning. 3. Ceramic floorina - grout turned to powder--could be scraped out with fingernail; tiles broke. Montgomery Design & Build attempted to repair by sending a construction worker, not a tile installer, out to correct. Appeared that three different colors of grout were used due to patching at different times. Finally, came and scraped out 330' of grout, breaking several tiles; could not use kitchen, as usual, for 3-4 days. 4. Air conditioner - whenever unit turns on, the lights flicker, TV shuts off, and buzz can be heard in circuit box next to family room, terrible smell in walls (like something burning), and did not always cool. Neighbor witnessed this. A/C unit was finally replaced approximately 11/89--has not been used since so unsure if problem is solved. Supplier of air conditioner stated to homeowners unit was not defective so they don't feel problem is solved. 5. Doors - weatherstripping was replaced two times on lower level. Atrium door glass scratched. Needed to be replaced. Front door does not fit properly. There was a 1" gap below door. Snow and rain coming in on floor. Montgomery adjusted, now there is a gap on top of the door (steel door). Came to fix again, and still is not flush. 6. Jacuzzi broke within one hour after moving in, causing flooding. Took 10-12 weeks to fix. Factory rep. (Swirlway) finally called in to determine problem, then sent bill to owners to pay. Result: Circuit breaker had to be replaced. 7. 2nd Floor Bath: Day of move in, when son took shower, water came through ceiling; defective valve had to be replaced, or pipes had to be resoldered. 8. Marble vanitv - warped. 9. Kitchen fauaet - gouged, had to be replaced. Kitchen sink had a large warp in it and was replaced. 10. Lower level bath - Plumber used mixture of chrome and brass fixtures, i.e. brass on shower, chrome on sink - had to be changed. 11. Window sill had to be replaced. 12. Garaae doors - double doors replaced four times, single door replaced three times; won't hold paint and keep warping. (type: wood, stained, raised panel). Installer placed brace on it the last time. Service door needs sealer (cement) - can see light through. When repairing kitchen floor, contractor damaged door knob leading from house to garage so that the homeowner could not use door. Took one week to get contractor back to fix. Portion of drivewav caved in as owner backed out to tell Montgomery of these problems. Garaae door openers - homeowner was to receive two transmitters for each door. Waited three to four months for two of these. Guy, Superintendent for Montgomery, brought transmitters, programmed, gave them to the owner, incorrectly programmed all four to open one door. 13. Foundation: Beginning June 1989, with each rainfall or when homeowner waters lawn, lower level leaks. Carpet has to be taken out and replaced each time (8). Finally needed new carpet. Walk-in closet and utility room get wet. Homeowner hired a private inspector, Don Hedquist, 5/15/90, referred to them by their attorney. It is this inspector's opinion grading is not properly done and walls could collapse at any time. See attached Code violation sheet. 14. 100-200 nail nops. Tim, construction worker for Montgomery Homes, hammered, refilled, never repainted or put paint only on spot of nail pop, thus wall is different colored, looks like checkerboard - sanded differently, left many dents. 15. Plumbina: pipes in bathroom not insulated. When flushing toilet, pipes beat on wall; piping under tub area not insulated--noisy. Montgomery Desiqn & Build cut holes in guest bedroom closet and behind kitchen cabinets in an attempt to fix. Jody could not believe noise they were making. 16. Half bath - homeowner requested pedestal sink instead of wall model on plan. Montgomery agreed to this, but pedestal sink was not centered on wall; it was installed in the same place as the wall unit, making it inconvenient to use. 17. Familv room bar area unusable as builder did not properly place door. Cannot open door fully as wet bar is in way, must be closed in order to access this area. Swivel for TV and VCR was to be built in, owner still has not received. 18. Vents - sheet metal is collapsing inside - 1/2 of rooms are not receiving full heat or cool air. 19. Outside wall outlets - cold air blowing in. Montgomery Design & Build corrected by spraying foam around outlets. Has not resolved problem. 20. Wallbaper shrinking around countertops. Corrected by placing quarter round edging around countertops. 21. Countertoo - snack bar, angle separated three times. Montgomery Design & Build had countertop installer repair. It is his belief counter itself needs bracing to prevent this from recurring. Continues to separate (is bumpy). 22. Support wall - homeowner noticed two rotted 2x4's during construction. When questioning Tom Montgomery, they were told these were temporary only even though wiring was placed through them. Homeowner has since discovered they were never replaced. 23. Floor saueaks - master bedroom, fixed, but another squeak has returned. Step squeaks, as well. Homeowner observed bridging for floor was not connected when flooring was ripped up. Contractor stated they were supposed to be connected and proceeded to hammer the ones he could see, in. 24. Holes in concrete block - mice get in. 25. Brick - mortar needed replacing. 26. Ceilinas - did not receive coat of paint before texturing. As a result, rusty sheetrock screws have popped thru all over. Painter stated to them that they had been advised not to paint the Monahans ceilinqs. He said they paint all other ceilings, but were told specifically not to paint theirs. He said they would be back more often than they wanted because they could not paint the ceiling. 27. Water softener - hose not put into drain so each time it recycled, it shot water all over. Supervisor showed homeowner how to use water softener and left the water running, not realizing he had turned something and it flooded in the utility room. 28. 4/21/90 - another flood. Pipe leading to outside faucet burst in wall. Montgomery claims it is owner's fault. Owner states he has owned four other homes and never had a problem. He turned water faucet off in utility room in the fall of the year and opened the faucets to drain. Water was over foot when walking in lower level that evening. At 10:30 p.m. Montgomery's were not home, owner called worker (Jody Shaefer) who called in Valley Plumbing. At 2:00 A.M. they knocked hole in wall and found burst pipe. Damage -$5,200 + one of a kind pool table and personal stuff, antiques, etc. Frost proof, freeze proof, system used so it should not have needed to be drained. Sunday, 4/22/90 - Maryanne Montgomery called owner and stated, "Pat, Tom and i feel very sorry about this, but I guess you have a lemon". Since inconvenienced for a possible 7-10 days, Monahans had to leave their house to have major work done on replacement of their bowed ceilings from prior floods. They moved to Residence Inn for two nights, three days, (they were told to move back in after 3 days) while a ceiling expert was brought in. Tim, the ceiling expert, and Jody came over and Tim stated, "Oh, this is going to take 7 days; I am definitely going to have to take out all the sheetrock. I am going to have to replace it; that's all there is to it, Jody". In the end, all they did was scrape the texturing off, pound a few screws into the sheetrock, and re-sprayed. When owner questioned this, Tim stated, "I ran a line and this is plumb." They left and returned the following Monday to fix nail pops. Tim could not face owner, stated he did what he was told. The Monahans have not landscaped their home due to the fact that the Montgomerys still need to fix their flooding problems. This is a major job in that they have to dig out dirt down to the first blocks and tiles and drill holes and maybe replace the drain tiles. Maryanne said this will be taken care of, but when? Homeowner gave contractor several lists of items to be corrected during the first six months and contractor haj lost all records. Reviewed• Date: / Pat or Julie Monahan Reviewed:?Pc..a ?J Date: Doug R d, Chief Building Official Ci) N,4!/1rp?" A ? AV?A).A41'(A? ? g ?.,e?? 4 , . 64,d -66'e, '444 14?4"-c ? c? a&h,,° 9n?y ?., &AW a4 G L ? % =v 1 ?'9 G, sfav C&O, 210 64 ?Ja4 r ? ?v? ? dw-I &14 d?d 7.ZK Q,?? 14A??,?? L, L ze?le. \ ? PO,?b dMvl ( 3 CMy4 ?4 ?W? ??l a4V ?Y,"461„ I-s" ?? ??'?e-f?-R-?? ?C?C'+( t ? U.?uL?P,CLk[C ?1? C?G`u?\ l? ?f,e?TP? GZL4. Cl`'?Cxcuq ?vnC? 6u'f _?'?['?t?,(}1.??cwa?? d l ??e?.Q?z.??,Q .,?1? ??? ??r .?ao? c?z,? /- . / be 104, a1-4?uu? . 3JU e? ?c%. pft 14Ut) ? lzrl ?arn p?eeec?, «. A?eu7 .? c?? .E,4 TAa 75 -? ? ?? Ac,???e?P ?4.-&Oa? -/t&< A)a Z,16? „ ? ?' Cti`G2Q, 7,??iizw?u?+ GK z? G'Gru'u?r f.e???uC d f aw??.e 0) A4.) ? .?(.Ed-9i ? iLric4? c1:C?1u:n.? l?c2? (.?,?'?-• U u d iz ? t?n .?-'? 4,,&, fi -?x..J? / .? , ItAd R? ?.? C?'?,u ? A ? ??p? ?r l.la Gti`r.?' fAL/ -? (?. ? o?- ???-n ?1C`? ? ? "? !?W 46W 6L dA, au' a4j 1,?A4, .?Xv'? ?- lM 14ade, 6? A"aa I -liv /;' A6:.? ? ?? ? 4? -gic ? ?? . . , C-V. X AtdJcxX qr,pl-c?? 07r Aavem Ca? -& 4114 ?P so a-I 7a1'-1v ..C,????.uy ?,p q?.?l?ri44L.: Lin ??IAK • i f?? w? •? ^ ?i ? W-w ? ! t?L?K1 -CJc2 ?k),??ry L l1 ?1.??? 04? O"" ia?e.,/?cuu? 7pG''ad?:U u ?2 ? . ?) ? 4???;)Pl ?7 - DD Q.t-trvieQ/t? ?/inqry, S+oAe bridge- 3a99 o 1aO o 1/ Par+I ., clokdy CITIZEN'S REQUEST FORM 40 o ? EAGAN ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT DATE: r - '12 - q0 NAME : C mm A ADDRESS : PHONE : (p g 7- q 8 3 7 NATIIRE OF REgUEST: ??LQ?, Qin,p? ? 'rc? F 1 ) e. ^ Pw,r c8 I CiZ ua ?z ttr ? .Lrl. -.lK.? ...k- -t- n a- tn + n , A e u.. - 2 )s6L -(,? TAKEN BY: AA _,. 1A ) AEFERRED TO: A 5 A? P. ACTZON TAKEN:? or tkQ &jj 40` CAIM ?M ? 5? BY: n?.. Ni ; _,Vk A11.e./L- ,a.n.c-& DATE : I - a - t- CUL-CE-SA STA I +67.91 \0 \ 919. 6r; . i r Ic (D QI 9. G8 r?aiq, a3 • ?'=119?d? ??; ?19,+8 s I9 ? ? '0)6/ 0 . . ? Y ? c I- . LC n ? STA 0+00 ///-CON SEECDETAIL ALLEY i--4 1= ? STA I I+ 3191 STONEBRIOGE ORIVE NORTH ? :ch ? 10 LTI (L I \ I Q ? I 1682 ? = p / I ?- u .918.80 I ? ?Q?! r.G ?18.82 / 1? TC.9? I?fi. 0 -- / C.918.54 ? ? ? rn m` I TC. 918.80 ? i ? T.G 9iZ47 ; ZAMAnDOT TYPE"p" 131 14 CONCRETE C&G 14?4A?) 4-S q?6 W ? O ? Z ? F-' i I 1 O '. C. 91E.10 ? C?, \! ,?6, ? C.Y17..i9 C, \ C.=iZ47) C.9ii ? oi i 4c: 91303 ; cn i - Uf a-I ?- cuRVE ??ArL, ? ? ?_?'???a,.,__.e.e?,..;.? --r?.?..,?_??.a?:_----- , __ .__. ? ------_ _ _ _ _ . _ , ??au./tRo'?"? Q-?.?e....?( .. f/Z....R?^-e,? .._ ,...??._....G_'?.?.,._?._----=----.?"?.?..? _-- ?clC b+,. _ ??' ??.?/ _?''t .-?vi?..t. ? _. -- ? ? S??Ks ? c ?.?A...? ii? .? ' ??-?-'-- -et,.^-'? I;; ii: ,_.___---- ?" ?V __/+?wee/?. ?,? ' ` w? I.?J ?,r-?e_ _??a¢: s?k?-?s _ _.-_. c?&._____ ? - -r__?P._?"?.''-? ._--_ s.?--.?:.?-7?_q:,..f -.? .....?-...s e? . __. .?......, __,..24.:.e._ _.--_ _?`ta.?..g?.. - W-Dk! ---- '. .._ .. __ _ ..--- _ .__.._._...__???_._ _ ._.__. ?,,..??•,.a.?r.? - - - ? ' i ! . 1 P,? ; i? Y?-.' . • 'y.M?_... -3 -{?•,s,?•(?-?..?.(____.P._?1( `-"'--- __- ------ ?-._. Ic ?.?¢-r?.--- ------....---- -...._....--------- ------ ' ' ?,,le1F--(3?-------------------- - -. .._..-- ------ ------- --- - Ge ,qa4-"l- ,. t ? 7t/ _?i... Co?.•.-1? aL? L? e?. ? 5??,, ?.,?'?,., ? _ ._ .,.. ? _ ,.. _ . _._?._ . _.__._..:. _. ii I?! ?_._...?.___ ,:_ . . . . . _ ?'?, A?,r? s ?-- f?`?-, ??,2. ??? -- ??, ?.t,,., ?e?dt. ? _._. _.-_.....?;/ /CARBON DIOXIDE DIVISION J ?'a C-e-a?/ ?n l'jt?4 !? ? /?' n r / ?-v yc?•1 \ E V OUGNT A Mc)NTGomERY DE5-IGN 6ND BUILD ?l 0 ? ME 1 YEAK AGo , \14 E" vE H Ao: 1} SI X MASOIZ 1.nITEfZIDR ? I?ODS Zh1 L ESS 1 wAN OWE Y EttR I 2-•1 REYERTED ELEC.. -L QICFtL PRObLEMS 3.? REPEATED ?:LooR Pt2o-ei-EMS 4.? REPEATED LEi 6N6 A-No WAL.I._. P266LEMS 5.? RIEPER l ED 'PLuMY,IN6 PP.ca6l...EMS ?•? eoU N DFt -iiDN P966LEMS J F ?ou ARC CONSIDERIN6 HM iNCa A HOUSE 6uiLT YOu ARE W ELCoM E-T O ZNSPEL.T OUR HoME ANn DE(-I DE fOIZ `IOURSELF. 1nM - C1837 Montgomery Design & Build 3786 WINDTREE DRIVE EAGAN, MN 55123 (612) 861-1773 :NCNIHAN FACTS I: respcr.se to Monihaa allega?ia :s we :espoad: 1. See Valleti Plum6ing :Jompany, Inc. Ietter 3ated 5-9-30 a. One oP the origi:al leaks.pro.a.uced enough wate: to cause drywall sagging in kitchen ceiling. This spot c.as replaced. b. Item n 6- Eraken lacan :aucet Csrpet in lowest lzcel suturate.3, our insurance repreaer.tative has been investigatir,a to determine liability. 2. Aspen Electric (°9C-636z') repluced wiring to rzir conditioner conder.ser because of humming noise. Noise cli.a. r.ct gc awuy. . Flare Iieating replaced eondenser unit. Humming noise went uway°. 3. Flooring problam was one of cracking and fla'aing grout in kitchen floor. Craut was replacad. 4. Ceiling and wall problems were dr;rwall craclzs. ?9a guarantee you will also have drywal1 cracking du:i;,,g the first ;;ear. P7e have never built a home that has not ha3 drywall cracks. We do a 1 yeur warrar.ty repair of sll ctrywall crac::s as normal procedure. 5. Co to item n 1(this seems to be a do loop without exit). 6. We are unaware of an;; foundation problems. 7. Monihan's are demanding we pay them $75,000 for the incipience we hace brought to their lives by way of this list of problems. Mary unr. Montgome:y Thcnas `:ontgor.iery . ? r V A?.;;1.:,JGI P?, tJ ?e?BIl?l G COM?"`.C7???, ALV a. 810 CRCEK LANE. JtlHOAN, htINNGSbTA 55352 - (612) 492-2121 f6 12) 492-26 1 7 ?May 4? 1950 MontgamFxy Design & Build co. 3786 Windtree Dx•4ve Ragan; MN 55123 , Attn: Mary Ann A?ontgpmery Re: 698 NorthbrzC2.ge Court Eagan, MN Dear Mar.y Ann; The fc>llowir_g are a li.st of prablems we haa at the abnve addrass ard the correctivp- action takeris 1) Water So£tner Dratn At tkle time tFze water softner was installed,r the plumb?ar on the job rieedera additional pipe to complete the drain for the water softner, heing he neerled addtional mate.rial, the water was never turr.ed on to the water so£Y.ner. Befare the plumber arr.a.ved back on the jab ta comp]-ete this taslc, somehne mistakenly tkrned the water cn T.o the softner, when the w3ter taas turned on the softner regenerat?d and cause-.d watzr to be.di5charc;ed on the £loor which ran inta the floox dxain. Actior_ ta3cen: A drain was immediately installed on the softner discharge to eliminated further mishapsa 2} Wisirlp9ol lir=e The first week the o:aners moved ixito k:heir home, the whirlpool in the master bath developed a laak on the pipe that feeds the whirlpool jets. Action taken; Immediatelp aL'ter receiving the cali, Allen Pesol,a went over tn the Piome anr.l reuairer.i the l.eak on the line. The leak occuzred by manufacture defeat in the whirlpool design. 3) W'ater line leak T'he same week a leak on a water pfpe eccurred The pipe was fourid to have bnen punctured by a screw. Acti,on taY.en: 9noe adain the problem was promptly raKen care of aftex receivina notice. Ttxe section of pige was xemoved and a r.ew peice was replaced. ¢) Ice maker Sn the followirig cceeY.s we were rzol.ified by the hameoconer that their a.ce mal;er kit cao,xld not work. She stated her applzance s2rvice compariy said it was c3ue to £aulty i.nstailatAon by Valley Plumbina. klowever, Lhis was not the case. The kit was of de£ective desi.gn. Ac:tion taken: Va11cy Plumbing ir complianr,e with the owm.er replaced thsir ice maker kit free af char.ge. 5) Palfshed brass kavcets U7e werp notifi?d by the homeowner that Yier palished bress faucets wc-rc flaking off_ The ha.s btan a cc>mmon probl.em tY1X'Q+,1ctY1oUM , the cfty o£ Eagan, we bell.ave there 13 passibly som%sthing causing this problsm fzom city water water or cl=anirig chemi.r..al.s. Aatioax taken; ,A£fier we v;ere.noti£ied by the owner, we placAd pn ord2r her taucets, after they arrivecl we xescheduled a time and replaced kic.r faucFts, 6) Bro;cen lawn faur.ets Un RprSZ 21, 1930 I received a caZl at 11;00 pm, Jndy from MorAtqomc>ry Design, he said the owners had a lot of wate: in their basement. After arxiving rt the hom4, 7 started to check various items over witki ,7ody and the hvmeowmer. We discovere8, the rear lawn fatxceti was found to have frozen and spli't open. This was a rtsult of the honteorvnex• not shutting o£f the stop & taaste ealve in the ntQChBnical room ind draining botli the valve and the lawn fducet. A note on this subject was baclt in December when we replacecl the pqlished brass fa.ucets, our plur.eber 3'on Gurnsev told the owners to disaonnect their gardan hosPs and to dxain zheir 1awt1 faucetse Antion taken: Af*er discnvering t:he prok,].em en P,pril 21, 1990 I told the oc,rner nat use their lawn f3ucet tzntil ;.t wa, replaced. The follow3ng Mvnday, I schec3uled a. pl.urrbez• here to replac.c the broY.exi ].awn fauce£, Tf you.have any questi.ons, please feel free to cal?. 9in ely{; Daniwl D. marris, C-?O DDM/kpm ,. ,??^ ` . 1 . .. . ? ? . ? .... ..?.?.._ ?? 1???. 5• vLo+ t,v ab ?ive. n-kt l'hm 11 Dea'r FIomeowner, & Valiey Pltambihg Co. 610 CREEN LANE - JORDAN, MINNESOTA 55352 Valley Plumbing Company, Inc. would lilce to congratulate You on the , purchase of your new hnme. In. order to givr: you better ser.vice and to eliminate any unnecessary service c1lls, we have put together a li.st of sug4e'stions that we ar.e sure you will find helpful. 1:;-OUTSIDt LAWN FAIICrTS 7 ' ...•.i':,+? ti These should b:r, shut ofi' and drained in the fall to prevent'.-r';^x?ky S freezing and breaking. ThErc- is a separatr.-: ,hut-off valve on tne inside oi the house for each :lawn faucet. Turn thi.s valve off and open the little drain on the sirle af the va].ve. I'heri go outside and open the J.awn faucet. In the spring, you can closr the uutside lawn faucet and opcn the inside va].ve for that faucet. A.LWl.tX.S. be sure to tighten the paclcinfi mat brlow the handle of the valbe. Whenever the valves are opened or closed, the packing nut sltioizld be tightened.' ?. '- 2.' HOSE BIBBS I'OR 47ASHING MACI3INI: '. . These valves will also need the paclcing nut tightened if they are clo'sed and opened again. 3. WATtR SOFTI:NERS i If we furnished 1 W.?'teS soi`tener for ycu, be sure to read the Homeowner' s Manual. ••i All softr_-ner brine tanlcs should be clc<,ned once a vear to prevent any dirt from getting into the softener head. ALWAYS OSE THE WHITE aOFTENER PLLLE'Pa. NEVER USE, ROCK SALT. Rock salt contains small amounts of sand, which in time will damage your softener. 4.. KITCI3t-N SINR AND LAVATORIES Everyone stores things under the kitchen sink and bathroom 1avs. We ask that you talce caution not to 1et your items 1ean against the drain:pipes, because they can get moved and could•develop a leak. • ? (over) ' ? / 67 ?G ;r?rD G?"/' ?i ?tfif /b1c)njr',-?(n?;,J 6Fs?-?j?37 ./??.?i?liT „?¢f/e?? C;- ??: i? +?-??--- ; ? , ? ? fG ? ?f/) ? ?r ii i 21l .? /!'C r?,l,? j l!'-l ?.'l? ?^-'?L%? ?-?C!.'C?L/?c. . ?7llJ' '' c•_.%?J / ? •'??: ? ?- -?? ?? z?r_ y/ _-???/ p/ .? ? ._ ?` ?: L???? -ri , ?;;? ?l _???-i "T?? ? G'c'' v ?C'?'=Cl ? "?? . i, . r` ="?`'Z G?l.'?? c?j? ???/1?,1=Lc'?? ?L'?l C?/ -? . ? y ?/ /'y? ?. /? . ? ?/" 7Z4,- ; ? V-?fri C(??y???? C?L' ?t i" ??LL-`' ,iC.r? ,?GL??? 7TCCi'>> •?C?" ) , ??'''¢-??<?-??' ??z??/? ,??,?.??c•.?? _ -- - n. - ------- _W"-_ G? ?R I ? J ?IL I!l??? ?§ W? *-07 `AM nR;.? 1`??' [. / ? 446, .?i S t? 1--= zAe'li?"L I&` LH 'T 6?.e ora?,+eRd carage ,..._... ?]..?r?.d ? `` ?? /y;? ?..cG°?? C•?i'.? ;?'?G' ?Gt?.E?J ?-4?Z-- 7, 'r , ???? ???i? , r? ? ? `` ?c? ? , , ? f?,,?. ,?? (?' ? ?_`, ` - ? !??'??,?f?'.? - li!9? '? ? QE f}f? eo C1 f;7 d U?s rl 'p r e L?'?v¢ei? ' < _--_--•--- - ? .; C"Z-/t ,;j?7. --- ?f1 ?l'?i .. ??C?C?/?i/? ?? ?? ry C '??`CJ?__ ..._ _ ._ . ??/-??`' ? ? ? ?'f??=1Z h C.`?.`.- . 4-1 a?? Ir C .? _?o-. ? ?--` yi9-9D---- ? 1A //1f.-?,? J) ?14?2(4CN ?s tt/G!"/rp ? ?/ . ?11V6 - ,. w/? i'f e(=/aol` ?Rk I?c ? : ?iEOi.!/1j1? ?il'???O•?f?'r?S ------ ? 1 ? . . ...ry......?- ?.._ ?R ,. ..:. ._. ..._ . : ? YN, .. .- ?_1 ; . _ _....... ---_ ...._... ? ;?. , %' ??? IZf ? r17 ? ? 1411eh/?'l?/v ulin?o ,2 ---- ?. t 51-7 -l,r. rc.E-? ?onac.4 ! ? ?f??7? ,??r??s?-??1.??7--? . _ lz?oelpe , --- .,.. a?- , ?_/?l-'r'? /-/?i/?'?' ?/??J 5ab ? - 14 F+ ?„? -* llel-- , ??- ? ? , , ? -.?..?.- ?ti?? ? ?? ? ? NAME: ? GRAND OAKS DEVELOPMENT COMPANY WARRANTY 11VORK ? ADDRESS: 61 a- IOD (1,? UJ n LG Cz Gr. CLOSING DATE: PHONE NUMBER: Home The following items require your attention: Item i work Qais - 4 6d ?a Homeowner Signature: d *""'? Date: White Copy Grand Oaks Development Yellow Copy Homeownera 3^• k ROBERT F. IHINGER, JR. Attorney at Law 6449 Lyndale Avenue South Richfield, Minnesota 55423 (612) 866-8431 April 25, 1999 Tom Montgomezy - Mary Ann Montgomery Montgomery Design and Build 3786 Windtree Drive Eagan, Minnesota 55123 Re: 698 Northbridge Court, Eagan, MN Pat and Julie Monahan Dear Mr. and Mrs. Montgomery: I have been retained by Pat and Julie Monahan to help resolve the situation regazding their defective homestead. I'm sure I do not need to itemize the problems they have had for the past 12 months with the property, but I'll hit the hiqh points anyway. Flooding occurred in seven separate incidents, due to your manufacturing defects, from the first day of closing to as recently as one week ago. These were caused by improper sealing of whirlpool and toilet, leaky pipes, and imptoper installation of the water softener drain. In addition, the lower level closet repeatedly flooded, every rainfall, due to improper installation of dxain tile, ox possibly just insufficient grading of the exterior wall. Over 33 items were defective or impropezly located and had to be replaced and/or relocated, including but not limited to: doors, walls, windows, floors, carpeting, sinks, faucets, drains, tile, mortar and grouting, electrical systems, the air conditioning unit, and a portion of the driveway. Mary Ann phrased it perfectly recently when she characterized the house as a"lemon". It was a disaster from the beginning, and the problems have not stopped appearing. It seems that my clients keep giving your people lists, and the lists keep getting lost before the work is completed. The current list of things that still need repair is three handwritten pages long. The Monahans have had to live with workmen coming through theiz home continuously for the past year; or worse, promising to appear and not showing up, even though the Monahan's had to make arxangements to accommodate those promises. Mrs. Monahan has been prevented from starting work and bringing in a separate income, which she has always had heretofore, because of the constant necessity to be at home for the workmen. Montgomery Design and Build April 25, 1990 Page 2 The Monahans have h3d tb bear an inordinate amount of uncleanliness and have borne a large share of the cleanup efforts, including the final cleanup prior to moving in, which had not been done by your workers. They have had to deal with recarpeting, reflooring, retiling, receilinging, restaining, and numerous other messy refurbishings, all because the job was inadequate to start with. Numerous misrepresentations have been made to the Monahan's over the past year including: statements involving the work that was to be done on the house prior to completion, the work that was actually completed, the repair work that was promised, and the fact that you claimed to be "a H.O.W. builder" yet theze does not appear to be any H.O.W. warranty covering the property. Mr. and Mxs. Monahan have reached the end of their patience, and want to resolve this situation immediately. They would prefer to resolve this situation without litigation, but will not hesitate to use the courts if other alternatives do not prove fruitful. They have already contacted various media representatives about covering their story. They think the Twin Cities residents would be very interested in reading about "Money Pit II" as most of their friends refer to the situation. They are planning to do what they can to see that no other families are put through the pain they have been subjected to. They have already told the truth to one family that was ready to purchase one of your homes, and it appears that family will now use another builder. They will probably do what they can to spread the truth some more this weekend at your two show houses in their neighborhood. I doubt the "Spring New Home Preview" will prove very successful this year, if people are informed about .the kinds of problems one of your very fitst Montgomery Design and Build homes produced. My clients do not intend to create any disturbance or to deviate from the truth in any way. They simply wish to exercise their lst Amendment right to free speech to prevent another family's potential tragedy. My clients' demands are simple and eminently fair. They want you to take back the house, compensate them for the costs of acquiring and moving to new property, and provide a modexate sum for the lies, lost income, pain and suffezing that they have been subjected to. They request payment of $215,000.00 for the value of the home they thought they had purchased, $19,000.60 in closing costs, $5,000.00 in moving costs, and $45,000.00 in intangible losses. These sums total $275,000.00, and would be due June 1, 1990. The Monahans will vacate the premises on oz before June 1, 1999, should this proposition be accepted. The mortgage currently against the pxoperty will be satisfied at Montgomery Design and Build April 25, 1990 Page 3 closing out of the proceeds of the aforementioned payment, so the property would be yours , free and clear, to fix and resell or level to the ground and start over on the lot, whichever you thought best for your professional xeputation. Please respond within the next week so that we may resolve these matters amicably if at all possible. My clients are very anxious to find a new home and will need as much time as you can give them in order to be out by our suggested June 3, 1990, date. Your advertising flyer contains the motto: "BUilding Dreams Together." In the case of the Monahans, the dream built into a nightmare. It is now time to make amends. , Kindest Regards, -,96e,r C_ ?a;, J , Robert F. Ihinger, Jr,( xc. Pat and Julie Monahan `9 t - ? ? ? 1' PERMIT City of Eagan Permit Type:Plumbing Permit Number:EA141182 Date Issued:02/24/2017 Permit Category:ePermit Site Address: 698 Northbridge Ct Lot:12 Block: 4 Addition: Hills Of Stonebridge PID:10-32990-04-120 Use: Description: Sub Type:Residential Work Type:Replace Description:Water Heater Meter Size Meter Type Manufacturer Serial Number Remote Number Line Size Comments:Please call Building Inspections at (651) 675-5675 to schedule a final inspection. Carbon monoxide detectors are required within 10 feet of all sleeping room openings in residential homes (Minnesota State Building Code). Fee Summary:PL - Permit Fee (WS &/or WH)$59.00 0801.4087 Surcharge-Fixed $1.00 9001.2195 $60.00 Total: I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Contractor:Owner:- Applicant - Bradley D Brodsho 698 Northbridge Ct Eagan MN 55123 (651) 456-5748 Champion Plumbing 3670 Dodd Rd., #100 Eagan MN 55123 (651) 365-1340 Applicant/Permitee: Signature Issued By: Signature PERMIT City of Eagan Permit Type:Building Permit Number:EA153018 Date Issued:11/14/2018 Permit Category:ePermit Site Address: 698 Northbridge Ct Lot:12 Block: 4 Addition: Hills Of Stonebridge PID:10-32990-04-120 Use: Description: Sub Type:Reroof Work Type:Replace Description:Does not include skylight(s) Census Code:434 - Residential Additions, Alterations Zoning: Square Feet:0 Occupancy: Construction Type: Comments:Please print pictures of ice and water protection and leave on site. Carbon monoxide detectors are required within 10 feet of all sleeping room openings in residential homes (Minnesota State Building Code). Valuation: 4,000.00 Fee Summary:BL - Base Fee $4K $103.25 0801.4085 Surcharge - Based on Valuation $4K $2.00 9001.2195 $105.25 Total: I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application and state that the information is correct and agree to comply with all applicable State of Minnesota Statutes and City of Eagan Ordinances. Contractor:Owner:- Applicant - Bradley D Brodsho 698 Northbridge Ct Eagan MN 55123 (651) 456-5748 Property Claim Solutions Llc 2005 Pin Oak Dr Eagan MN 55122 (651) 994-2028 Applicant/Permitee: Signature Issued By: Signature